Archived [OLD] Experience Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,192
Reaction score
29,318
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,318
Hatz vs WingedClover | Not Canon, Battleground

Participants: @Hatz @WingedClover

First Post:

Last Post:
@WingedClover

Personality: 13
Story: 14
Combat Prowess: 10
Description: 15
Enjoyability: 13
Rule Breaks:
Post Count: 19
Experience: 7490



@Hatz

Personality: 14
Story: 14
Combat Prowess: 10
Description: 15
Enjoyability: 13
Rule Breaks:
Post Count: 18
Experience: 7243

Comments for both:
A few posts were a bit short, battle was minimal and it was a bit confusing at times, but descriptions were generally pretty good.
 
Messages
12,632
Reaction score
39,412
Points
30,850
Salty Doubloons
10,892
REVIEWED
Marineford
Participant : @Emperor Cross
Host : @Gambit

First Post :

Last Post :
 
Messages
9,853
Reaction score
35,467
Points
28,000
Salty Doubloons
1,694
Last edited by a moderator:
Messages
14,844
Reaction score
44,241
Points
33,300
Salty Doubloons
1,144
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Punk Hazard

Participants
: @Emperor Cross @Frayz and @Oreki
Host: @joby and @Gintoki

First Post: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/punk-hazard.199/post-1187
Last Post: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/punk-hazard.199/post-42973
Extra info: Canon Island / Ceasar and Monet are dead.
Oreki's score
Personality: 20
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 17
Enjoyable: 18
Post Count: 17
Exp: 15,012

Emperor Cross's score
Personality: 20
Story Progression: 18
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 18
Post Count: 20
Exp: 17,949

Gintoki's score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 18
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 15
Enjoyable: 16
Post Count: 17
Exp: 9,054

Frayz's score
Personality: 18
Story Progression: 14
Combat Prowess: 0
Descriptions: 14
Enjoyable: 16
Post Count: 2
Exp: 1,110

Joby's score
Personality: 0
Story Progression: 14
Combat Prowess: 0
Descriptions: 19
Enjoyable: 18
Post Count: 1
Exp: 286

Monet's fruit goes to Oreki.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Banaro Island

Participants
: @God_Usopun
Host: @SkeletonsOfThePast & @Oreki

First Post:
Last Post:
Extra info: Canon Island / Sheriff dead
Xatch's score
Personality:
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess:
Descriptions: 18
Enjoyable: 17
Post Count: 1
Exp: 286

Usopun's score
Personality: 17
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 15
Descriptions: 17
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 16
Exp: 12,563

Oreki's score
Personality: 18
Story Progression: 15
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 15
Exp: 7,852
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Participant : @Icetime
Host : @Captain Khan
Start of fight: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/kame-house.133/post-3314
End of fight: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/kame-house.133/post-3337

Extra info: Cannon . Ice is MIA, so unfinished . The first post of Ice was merged into his last adventure at the same Island so the reviewer should consider that .
Ice's scores
Personality: 15
Story Progression: 15
Combat Prowess: 15
Description: 13
Enjoyable: 14
Post Count: 18
Exp: 12,228

Khan's scores
Personality: 14
Story Progression: 15
Combat Prowess: 16
Description: 16
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 12
Exp: 5,851
 
Messages
2,723
Reaction score
13,061
Points
10,800
Salty Doubloons
1,127
Name of fighters: @Gintoki @Gambit and @D I O
Link to start of fight: Undivided Resolution, Post 1
Link to end of fight: Undivided Resolution, Latest Post
Extra info: Unfinished, it was a Normal BG for myself and Gambit but a Special BG for D I O. Unfinished due to D I O being busy with his exams + coursework

Posts Count:
Gintoki
6
Gambit
6
D I O
4
@Gintoki
Score (Non-Canon): 2,564 EXP

Personality: 16
Story Progression: 18
Combat Prowess: 0
Description: 17
Enjoyable: 18

Post Count: 6

@Gambit
Score (Non-Canon): 2,614 EXP

Personality: 18
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 0
Description: 18
Enjoyable: 18

Post Count: 6

@D I O
Score (Non-Canon): 1,449 EXP

Personality: 15
Story Progression: 14
Combat Prowess: 0
Description: 16
Enjoyable: 16

Post Count: 4

Reviewer EXP: 300+100=400
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Oreki's score
Personality: 18
Story Progression: 15
Combat Prowess: 15
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 16
Post Count: 10
Exp: 7852

Gintoki's score
Personality: 17
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 15
Descriptions: 17
Enjoyable: 18
Post Count: 9
Exp: 4,959

This shall be the last BG I do that isn't in the Dec 10th section. After I finish that section, I'll head on to the rest. Nobody ask me to do anything outside that section.
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Participants: @NeoRetro & @captain abram
Host: @Gambit
Link to start: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/rubeck-island.145/post-3718
Link to end: https://thrillerbark.com/threads/rubeck-island.145/post-8524
Notes: Participants are MIA... Please restart the thread after review..
Gambit's score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 17
Combat Prowess: 0
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 2
Exp: 772

Neo's score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 0
Descriptions: 17
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 2
Exp: 1,158

Captain Abram's score
Personality: 15
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 0
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 15
Post Count: 2
Exp: 1,110
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Fire Tiger's score
Personality: 17
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 17
Descriptions: 18
Enjoyable: 17
Post Count: 10
Exp: 5,697

Frayz's score
Personality: 18
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 16
Enjoyable: 17
Post Count: 10
Exp: 8,127

Emprror Cross's score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 15
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 15
Enjoyable: 16
Post Count: 10
Exp: 7,581
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Gintoki's Score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 14
Combat Prowess: 13
Description: 14
Enjoyability: 8
Post Count: 12
Exp: 4730

Gambit's score
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 13
Combat Prowess: 12
Description: 15
Enjoyability: 9
Post Count: 11
Exp: 4336
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
@Oreki vs. Dabit


Extra Info: Not canon, incomplete, a player is missing... if you find him please do tell him to come back.
I decided not to review Dabit's posts since he's not here.

Oreki's score
Personality: 17
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 14
Descriptions: 15
Enjoyability: 15
Post Count: 6
Experience: 2978
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
Fighters: @God_Usopun & @Fire Tiger
Fight Start:
End:
Details: Duel
@Fire Tiger
Experience: 5,887
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 18
Combat Prowess: 16
Descriptions: 17
Enjoyability: 20
Post Count: 10
quick comments: very very enjoyable set up and story. interesting descriptions of sulong mindset. fighting was somewhat predictable.

@God_Usopun
Experience: 5,326
Personality: 16
Story Progression: 16
Combat Prowess: 19
Descriptions: 12
Enjoyability: 18
Post Count: 10
quick comments: good responses to what was set up. Really fun and dynamic use of your guns but could have described pain more. Average overall descriptions. Enjoyable personality towards kilij.
[automerge]1582401338[/automerge]
Request of review
Players: @Hatz & @God_Usopun

Extra info: Duel, Non-canon
@Hatz
Experience: 171
Personality: 2
Story Progression: 2
Combat Prowess: 5
Descriptions: 2
Enjoyability: 2
Post Count: 3
quick comments: not much to say. I would call this the bare minimum. Seems like you didn't have time for it.

@God_Usopun
Experience: 1,134
Personality: 12
Story Progression: 9
Combat Prowess: 15
Descriptions: 12
Enjoyability: 15
Post Count: 3
quick comments: pretty average in most cases tho you did show up well for that last post in particular. I'd say overall your performance here was a step below the effort you put forth in your BG with tiger
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom