[FIN] Regular Mafia Round 10 - American High School 2 - JoJo Version

Who shall be expelled today?


  • Total voters
    5
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
4,617
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,740
One of my top suspects is Rej.
He teamed up with Law to bote Stray smelled like casting Town vs Town.

Also his "Waindo is Town" post after Waindo posted a single time smelled like TMI. (Especiay after figuring out Waindo and Rej not in the same friendchat).


Jojo Highschool is the best...
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rej
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302
As a set of fresh eyes, why do you reckon he was lynched?
AL. claims that his posts were too "TMI." A famous historian didn't elaborate, but apparently was convinced by the lie that Stray informed him of--Ryu caught a lie. Stray seems to think he was avoiding them and trying to sneakily vote them. I'm not sure about Gambit.

It was, really, for no good reason. It seems like people reached for reasons to lynch him due to the lack of information.
 
Messages
861
Reaction score
1,097
Points
5,400
Salty Doubloons
1,929
Vote Lynch Ryu Kishi

Ryu is not looking good. He said he suspected Trafalgar for knowing that people in a friend's chat have to be active during the dp to chat during the np which I didn't see anything suspicious about it and Ryu said Trafalgar followed Rej with a vote on Stray when Trafalgar never followed Rej on a vote. Stray also said there was an outed scum last day saying Ryu caught Trafalgar and Rej lying but this was never explained.
 
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302
One of my top suspects is Rej.
He teamed up with Law to bote Stray smelled like casting Town vs Town.

Also his "Waindo is Town" post after Waindo posted a single time smelled like TMI. (Especiay after figuring out Waindo and Rej not in the same friendchat).


Jojo Highschool is the best...
Why didn't you vote yesterday if this is what you felt?
 
Messages
861
Reaction score
1,097
Points
5,400
Salty Doubloons
1,929
He seemed scummy. And sure enough he was just a funny guy
Just having to read back on day 1 you said where was an outed scum and Stray said Ryu caught Trafalgar and Rej lying and your vote looked like you voted Trafalgar after Stray quoted you and you never mentioned Trafalgar was scummy.
 
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
1,475
Points
6,300
Salty Doubloons
2,134
...
Talk to me about non-Law voters.
Let's see Waindo and Juliet got modblocked for lack of posts which of course doesn't mean they're town but my impression is that they would've at least got the minimum post if they weren't
Rej I find odd for similar reasons that Nessos does but I also feel if they were maf they wouldn't support someone so openly when they only posted once.
Ryu & Naomi seem alright for now
Everyone else I'd have to wait and see
 
Messages
1,097
Reaction score
1,544
Points
6,300
Salty Doubloons
2,009
Just having to read back on day 1 you said where was an outed scum and Stray said Ryu caught Trafalgar and Rej lying and your vote looked like you voted Trafalgar after Stray quoted you and you never mentioned Trafalgar was scummy.
I did. He implied I had no friends. Which is wrong. His passive aggressive stance led me to believe he was scum
 
Messages
149
Reaction score
406
Points
2,200
Salty Doubloons
649
Somebody attacked me and somebody healed me last night. Whoever is the healer, thank you!
As someone who was highly suspected last dp I have no idea why someone would attack you and why another wpuld even waste a heal on you, this is worse.
Been mulling over Papa Rak for over a minute, I haven't seen anything I like so far from his contribution. Felt like he was using our little interactions just to get some posts in. Not very fond of that.

Another post of him asking "why X was getting voted" pinged me, not ready to disclose why at the moment lolol
as far as I can remember he usually sticks with this attitude when he is scum
What’s your alignment?

