[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 19: Baruk Khazad!

[Beky]

Watcher can also cause potential mislynches in this particular circumstance:

Watcher +Doctor exist, Mafia Strongarm and Doctor both visit the one the Watcher is watching

The target ends up dead and then Town might lynch the Doctor.

Like i said, i don't think mafia will go for Strongman exactly bcs 3 roles can snatch him easily wheres GF doesn't have any downsides

 

[~UwU~]

Picking Ninja does what? Nothing really except it lets Cop get you

Ninja makes it so Tracker and Watcher doesn't see you.

Godfather however can pass as Vanilla, can't be caught by Cop or Watcher or Tracker nor can Doc or RB cuck him

A GF would be seen by the Tracker or Watcher.

 

[Beky]

Ninja makes it so Tracker and Watcher doesn't see you.

But a Cop can

A GF would be seen by the Tracker or Watcher.

Indeed, but unless he performs NK he can't be caught

 

[Beky]

To me this is no brainer

Double invest is far superior to RB or Doc. And Watcher/Tracker can snag GF a cop can't

 

[~UwU~]

But a Cop can

Not in the act of performing the kill. Who the night kill hits makes no difference for the Cop unless they're the target.

It's a completely different kind of investigation

Also Tracker/Watcher can't catch the Mafia that aren't performing the night kill

 

[Rej]

you guys forget that the blocker is a blocker, not a roleblocker, he isnt blocking the role, he is blocking the kill

this is nuts since he cant block the invest

I vote cop and blocker

the chances are low that they pick godfather and rather pick something more proactive

vote cop
vote blocker

 

[~UwU~]

Double invest is far superior to RB or Doc. And Watcher/Tracker can snag GF a cop can't

Cop can snatch the Goons who aren't performing night kill, Watcher/Tracker can't.

See how easily I turned that around

 

[ZFR]

Vote Count

Cop 5: @A famous historian, @Gambit, @Mango Senpai, @Juliet, @Rej
Doctor 3: @A famous historian, @Pepper, @Mango Senpai
Tracker 3: @Pepper, @Juliet, @Beky
Blocker 3: @Gambit, @Nessos, @Rej
Watcher 2: @Nessos, @Beky

Spoiler: Votes

I move the motion that I get the dwarf goodies and that gambit gets the rope.
[automerge]1626452486[/automerge]
I vote cop and doctor

Looks like.my vote will be cop and blocker.

Yes just discussing though I'll give you my vote now anyways
Vote Doctor and Tracker

Vote Cop + Doc

Vote Cop and Tracker

What do you guys think about cop and tracker? The more invests the better.

you guys forget that the blocker is a blocker, not a roleblocker, he isnt blocking the role, he is blocking the kill

this is nuts since he cant block the invest

I vote cop and blocker

the chances are low that they pick godfather and rather pick something more proactive

vote cop
vote blocker

Spoiler: Tags

1. @Gambit
2. @Mango Senpai
3. @Ekkologix
4. @A famous historian
5. @~UwU~
6. @T-Pein™
7. @Pepper
8. @Beky
9. @Nessos
10. @Fujitora
11. @Juliet
12. @Waindo
13. @Rej

 

[Rej]

also blocker is more likely to hit a shooter through poE than the doctor protecting towncore when mafia can shoot outside of the towncore and they can make clever and pushy plays as a 3-man team vs 10 towns

 

[Rej]

Vote Count

Cop 4: @A famous historian, @Gambit, @Mango Senpai, @Juliet
Doctor 3: @A famous historian, @Pepper, @Mango Senpai
Tracker 3: @Pepper, @Juliet, @Beky
Blocker 2: @Gambit, @Nessos
Watcher 2: @Nessos, @Beky

Spoiler: Tags

1. @Gambit
2. @Mango Senpai
3. @Ekkologix
4. @A famous historian
5. @~UwU~
6. @T-Pein™
7. @Pepper
8. @Beky
9. @Nessos
10. @Fujitora
11. @Juliet
12. @Waindo
13. @Rej

I voted...I hope xd

 

[~UwU~]

the chances are low that they pick godfather and rather pick something more proactive

By your own admission you think the chance of a Strongarm appearing is greater than 33%, yet you want a Blocker hmmm...

