[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 5 - Wano Hype!

[Stray Cat]

@Dragomir why are you asking such a weird question?

 

[Nessos]

@Dragomir why are you asking such a weird question?

Its no weird question. He is completly right lynching provides 0 info.


He was brandmarked as scum. If you were in a scumteam with him would you still support him or were you afraid that you get in the list for trying to protect him?

On the other hand if AL is Town we can expect there might be scum halfass defending him trying to get Town creds for his unavoidable lynch.

 

[Dragomir]

That kinda info a lynch provides?

So just to find out if he's scum or town?

To find out if he is scum or town

If you're gonna do that, then why not lynch anybody? Wouldn't you want to find out if I am scum or town, or if Wai is scum or town? To say this is for info and not have anything besides the pure basics that all lynches contain is asinine. Every lynch provides that, what would be info are stuff that this particular lynch provides outside the basics.

 

[Nessos]

We shouldn't set up lynch target now.
Still 44h to go.

 

[AL.]

So you were joking when you said you were Town?

nope

I'm sensing contradictions there, Al .

explain and I'll debunk

Anyway, I think an Al snack will be good this DP. Give a lot of info on stuff.

you're trying to push me without damm reason flower

 

[Dragomir]

@Dragomir why are you asking such a weird question?

Because what you said was weird as shit. You're lynching someone to find out if they're town or scum? That's what every lynch does. It's not an info lynch unless it provides something outside the general stuff.
[automerge]1582758699[/automerge]
Sounds to me like you just wanted to call it an info lynch in order to strengthen your case but that's not gonna work.
[automerge]1582758906[/automerge]
From what I saw, the 2 main reasons for why Al is being sussed is...

1. He has been talkative and aggressive.
2. He was defensive when you guys tried saying that him being talkative ad aggressive was bad.

And as a bonus: an info lynch.

I'm having trouble agreeing with any of that.

 

[AL.]

joking while making people talk is being aggressive?? ok

3 posts of debunking shades is being defensive?? ok

I m utterly lost for words seeing this nonsense

if you guys wanna accuse me then make good god damm case against me rather than using nonsense until then piss off

 

[Dragomir]

joking while making people talk is being aggressive?? ok

3 posts of debunking shades is being defensive?? ok

I m utterly lost for words seeing this nonsense

if you guys wanna accuse me then make good god damm case against me rather than using nonsense until then piss off

I'm not accusing you. Just listing the reasons against you and saying that I don't agree :tiredpepe

 

[AL.]

I'm not accusing you. Just listing the reasons against you and saying that I don't agree :tiredpepe

I don't think I mentioned anyone specific drago

 

[Dragomir]

I don't think I mentioned anyone specific drago

I know. I just think it included me since you said that after I made the post.

Anyway, Flower, scum. Agree or disagree?

 

[Hayumi]

Omg guys I got second place in the talent show!!! Seems like I missed a little let me read up.

 

[AL.]

Anyway, Flower, scum. Agree or disagree?

I view her as scum but more then that I m not liking nessos

he is coming after I said he was being lazy
[automerge]1582760544[/automerge]
coming after me
[automerge]1582760600[/automerge]

Omg guys I got second place in the talent show!!! Seems like I missed a little let me read up.

congrats hayumi

 

[Dragomir]

Omg guys I got second place in the talent show!!! Seems like I missed a little let me read up.

That's awesome! What did you do?
[automerge]1582760805[/automerge]

I view her as scum but more then that I m not liking nessos

he is coming after I said he was being lazy
[automerge]1582760544[/automerge]
coming after me
[automerge]1582760600[/automerge]

congrats hayumi

I don't see how that shows anything about him.

 

[Hayumi]

I view her as scum but more then that I m not liking nessos

he is coming after I said he was being lazy
[automerge]1582760544[/automerge]
coming after me
[automerge]1582760600[/automerge]

congrats hayumi

That's awesome! What did you do?
[automerge]1582760805[/automerge]

I don't see how that shows anything about him.

Thanks guys! I sang lol. Anyways so I see Al is being pressured?? That's interesting

 

[AL.]

I don't see how that shows anything about him.

I think he is doing a tit for tat maybe but yea its sounds foolish
[automerge]1582761278[/automerge]

Thanks guys! I sang lol. Anyways so I see Al is being pressured?? That's interesting

what are your thoughts on the situation??

 

[Hayumi]

I think he is doing a tit for tat maybe but yea its sounds foolish
[automerge]1582761278[/automerge]

what are your thoughts on the situation??

Um I can understand why some people that know your usual gameplay well being a little sus if you are changing things up, but Stray Cat's reasoning is a little off to me. Like at some point they said that you were being too defensive, but like if you are genuinely town of course you have the right to get defensive when people start pressing you based off of meh statements tbh. Not sure how I feel about anyone right now as making full on judgements is a little to much at this point in this game imo. But I've had people question me in a very similar fashion to the way Stray Cat was/ is to you and that person ended up being maf in a previous game where meanwhile I was town. But it's way too early for me to make reads right now tbh.

 

[Dragomir]

But I've had people question me in a very similar fashion to the way Stray Cat was/ is to you and that person ended up being maf in a previous game where meanwhile I was town.

Are you talking about me?

 

[Stray Cat]

Because what you said was weird as shit. You're lynching someone to find out if they're town or scum? That's what every lynch does. It's not an info lynch unless it provides something outside the general stuff.
[automerge]1582758699[/automerge]
Sounds to me like you just wanted to call it an info lynch in order to strengthen your case but that's not gonna work.
[automerge]1582758906[/automerge]
From what I saw, the 2 main reasons for why Al is being sussed is...

1. He has been talkative and aggressive.
2. He was defensive when you guys tried saying that him being talkative ad aggressive was bad.

And as a bonus: an info lynch.

I'm having trouble agreeing with any of that.

Maybe you missed that I voiced suspicion on Michelle earlier because of her defending Al to some degree? Or are you ignoring this on purpose to paint me as scum?
[automerge]1582764004[/automerge]

I know. I just think it included me since you said that after I made the post.

Anyway, Flower, scum. Agree or disagree?

And then there is this. Trying to get a wagon rolling to save Al or something? You guys buddies?

 

[Hayumi]

Maybe you missed that I voiced suspicion on Michelle earlier because of her defending Al to some degree? Or are you ignoring this on purpose to paint me as scum?

I mean to be fair your reasoning for being sus of Al based off of him being too "aggressive" and then questioning/sussing him again for getting understandably defensive at your random claims comes across as weak basis at best tbh. So you can sit here and defend your own reasoning but it isn't ok for Michelle to make some statements that "defend" another player? It's way too early for you to jump on people out the gate and want a rando ass lynch when Al could very likely be town and you yourself scum. But you yourself would obviously know that and would jump at an opportunity to "info" lynch someone you know is town

 

[Stray Cat]

I mean to be fair your reasoning for being sus of Al based off of him being too "aggressive" and then questioning/sussing him again for getting understandably defensive at your random claims comes across as weak basis at best tbh. So you can sit here and defend your own reasoning but it isn't ok for Michelle to make some statements that "defend" another player? It's way too early for you to jump on people out the gate and want a rando ass lynch when Al could very likely be town and you yourself scum. But you yourself would obviously know that and would jump at an opportunity to "info" lynch someone you know is town

That would require me being scum which I'm not. Have you not paid attention to anything? Al is clearly fishy. Just like the situation revolving around his case.