[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 2 - Case Closed

Status
Not open for further replies.
Shottie

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Drago asks for reads
Give reads with 3 possible scums listed
Drago focuses on what I said about him
Drago votes me up roflmao.png
Classic Drago Tizzy
 
Okosan

Okosan

Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
Shottie said:
If you're communicating and one of you pops town then you're town masons, if one of you dies and flips scum then by your own admissions both of you are scums.
Click to expand...
Coooooooo! (So you're "info lynch" clears or implicates exactly one person? It seems like you didn't really think the vote through and are just trying to justify your actions. There's actually a lot more info out there that gets revealed in both of those scenarios just due to general interactions, people pushing, etc. For instance, if Okosan is mafia the Rej is lot less likely to be mafia due to how much Okosan and Drago have been going at them.)

Coo? (The best part is other lynches like AFM or Rej give plenty of info just in different ways. There's very little reason not to just vote who you find scummy instead of trying to go for "info" like you said.)

Shottie said:
I didn't say AFN was acting odd, I said he decides who he's going to lynch start of dp and doesn't change his mind. I tried getting y'all to look closer at him last dp but no one but Rej was interested.
Click to expand...
Cooo Coo? (So you're saying that you both didn't say/think AFM was acting odd, and yet you pushed him all day yesterday? That makes no sense. Why would you push someone that you didn't think was being odd/scummy?)
[automerge]1572151595[/automerge]
*Coo! (*your)
[automerge]1572152099[/automerge]
Coooo! (If Okosan thought we still had time to pivot Shottie has shot up Okosan's scum list and would seriously consider voting them)
 
Last edited:
Shottie

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Okosan said:
Cooo Coo? (So you're saying that you both didn't say/think AFM was acting odd, and yet you pushed him all day yesterday? That makes no sense. Why would you push someone that you didn't think was being odd/scummy?)
Click to expand...
Ummm, because the reason was he voted me up and came back with "it's just a joke". When you vote up someone who's voted you up it tends to be called OMGUS and that's just an annoying reason to fight all day.
Okosan said:
Coooooooo! (So you're "info lynch" clears or implicates exactly one person? It seems like you didn't really think the vote through and are just trying to justify your actions. There's actually a lot more info out there that gets revealed in both of those scenarios just due to general interactions, people pushing, etc. For instance, if Okosan is mafia the Rej is lot less likely to be mafia due to how much Okosan and Drago have been going at them.)
Click to expand...
And why are you so concerned about 1 vote? Right now you and I are tied, Drago has a vote on me for... stating my opinion? Dunno, if nothing else his vote shows he has to try and protect you.
And I like more direct lynch confirmations. A+B=C not A+C=bananas.
I means last dp was it i was scum I'd drago ended up scum? Or was it me being scum if juliet flipped scum? There was a bunch of bananas last dp.
 
Shottie

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Okosan said:
Coooo! (If Okosan thought we still had time to pivot Shottie has shot up Okosan's scum list and would seriously consider voting them)
Click to expand...
And I'm scummy because...??? I doubt your claims? There were a whole lot of folks earlier with doubts. I just happen to be the last one to the party and that's where I've been hung up on.
 
Okosan

Okosan

Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
Shottie said:
Ummm, because the reason was he voted me up and came back with "it's just a joke". When you vote up someone who's voted you up it tends to be called OMGUS and that's just an annoying reason to fight all day.
Click to expand...
Cooo? (So to clarify you don't think that's odd then? Because you said you didn't say that even though you apparently have plenty of things to bring up of AFM's that seem that way)

Shottie said:
And why are you so concerned about 1 vote? Right now you and I are tied, Drago has a vote on me for... stating my opinion? Dunno, if nothing else his vote shows he has to try and protect you.
And I like more direct lynch confirmations. A+B=C not A+C=bananas.
I means last dp was it i was scum I'd drago ended up scum? Or was it me being scum if juliet flipped scum? There was a bunch of bananas last dp.
Click to expand...
COOO! COO! (Okosan's really not concerned about the vote. It's the fact the vote is so scummy and your reads/justifications are so weird. And Okosan asked you for any info you would get if Okosan flipped various alignments, and all you came back with was what Drago would be. Even if you "don't like" more vague info, you should still be to think of the possibilities. So it really looks to Okosan you didn't think the vote through and came up with that response not thinking about what the other implications might be.)

Coo!!! (Lynching one person to confirm another and that's it is just bad)
[automerge]1572152794[/automerge]
Shottie said:
And I'm scummy because...??? I doubt your claims? There were a whole lot of folks earlier with doubts. I just happen to be the last one to the party and that's where I've been hung up on.
Click to expand...
Cooooooooo! (No you're scummy because of that read list earlier, your insistence in pushing doubt on people without really taking a stand, and that horrible vote on Okosan with no good justification. The last one Okosan's already explained, and the first two tie together with you calling a bunch of random people scummy but not voting any of them or really calling them out.)
[automerge]1572152924[/automerge]
COOOO! (Also any suspicion that does come from you suspecting Okosan isn't because of said suspicion, it's the content of it if that makes sense. Other people thought we might be open wolfing as partners (which Okosan can at least understand since it's paranoia), but you're just jumping in on it disbelieving that we might even be talking together. Which makes actually 0 sense)
 
Last edited:
Shottie

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
:blobthink: it's like Okra didn't notice he dared me to vote him up by calling me out on not following up on my reads about him, so I did and now I haven't thought my vote through, or tried to push my other scummy reads on folks who aren't around and just 2 hours left before votes lock.
Just last dp I berated for not chatting with the people online and now I do and I'm told I should be questioning those not online.

Let's hope next dp I'm alive so I can finally figure out which method of questioning is more acceptable for you folks.
 
Shottie

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Okosan said:
COOOO! (Also any suspicion that does come from you suspecting Okosan isn't because of said suspicion, it's the content of it if that makes sense. Other people thought we might be open wolfing as partners (which Okosan can at least understand since it's paranoia), but you're just jumping in on it disbelieving that we might even be talking together. Which makes actually 0 sense)
Click to expand...
No honey I was doubting you guys as town masons. I was calling you scummies because you talk together but are taking different directions creating more chaos and not getting behind the same peoples to double team push.
 
Okosan

Okosan

Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
Shottie said:
:blobthink: it's like Okra didn't notice he dared me to vote him up by calling me out on not following up on my reads about him, so I did and now I haven't thought my vote through, or tried to push my other scummy reads on folks who aren't around and just 2 hours left before votes lock.
Just last dp I berated for not chatting with the people online and now I do and I'm told I should be questioning those not online.

Let's hope next dp I'm alive so I can finally figure out which method of questioning is more acceptable for you folks.
Click to expand...
Cooo!! Coo! (He literally didn't though? He called you out for not taking a stance on us as being scum or not because you said you were just going to watch and figure it out later, even though you already clearly suspected us. You still haven't taken a stance on anyone else either really. Any people you've said you're getting scum reads on you haven't really pushed either unless Okosan is forgetting something (He'll be honest he hasn't actually compared the list to the people your posts, though. He just doesn't remember any of them really tbh) )
[automerge]1572153905[/automerge]
Shottie said:
No honey I was doubting you guys as town masons. I was calling you scummies because you talk together but are taking different directions creating more chaos and not getting behind the same peoples to double team push.
Click to expand...
Coo!! (So you do realize that regardless of if we're lying or telling the truth we have to both be able to talk to each other right? So as scum if we wanted we could easily push the same people. Also just because we can talk to each other doesn't mean we necessarily have the same reads. And even if we did have the exact same reads it's not bad to push different people to get more reactions in general)

Cooooo! (Also weren't we both pushing and voting Rej earlier?)
 
Night 2
  • Index
    • Nana

    Nana

    Messages
    486
    Reaction score
    3,594
    Points
    3,600
    Salty Doubloons
    907
    Shottie said:
    Kay!
    Vote lynch Okosan

    I like the information we get with your lynch. We can confirm Drago one way or another.
    Click to expand...
    Dragomir said:
    Vote lynch Shottie

    Let's get it done.
    Click to expand...
    These won't count as day have ended

    Final Vote Count
    AFH - 4
    Rej - 3
    Fire Tiger - 1

    ...............................................................................

    With the ending of the day coming near , players decided it was AFH turn now to hang him as they suspected he had a relations with the ones who wear black ,,,,,

    and with that @A famous historian was lynched , he was
    Ran Mouri , the Doctor


    ​


    it's now Night 2

    You have 24 hours to submit your actions
    ​
    Players :
    2. @Rej​
    16. @Law​
     
  • Index
    • day 3
  • Index
    • Nana

    Nana

    Messages
    486
    Reaction score
    3,594
    Points
    3,600
    Salty Doubloons
    907
  • Index
    • Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Top Bottom