I would never attack you.
why is this giving me 3rd/ indeendent vibes ?
Not a big fan of Typo. Found that late push and vote on AL to be very meh, the reasoning was pretty bland. It felt like a statement vote with Law's lynch being written on the wall, rather than actually a genuine late suspicion and an attempt at doing something productive.
I was right on Law, I knew it, I understand this could be seen as if I am scum and actually know better than mere townies but ehhh it was a bit more clearer to me that he is town considering our group chat just pike the case with you and AL, I see neither much contribution from him here other than a push on Law who was clean in my eyes nor his usual play. I am not fully trusting you either, you vouch for him, ok I won’t be on his back until further notice.
Nessos, I agree with you on that

as for Rej ? Like, I do remember playing/hosting a game where Rej was town and I can say that he is not playing like that, his approaches and playstyle were more like Law’s, frankly that’s why he gets suspected usually but this time it’s different. mafia or 3rd at best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Messages
149
Reaction score
406
Points
2,200
Salty Doubloons
649
Oh and Juliet, the usual shady playstyle, nothing to prove this tbh but I am kinda confident she is not town. I might wanna hear from the people online their opinion on this ?
 
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
4,314
Points
7,200
Salty Doubloons
2,726
I'm gonna unvote. See what else develops

Unvote
 
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302
I did. He implied I had no friends. Which is wrong. His passive aggressive stance led me to believe he was scum
Ah, so it was for no good reason like I thought. :blobthinkhappy:
as for Rej ? Like, I do remember playing/hosting a game where Rej was town and I can say that he is not playing like that, his approaches and playstyle were more like Law’s, frankly that’s why he gets suspected usually but this time it’s different. mafia or 3rd at best.
Oh and Juliet, the usual shady playstyle, nothing to prove this tbh but I am kinda confident she is not town. I might wanna hear from the people online their opinion on this ?
What is it about their styles that's making you suspicious of them this game?
 

novaselinenever

Best Dad!
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
3,995
Points
5,300
Salty Doubloons
19,359
AL. claims that his posts were too "TMI." A famous historian didn't elaborate, but apparently was convinced by the lie that Stray informed him of--Ryu caught a lie. Stray seems to think he was avoiding them and trying to sneakily vote them. I'm not sure about Gambit.

It was, really, for no good reason. It seems like people reached for reasons to lynch him due to the lack of information.
What does that tell you about them?
There ia not motivation, they just feel the wagon. Oh my god, I love that rhyme.. It's only a matter of utilizing time..
There is always a motivation for an action. Was it to save someone, was it to put an easy vote into the board? Who do you think amongst them was "feeling" the wagon?
As someone who was highly suspected last dp I have no idea why someone would attack you and why another wpuld even waste a heal on you, this is worse.
Why wouldn't a vig attack a highly suspected person? Why did you assume it must be scum?
as far as I can remember he usually sticks with this attitude when he is scum
Oh that's good to hear. What do you think about him?
I was right on Law, I knew it, I understand this could be seen as if I am scum and actually know better than mere townies but ehhh it was a bit more clearer to me that he is town considering our group chat just pike the case with you and AL, I see neither much contribution from him here other than a push on Law who was clean in my eyes nor his usual play. I am not fully trusting you either, you vouch for him, ok I won’t be on his back until further notice.
Nessos, I agree with you on that
Lol what is with AL & I in your group chat discussions? What do you think was scummy about his push on Law, couldn't have been a mistaken townie? Even though I voted Nessos, I suspected Law a little bit as well and I'm definitely town lol.

I'm not vouching for him, I'm sharing my thoughts and read on him using both the thread and our interaction in the group chat as well as my rat theory. I'm always open for discussion about him especially since it's just a lean town rather than someone I'm locking Town such as Naomi.
 
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302
What does that tell you about them?
There is likely a scum among that group. A D1 mislynch usually features one. Though it becomes a debate of "whose reason was worst?" I think the relevant question is "who was in the middle the most?" The pusher is likely to not be scum because they naturally come under suspicion for being scum, but the weakest reasoner is likely to be seen as sheeping scum, which makes it unlikely on their end as well. So I believe that the Goldilocks zone is what we're looking for here. Of course, we have to take general reads into consideration as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom