[FIN] Traditional Mafia A simple game

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okosan

Okosan

Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
Okosan said:
Coooo? (Wtf are these posts? First off you're hard pushing the fact that the seer HAS to have checked one of you 3 when they very much didn't have to. In fact if Okosan was the seer he wouldn't have checked you at all. He would've checked one of his null reads as to provide direction, and he could push you more today to get more reads. Second, you're trying to use the fact that the seer hasn't revealed yet to confirm yourself? That itself is immensely scummy because A) It sounds like you're trying to get the seer to claim early instead of letting them decide whether whatever info they have is useful. And B) It's a perfect setup for you to say the seer is lying if they do actually come out with info that you are scum)

Coo? (Overall these posts feel horrendous to Okosan)
[automerge]1571160819[/automerge]
Coooooo! (Also question for you guys. Is Misty the type of player who would blatantly kill someone suspecting her as mafia or no?)
Click to expand...
Cooo! Coo! (Oops Okosan forgot to: )

[Vote Lynch Beky]
 
MistyCat

MistyCat

Messages
645
Reaction score
4,242
Points
3,500
Salty Doubloons
18,412
I m not gonna be around for this dp anymore guys. Had a horrible panic attack, just got back from the hospital, it s 2 am and I seriously just want it to be over
 
A famous historian

A famous historian

Messages
1,097
Reaction score
1,544
Points
6,300
Salty Doubloons
2,009
Last edited:
A famous historian

A famous historian

Messages
1,097
Reaction score
1,544
Points
6,300
Salty Doubloons
2,009
Last edited:
Trafalgar Law

Trafalgar Law

Messages
1,915
Reaction score
2,972
Points
2,950
Salty Doubloons
2,063
@Waindo what do you think about Gambit's play ?
[automerge]1571293868[/automerge]
It seems like scums wanna keep Misty and GU alive , feeling like we r heading in the wrong direction..
I'll go with my instinct....
Vote Lynch Gambit
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Gambit

Gambit

Messages
15,332
Reaction score
45,329
Points
33,800
Salty Doubloons
644
Waindo said:
I beg to differ, he can be sneaky as fuck. I would think that you're buddying with him, but both you and me sus GU as well so I guess that makes you clear for now? Does it?
Click to expand...
Aside from scum hunting, you should also pacify the situation in town hunting.. Whilst scum hunting a lot harder, the former hunting shouldn't be treated as anything different. How the player react to such accusations and how he/she positions himself in the game.. This includes, but not limited to taking a stand, bringing progress, moving the phase, and above all, not throwing scummy defense against their accuser.. Both Beky and Zemmi did that.. Although Zemmi, I couldn't entirely read her because of the lesser games I played against her.. She thought me how to play mafia and there's a fine line which separates my respect and fear of her posts. A lil bias but looking back, she wasn't right about Beky.... She sus Misty (now Juliet) hardly, and I am beginning to sus her now, too.
Waindo said:
You don't see anything strange in that whole convo vs Misty? Misty said that she was important, I doubt that she's the seer since I doubt that she would do such a mistake right of the bat in a setup like this, but she could be a Vanilla like us. Vanillas are an important role in this game. We're all important.
Click to expand...
At first, I was tryna understand what her purpose was for telling us that.. More like a normal d1 chat where all of us are expected to fluff and bluff.. But then again, I could be wrong... Seems to me that she actually was the one who wanted to out the seer... Setting up whoever will click the bait and claim eventually...
Waindo said:
You don't find Beky asking for a claim right of the bat as strange? Well I think that Beky wanted to lowkey implant us with the idea that she's a seer and pinball the suspicion to Misty with that claim request. I call BS, Beky is an experienced player and wouldn't so hastily imply that he's a seer (if he really was a seer) D1 in a Vanilla game where that role is the only Town role with night actions.
Click to expand...
Welp, he was not planning or setting up the oiting of the seer.. He was debating with Misty why she would claim important... He was an understandable reaction why not claim instead simce she alrdy claimed to be important.. But the lady was stubborn enough and kept stalling us... She kinda tricked us all the way to 2 mislynches and I am beginning to lose patience and motivation to continue this.. 1 more mislynch and we doomed.. That is if you're town.. But I still read you as leaning town.. I still do..
Zemmi said:
I lean towards Misty or Beky being scum. I find the situation interesting but I don't want to go into much detail, I still don't see why Misty would have done what she would have done without being town but I also get what Beky said about her not being dead when we don't have a healing role, because if I was scum I would of took a bet on her telling the truth but they didn't.

Yet at the same time I can see how Misty could feel like they were framing her to get lynched setting up an easy lynch for the next day.
Click to expand...
Look at this post.. Zemmi is always 79% accurate with her gutfeel.. Misty's gutfeel about Zemmi and Bemy being scums were bullshit and stupid... Sooooo stupid that we can ourselves stupid too for lowkey letting her control the dayphase... And then she subbed out?
Waindo said:
Oh and Gambit, if you really wanna be all meta about this I might even start to think that you're scum, since you've just said that you're tired of just being scum in the Mafia Chat thread.

That would also explain your defence of Beky here even though he obviously made himself suspicious with his initial posts, yet you are saying that there's nothing suspicious about him. We playin' the same game here bruv?

Oh and going off right after I precisely analyzed why exactly is Beky sus is again making you two look like scum buddies.
Click to expand...
Why would you entrap my post in the gen chat when it is not even classified important to this game??? Saying that I was tired of being scum in tos doesn't mean that I am scum in every game...

I have played with Beky long enough to know him.. We been scum buddies a dozen times and I know how the man played as scum.. He is fucking obvious and would panic when called out without dropping a reasonable defense.

Now that she flipped town and I was right.. I want to ask you what you think of Juliet and the others now? Remember, 1 more mislynch and we fly..
Trafalgar Law said:
@Waindo what do you think about Gambit's play ?
Click to expand...
Why don't you just gimme your exact read on me?? And answer the same question I asked of Wai?? Are u tryna buddy with wai?

@Juliet come over here and talk!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Trafalgar Law

Trafalgar Law

Messages
1,915
Reaction score
2,972
Points
2,950
Salty Doubloons
2,063
Gambit said:
Why don't you just gimme your exact read on me?? And answer the same question I asked of Wai?? Are u tryna buddy with wai?
Click to expand...
I read him townie and have same thought as mine about you...

You are keep voting GU and not even pushing his Lynch and you reasoning is not convincing at all..

Every dead townie and alive have sus Beky at some point except you , who only appear when we sus you...
That's not townie play at all.
My vote on you will stay still... because out of all players I found you the most scumy...
[automerge]1571295367[/automerge]
Gambit said:
I have played with Beky long enough to know him.. We been scum buddies a dozen times and I know how the man played as scum.. He is fucking obvious and would panic when called out without dropping a reasonable defense.

Now that she flipped town and I was right.. I want to ask you what you think of Juliet and the others now? Remember, 1 more mislynch and we fly..
Click to expand...
Nope it's because you know he was town , and you tried to play passive by keep voting GU .
Why didn't you try to convince us to vote GU over Beky since you were voting him twice..?
[automerge]1571295452[/automerge]
And please give us your reads on every player...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Waindo

Waindo

Messages
3,336
Reaction score
10,079
Points
9,000
Salty Doubloons
1,061
Wowzers. As Gambit said, one more mislynch and we're doomed, while I'm still inbetween Misty and GU, I think it's time we get some pointers from the seer before we place our votes.

Beky that was an awful play from you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Trafalgar Law

Trafalgar Law

Messages
1,915
Reaction score
2,972
Points
2,950
Salty Doubloons
2,063
Waindo said:
Wowzers. As Gambit said, one more mislynch and we're doomed, while I'm still inbetween Misty and GU, I think it's time we get some pointers from the seer before we place our votes.

Beky that was an awful play from you.
Click to expand...
Do you still believe GU is Scum ?
If he is one then he is throwing the game , dude is not participating in DP and don't even care to vote ,
That's not how scum play , I know he is troll...

But you are misunderstood him , "he don't claim no matter what ! But he never throw as scum
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom