[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 5 - Wano Hype!

[nfcnorth]

if it was fake then he won't be punished

tbh fake claims get punished just as much in no claim games

 

[Hayumi]

If your fine ignoring his early comment, of not lynching on first day. even Juliet said this same thought early on. on why it's bad idea. Because it always results in town being lynched day 1.

But a lot of you, this has happen more then once in past game. people being lynch trigger happy which votes on town mostly the first day.
[automerge]1582833334[/automerge]


It's not like other will take vote off. So with some town having vote on them.. as 99% case voting back is only way.

Ok
No lynch.

 

[AL.]

It's not like other will take vote off. So with some town having vote on them.. as 99% case voting back is only way.

a lynch always provides info you should know better than that naomi

 

[nfcnorth]

What's your reason for Wai and North? Shouldn't they be scummy for taking advantage of Al situation?

Just curious why you see Wai and me taking advantage of the Al situation?

Also just saying fake claims technically need to be punished just as hard as real ones. Otherwise it opens up loopholes and other problems

 

[AL.]

tbh fake claims get punished just as much in no claim games

not here

 

[Nessos]

Tbh this DP is way too long.

48h dp1 in trad is nothing new.

why you gotta show up end of day and lazily throw shade at everyone who's been active trying to make this a game up til now

It is the middle of the DP not the end.

Just curious why you see Wai and me taking advantage of the Al situation?

Also just saying fake claims technically need to be punished just as hard as real ones. Otherwise it opens up loopholes and other problems

Just in case.you missed it @Beky subbed in for Oreki.

 

[nfcnorth]

not here

Well they should imo.

 

[Stray Cat]

Just curious why you see Wai and me taking advantage of the Al situation?

Also just saying fake claims technically need to be punished just as hard as real ones. Otherwise it opens up loopholes and other problems

Otherwise you can just say what you are not and then basically claim that way, so technically this is true.
[automerge]1582833923[/automerge]
@Beky hi!

 

[AL.]

Ok
No lynch.

you really want a no lynch???

if so whats your reasoning for that

a lynch on day 1 always helps whether its a proper lynch or a mislynch

 

[Beky]

Reading last 19 pages felt like dragging my nuts through glass.

If i noticed one thing when subbing in is that 90% of posts you read are scummy as fck and this game is nothing different. If it was up to me i would lynch 90% of you right now.

I personally believe D1 start shouldn't be used to lynch someone because odds of finding scum by : OH HE SAID THAT SHE SAID THAT is beyond ridiculous to me. In majority of cases you will miss lynch and then you will go after possible townies that did the miss lynch while mafia took a seat back and watched everything

That being said i am eyeing players that are here but not really pushing anything forward. To me scum is laying there in the grass just laughing.

So rather than using D1 to lynch someone use it to gauge players to figure out who to visit at night

 

[joby]

It is the middle of the DP not the end.

my bad

 

[Stray Cat]

Reading last 19 pages felt like dragging my nuts through glass.

If i noticed one thing when subbing in is that 90% of posts you read are scummy as fck and this game is nothing different. If it was up to me i would lynch 90% of you right now.

I personally believe D1 start shouldn't be used to lynch someone because odds of finding scum by : OH HE SAID THAT SHE SAID THAT is beyond ridiculous to me. In majority of cases you will miss lynch and then you will go after possible townies that did the miss lynch while mafia took a seat back and watched everything

That being said i am eyeing players that are here but not really pushing anything forward. To me scum is laying there in the grass just laughing.

So rather than using D1 to lynch someone use it to gauge players to figure out who to visit at night

Yeah, but how does that help when you can't share info due to no claiming rule? Lynches and kills are the only way to have clear reveals...

 

[Nessos]

So rather than using D1 to lynch someone use it to gauge players to figure out who to visit at night

Beky for no lynch DP1?
Its a "no claiming"-game so every lynch helps Town to get infos ven DP1 lynch.

 

[Beky]

Yeah, but how does that help when you can't share info due to no claiming rule? Lynches and kills are the only way to have clear reveals...

Dude you MUST share info in mafia as town. You are taking rules too literally. Yea claiming is forbidden and info dumping too.
But i SRSLY DOUBT rej forbade us to share info between us to catch scum.

So if investigate role gets a scum result he/she isn't allowed to share it? Bullshit
Info Dumping is when someone literally full claims their abilities, not sharing info you got during night.
If it is forbidden then whats the point of putting investigative abilities or any role really that helps town catch scum when you can't share info?

Beky for no lynch DP1?
Its a "no claiming"-game so every lynch helps Town to get infos ven DP1 lynch.

No. Def not.
How does no claim game make every lynch viable? Person being lynched can't even claim to save themselves or at least give a chance to defend themself

It is complete opposite - You shouldn't blind lynch to gain info. Keep every lynch secured and minimize casualties. This game is basically game of time. The more time we get the bigger our chances are

Blind lynching people is the last thing we should do

 

[Stray Cat]

Beky for no lynch DP1?
Its a "no claiming"-game so every lynch helps Town to get infos ven DP1 lynch.

Hayumi, Drago, Naomi, Beky...could they be the scum team?
[automerge]1582835084[/automerge]

Dude you MUST share info in mafia as town. You are taking rules too literally. Yea claiming is forbidden and info dumping too.
But i SRSLY DOUBT rej forbade us to share info between us to catch scum.

So if investigate role gets a scum result he/she isn't allowed to share it? Bullshit
Info Dumping is when someone literally full claims their abilities, not sharing info you got during night.
If it is forbidden then whats the point of putting investigative abilities or any role really that helps town catch scum when you can't share info?


No. Def not.
How does no claim game make every lynch viable? Person being lynched can't even claim to save themselves or at least give a chance to defend themself

It is complete opposite - You shouldn't blind lynch to gain info. Keep every lynch secured and minimize casualties. This game is basically game of time. The more time we get the bigger our chances are

Blind lynching people is the last thing we should do

Well, if we can share stuff a no lynch would be acceptable. But if we can't we definitely need a lynch.

 

[AL.]

beky acting like this is his first no claiming game

 

[Naomi]

Hayumi, Drago, Naomi, Beky...could they be the scum team?

Is it possible everyone voting is scum team!

You see. just because others have different opinion on matter. does not make them team.

That is the most bs excuse i'v seen through this game, and it came from you.

 

[Stray Cat]

Is it possible everyone voting is scum team!

You see. just because others have different opinion on matter. does not make them team.

That is the most bs excuse i'v seen through this game, and it came from you.

Why so defensive. I was just joking lol.

 

[Hayumi]

I

you really want a no lynch???

if so whats your reasoning for that

a lynch on day 1 always helps whether its a proper lynch or a mislynch

I mean preferably I want to lynch Nessos or Stray if anyone tbh

Hayumi, Drago, Naomi, Beky...could they be the scum team?
[automerge]1582835084[/automerge]

Well, if we can share stuff a no lynch would be acceptable. But if we can't we definitely need a lynch.

Because of shit reasoning like this

 

[Beky]

Well, if we can share stuff a no lynch would be acceptable. But if we can't we definitely need a lynch.

Well obviously you can't claim and just throw info about your role out there and be like - yea i am that no point investigating or doubting me

But cmon, how else should town function if they aren't allowed to share info?

beky acting like this is his first no claiming game

And you from what i've seen just threw shade this game at people without really giving any reasons just like you did now.
How does your post push the game forward in any way? It doesn't beside throwing shade on me you didn't explain or progress