[FIN] Traditional Mafia Double Dethy(Filler Round

Status
Not open for further replies.
Opening Post/Night 0 start
Messages
4,616
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,739
Double Dethy
A game for big brains :weirdpeep:


Host:
@Nessos
Coach: @novaselinenever
Players: 11

Setup said:
2 Sane Cops
2 Insane Cops
2 Paranoid Cops
2 Naive Cops
3 Mafia Goons
How to play/mechanics said:
Cops vs Goons

Cops trying to find Goons therefore they can Invest during the night. Cops doesn't know what kind of Cop they are (also death doesn't reveal).

Goons have a 24/7 Chat and a factional kill.
During Day Goons pretend to be Cops and use to give out fake results.

Day Phase are to discuss results and pick a Lynchtarget (plurality lynch).
There will always be a lynch.
(Equal Vote Count -> RNG lynch)

Game Starts with Night 0. In this Night 0 the faction kill is disabled.

Phase length: 24h
(may end Night sooner once all actions have been processed)

Sane -> Inno on Cops and Guilty on Goon
Insane -> Guilty on Cops and Inno on Goon
Paranoid -> Guilty on anyone
Naive -> Inno on anyone
Living playe:
1. @Salah Eddine
6. @oddoddfruit
8. @Beky
11. @Shion

Death Player:
7. @Samael, cop lynched Day 1
10. @RAIL_GUN, cop killed Night 1
3. @joby, goon lynched Day 2
5. @Hayumi, cop killed Night 2
9. @Fallen Prince, goon lynched Day 3
4. @Gambit, cop killed Night 3
2. @Rej, goon lynched Day 4





Night 0 has started
Day 1 will start once all cops send in their action.​
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,616
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,739
Its still Night 0.
Night -> No talking :weirdpeep:

Once all Cops send in their target, I will announce Day 1.​
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
Before we work out who can be what, I suggest we get all results in.

Beky, Innocent.
For D1 yes. Onwards we should make list and cross check it to determine who is what cop and if someone is lying.

Obv there is no way we can confirm one another without dying so wr should aim to confirm who is Sane cop.

I presume Mafia cant kill at night otherwise they would. That gives us an edge if we can confirm who is sane cop
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
For D1 yes. Onwards we should make list and cross check it to determine who is what cop and if someone is lying.

Obv there is no way we can confirm one another without dying so wr should aim to confirm who is Sane cop.

I presume Mafia cant kill at night otherwise they would. That gives us an edge if we can confirm who is sane cop
Insane Cop works just as well too. I think we should all keep our own lists as we go anyway, and keep this one as general as possible (for instance, I know by virtue of Gambit claiming Guilty on me he cannot be Sane, but the thread as a whole does not know that, so any list I post here will include him being Sane as a possibility. The only two sanities we will be eliminating today are Naive and Paranoid). I'll post what I have at the end of the day to correlate everything.
[automerge]1595956302[/automerge]
By the way, if we get all results in early enough how should we proceed with the lynch? I'm used to Dethy's having a kill night 0 so convention is almost always to no lynch but given the numbers here we would be trading a lynch for a night kill which clearly isn't worth it. We can either go completely random or just lynch whomever has the most investigations on them, or maybe whomever has the least? On that note, I wonder if we could end day early too. Obviously if we know our lynch and have all our info in the thread there isn't really much else to be done but go to night, but again this is operating under the premise that this game should be played like a Dethy rather than a normal Mafia game
 
Last edited:

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
Insane Cop works just as well too. I think we should all keep our own lists as we go anyway, and keep this one as general as possible (for instance, I know by virtue of Gambit claiming Guilty on me he cannot be Sane, but the thread as a whole does not know that, so any list I post here will include him being Sane as a possibility. The only two sanities we will be eliminating today are Naive and Paranoid). I'll post what I have at the end of the day to correlate everything.
I get what you comming from. IMO onwards we shouldnt be so open about invest results. Mafia prolly bets on it so they can bullshit their way among us.

Keep your results and claim only if nessecary
 

Rej

Messages
5,034
Reaction score
13,132
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,712
You guys really wanna throw all results in? Doesn't it help mafia to know who is which cop?
I mean we can talk about our targets and investigate them throughout the day, but is revealing the result really good?

My target was oddodd.
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
You guys really wanna throw all results in? Doesn't it help mafia to know who is which cop?
I mean we can talk about our targets and investigate them throughout the day, but is revealing the result really good?

My target was oddodd.
D1 it is.
Onwards no

And i just saw mafia has night kill.
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
By saying our results we can gauge what will be the reason for someones death.

Example i got inno on Fallen
I can be a lot of things.
But if he is Mafia i can be few things.

In that aspect we can narrow it
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
I get what you comming from. IMO onwards we shouldnt be so open about invest results. Mafia prolly bets on it so they can bullshit their way among us.

Keep your results and claim only if nessecary
Ah, I disagree on this. I feel like we absolutely need to claim results in order to solve the game. If you haven't played a dethy before, the idea behind it is that it can be resolved by using logic and deduction to eliminate possible sanities until you're left with clear outliers. It's not always a 100% thing but town tend to win more often than not using that. By not claiming results I don't really know how to go about playing it. It's actually almost as complicated to play for scum too because they have to guess where the "gaps" will be.
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
Ah, I disagree on this. I feel like we absolutely need to claim results in order to solve the game. If you haven't played a dethy before, the idea behind it is that it can be resolved by using logic and deduction to eliminate possible sanities until you're left with clear outliers. It's not always a 100% thing but town tend to win more often than not using that. By not claiming results I don't really know how to go about playing it. It's actually almost as complicated to play for scum too because they have to guess where the "gaps" will be.
You play it as vanilla vs mafia.
This early invests are null. So no point playing bases on em
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
By not telling our results you keep mafia in the dark. And then on Day X you force everyone to give their results
Mafia is bound to fuck it up and thats how you catch em
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom