[FIN] Traditional Mafia Attack on Titan Mafia

Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
i filtered a couple for the sake of thread health, but none can deny u were polluting the thread with stuff outside of the game out of nowhere when i made a hypothesis that u can be double voter
Sure, I would even go as far as to say I escalated the discussion - but you've also responded with the same sort of stuff in large part. You can't just be fine with it coming from one person and not the other.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
That wasn't a hypothesis either - it was a completely random argument you made to justify your apparent suspicion.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
Sure, I would even go as far as to say I escalated the discussion - but you've also responded with the same sort of stuff in large part. You can't just be fine with it coming from one person and not the other.
i'll apologize for my part, could have been done a bit cleaner
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
That wasn't a hypothesis either - it was a completely random argument you made to justify your apparent suspicion.
wasnt a bad guess based off ur claim

if flower is giving scum fakes, they'd need to sort of make sense and fit the actual roles i think r scum - reiner or bertolt. one wud be strongman / immune to redirection / roleblocker. the other wud be double voter / win f3
 
Messages
2,193
Reaction score
7,452
Points
9,350
Salty Doubloons
11,524
in the next day if ratchet flips town
- if larsi killed himself, we win and means eins was town
- if a kill failed on me/karp then lars is town doctor and eins is scum who ran out of redirect shots
- if a kill successfully happened on me/karp then eins is not town or lars is immune to redirections - hard to solve this scenario, but probably eins due to role spec
- if another abstain happens i am more leaning toward it being larsi afraid of redirections
@Einsauer why do u still sus karp?
All of this assumes Karp is definitely not the killer right? I know you said you don't wanna add more suspects, but I have a horrible feeling in my stomach that I'm getting Light Yagami'd and I only see it because Karp is the exact person would set me up as his scapegoat all game, keep me alive the whole time, then smile in my face while I'm hanged.

Basically at this point, I'm afraid to not only lose but also have seen it happening the whole time and nobody would believe me. :dogkek:

Other reason just being process of elimination at this point (in my mind).
You and Larsi are just a step-below hard clear in my mind, leaving only Karp should it actually not be Rail.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
also in my mind i keep thinking about the negima game where flower intentionally puts mislynch traps

figured she'd give town too much PRs to have us lynch each other as a trap i suppose?
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
wasnt a bad guess based off ur claim

if flower is giving scum fakes, they'd need to sort of make sense and fit the actual roles i think r scum - reiner or bertolt. one wud be strongman / immune to redirection / roleblocker. the other wud be double voter / win f3
i realize it might be a case of correct answr wrong formula tho but yknow... i'll take it
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
Vote Count Final Day 4

Kekko: Einseur > Rail > Larsi > Rail
Larsi: Rail
Einsauer: Rail
Rail: Larsi > Kekko > Larsi
Karp: Kekko > Rail

Rail - 4
Larsi - 1​
 
Messages
2,193
Reaction score
7,452
Points
9,350
Salty Doubloons
11,524
Surprised youre not voting for him already then
Wouldn't it jump straight to lynch?
I'm like 95% sure it's Karp.
But then they were talking about strongmen or whatever the fuck and I'm doubting my gut. Maybe Karp surprises me and throws you under the bus and convinces me with facts and logic, I dunno man. :pepeweird:

What I know is: I redirected you twice and both times, deaths occurred elsewhere.
 
Messages
2,113
Reaction score
7,127
Points
9,250
Salty Doubloons
2,765
I'm not sure who to vote for.
Larsi could have strongman. Or Einsauer is lying.
 

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,240
Reaction score
29,479
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,367
Whichever one of you it is, gg regardless
 
Top Bottom