[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 5 - Wano Hype!

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

Nessos said:
If thats end up being the case then they are the worst scumteam ever. Not saying it is Impossible.

It sure is odd Gambit tried saving Drago, though.

Nessos · Feb 28, 2020

Stray Cat said:
It sure is odd Gambit tried saving Drago, though.

Also my thought. So if Gamit, Beky and Drago are a scumteam I would put my bets on Drago having an important scumrole.

So if Drago flips Mafioboss we can be almost certain Gambit amd Beky are scum too.

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

Nessos said:
Also my thought. So if Gamit, Beky and Drago are a scumteam I would put my bets on Drago having an important scumrole.

So if Drago flips Mafioboss we can be almost certain Gambit amd Beky are scum too.

It's possible he even investigates innocent which is why Beky could have wanted to have people checked first. Which is another odd thing since checking players is oftenly useless due to invest immunities and other passives.

Gambit · Feb 28, 2020

Lol nice try. I ain't gonna save a scum buddy so blatantly.

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

Gambit said:
Lol nice try. I ain't gonna save a scum buddy so blatantly.

That's what scum would say.

Nessos · Feb 28, 2020

Gambit said:
Lol nice try. I ain't gonna save a scum buddy so blatantly.

You will.doesn't explain why are you defending Drago.
[automerge]1582911346[/automerge]

Nessos said:
You will.doesn't explain why are you defending Drago.

You still doesn't explain...
[automerge]1582911997[/automerge]
I am quite sure there are more player then Gambit, Stray and me!

No lynch is no option and not even 100min to go. Time to stand up from your backseat and Play!

Votecount

Rej said:
Dragomir: 3 (FELI D AEROM, Nessos, Stray Cat)
Stray Cat: 2 (Dragomir, Gambit)
Nessos: 1 (joby)
Waindo: 1 (AL)
Gambit: 1 (Michelle)

Jinri · Feb 28, 2020

Drago seems like a good information lynch. Along with a night'd worth of information, it'll shed light on a few players here and their own reasoning that they've brought up so far.

Vote lynch dragomir

Beky · Feb 28, 2020

Jinri said:
I don't agree with any rationale when it comes to lynching anyone. They're all too weak (even by D1 standards). And nothing has popped out at me so far. I will patiently wait for D2 to begin my hunting.

Jinri said:
Drago seems like a good information lynch. Along with a night'd worth of information, it'll shed light on a few players here and their own reasoning that they've brought up so far.

Vote lynch dragomir

Beky · Feb 28, 2020

I really don't like the look of this

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

@Nessos Gambit is awfully quiet now. Looks like our theory might be true.

Jinri · Feb 28, 2020

Now, I don't buy that Drago is scum, but there's not many better options. And I don't mind mislynching on D1 (better than no lynching of course).

Beky · Feb 28, 2020

Jinri said:
Now, I don't buy that Drago is scum, but there's not many better options. And I don't mind mislynching on D1 (better than no lynching of course).

If you don't believe him to be scum why then lynch someone that can by your words be a townie? For information?

Let's presume you do lynch him , what info do you hope getting

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

@Beky why so afraid of mislynches btw? You do realize even if we investigated players at night the possibility is there the results aren't even accurate due to Framers and invest immunity, right? Kills and lynches are the only solid reveal.
[automerge]1582914206[/automerge]
Why is it everytime I generate some heat in the discussion people log off :weirdpeep:

? Feels so lonely here...people gotta play...

Nessos · Feb 28, 2020

Low activity in the last 30min of a DP feels so wrong.

Samael · Feb 28, 2020

Sorry for being late. I’ll read what I can, comeback with reads and thoughts on things of course and as far as a lynch vote? If I deem someone enough that’s where my vote will go if not I’ll more than likely start voting next phase.

Beky · Feb 28, 2020

Stray Cat said:
@Beky why so afraid of mislynches btw? You do realize even if we investigated players at night the possibility is there the results aren't even accurate due to Framers and invest immunity, right? Kills and lynches are the only solid reveal.

We are already at disadvantage in normal games, this game we are at even bigger disadvantage due to lack of info sharing.
If you keep miss lynching people left and right and mafia getting a kill per night you will see town this game drop before D4
IDK how is this a hard concept for you guys to understand. It really isn't that hard to figure it out. Ya'll say you want info from the lynch. I said at the start of this game than when miss lynch happens ALMOST ALWAYS another townie gets miss lynched next day bcs she sheeped a bad wagon

Considering all of that the game plan should be to be conservative with lynches and keep the numbers up

Nessos · Feb 28, 2020

Stray Cat said:
@Beky why so afraid of mislynches btw? You do realize even if we investigated players at night the possibility is there the results aren't even accurate due to Framers and invest immunity, right? Kills and lynches are the only solid reveal

Not to mention this ain't ToS. I mean even without "No claiming rule" you can claim anything.

This is trad, trad is based on reads you get from accusations. Roles are Just ro Help someone form reads. Trad games doesn't focus so much on roles like Reg or ToS.

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

Beky said:
We are already at disadvantage in normal games, this game we are at even bigger disadvantage due to lack of info sharing.
If you keep miss lynching people left and right and mafia getting a kill per night you will see town this game drop before D4
IDK how is this a hard concept for you guys to understand. It really isn't that hard to figure it out. Ya'll say you want info from the lynch. I said at the start of this game than when miss lynch happens ALMOST ALWAYS another townie gets miss lynched next day bcs she sheeped a bad wagon

Considering all of that the game plan should be to be conservative with lynches and keep the numbers up

Yeah, but you are completely ignoring there is an actual case on our lynch target. And Gambit's straight up defense, then suddenly becoming quiet raises some flags.

Nessos · Feb 28, 2020

Btw thats also the reason why every tradgame starts with DP and not with a night phase like Reg or ToS.

So wasting a DP with a no lynch is Always a bad thing in trad.

Stray Cat · Feb 28, 2020

Like...even if Drago flips Town, this defense can be seen as him saving a Townie because he knows he is Town due to being scum and trying to get Town cred. But that doesn't explain why he deflected to me since I am Town, so I think Drago is actual scum.

[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 5 - Wano Hype!

Sengoku & Garp vs King & Queen

Geezers win extreme high diff

Geezers win high diff

Geezers win mid diff

Geezers win low diff

Geezers win extreme low diff

Geezers lose any diff (explain in PM)

More options

Recent threadmarks

Stray Cat

Nessos

Stray Cat

Gambit

Stray Cat

Nessos

Jinri

Beky

Nancy <3

Beky

Nancy <3

Stray Cat

Jinri

Beky

Nancy <3

Stray Cat

Nessos

Samael

Beky

Nancy <3

Nessos

Stray Cat

Nessos

Stray Cat

Recent threadmarks