 

[ZFR]

I voted...I hope xd

Yes, fixed now.

 

[Beky]

Cop can snatch the Goons who aren't performing night kill, Watcher/Tracker can't.

See how easily I turned that around

I guess we will agree to disagree.
But i personally believe Mafia will go for GF to deep wolf it and if we go Cop-Doc/RB we won't have a way to catch him
If mafia goes Ninja then yes Cop is usefull but bcs Cop is usefull and hit 100% is why i think it is a risky pick for mafia
Strongman while strong is same as Cop

Cop is just too strong in this scenario for mafia to gamble and go anything but GF when they are first pick

 

[Beky]

Bear in mind i am 3 mojitos deep and i could be seeing things this night

 

[~UwU~]

I guess we will agree to disagree.
But i personally believe Mafia will go for GF to deep wolf it and if we go Cop-Doc/RB we won't have a way to catch him
If mafia goes Ninja then yes Cop is usefull but bcs Cop is usefull and hit 100% is why i think it is a risky pick for mafia
Strongman while strong is same as Cop

Cop is just too strong in this scenario for mafia to gamble and go anything but GF when they are first pick

Or maybe Mafia picked Ninja and hopes to convince people Cop is a bad choice.

 

[Beky]

Or maybe Mafia picked Ninja and hopes to convince people Cop is a bad choice.

true true
I am still at 2 invests but i'll trade watcher for Cop, better than Doc or RB

 

[~UwU~]

Vote Cop and Tracker @ZFR

 

[Beky]

Vote 1 - Cop
Vote 2 - Tracker

If i am right and i believe i am 2 invests is best

 

[ZFR]

Vote Count

Cop 7: @A famous historian, @Gambit, @Mango Senpai, @Juliet, @Rej, @~UwU~, @Beky
Tracker 4: @Pepper, @Juliet, @Beky, @~UwU~
Doctor 3: @A famous historian, @Pepper, @Mango Senpai
Blocker 3: @Gambit, @Nessos, @Rej
Watcher 1: @Nessos,

Spoiler: Votes

I move the motion that I get the dwarf goodies and that gambit gets the rope.
[automerge]1626452486[/automerge]
I vote cop and doctor

Looks like.my vote will be cop and blocker.

Yes just discussing though I'll give you my vote now anyways
Vote Doctor and Tracker

Vote Cop + Doc

Vote Cop and Tracker

What do you guys think about cop and tracker? The more invests the better.

you guys forget that the blocker is a blocker, not a roleblocker, he isnt blocking the role, he is blocking the kill

this is nuts since he cant block the invest

I vote cop and blocker

the chances are low that they pick godfather and rather pick something more proactive

vote cop
vote blocker

Vote Cop and Tracker @ZFR

Vote 1 - Cop
Vote 2 - Tracker

If i am right and i believe i am 2 invests is best

Spoiler: Tags

1. @Gambit
2. @Mango Senpai
3. @Ekkologix
4. @A famous historian
5. @~UwU~
6. @T-Pein™
7. @Pepper
8. @Beky
9. @Nessos
10. @Fujitora
11. @Juliet
12. @Waindo
13. @Rej

 

[Nessos]

Picking Ninja does what? Nothing really except it lets Cop get you

Ninja is as powerful as strongarm in this game.
Are Team Mafia and picked Ninja?

Tracker/Watcher is superior in any way than Cop

Thats again wrong.
Tracker is inferior to Cop. Both Tracker and Cop go for scummy player Cop will get guilty on anyone Tracker will only get result in the one performing a kill.

=> Cop >>>> Tracker