[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 5 - Wano Hype!

[Nessos]

So if investigate role gets a scum result he/she isn't allowed to share it? Bullshit

As Invest you can't say anything that reveals you as Invest. So you can't say "I invested X and got guilty".

You have to pack it well and use Grey zones.

 

[Beky]

As Invest you can't say anything that reveals you as Invest. So you can't say "I invested X and got guilty".

You have to pack it well and use Grey zones.

Yes so?
Still way better than going blind lynch someone on basis he said she said

 

[Nessos]

Come on @Beky I am quite certain that this not your first Game we're claiming is useless or forbidden.

 

[Beky]

Come on @Beky I am quite certain that this not your first Game we're claiming is useless or forbidden.

It isn't.
Who said it was?

 

[Stray Cat]

Well obviously you can't claim and just throw info about your role out there and be like - yea i am that no point investigating or doubting me

But cmon, how else should town function if they aren't allowed to share info?


And you from what i've seen just threw shade this game at people without really giving any reasons just like you did now.
How does your post push the game forward in any way? It doesn't beside throwing shade on me you didn't explain or progress

Well, I was wondering about that.

Anyway, can you give your thoughts on Drago?

 

[Nessos]

A no lynch is always a loss of ressources.

 

[Naomi]

A no lynch is always a loss of ressources.

I seen important town roles die, which gave scum lead on first day. from past experience.

because of town lynchers (or scum) this made it easy for scum to push narrative on person voting first day which resulted in more town being lynched.

 

[Beky]

A no lynch is always a loss of ressources.

So you are ok with possibly blind lynching a town that can cause more distress to town and possible miss lynch more townies?

Well, I was wondering about that.

Anyway, can you give your thoughts on Drago?

in about 30 min cause i got Vampires to kill

 

[AL.]

And you from what i've seen just threw shade this game at people without really giving any reasons just like you did now.
How does your post push the game forward in any way? It doesn't beside throwing shade on me you didn't explain or progress

threw shades??point them out

you can't see that my posts are making others talk and by doing so producing content for reads

 

[Hayumi]

Ok can everyone please give me an updated vote tally. Who is in the lead at the moment and who are the majority of you feeling should be lynched, whether for information or because of really strong scum vibes now is a good time to share if you haven't already

 

[Nessos]

So you are ok with possibly blind lynching a town that can cause more distress to town and possible miss lynch more townies?

Not a blindlynch. You already have 387+ posts on 20 pages to analyze and still ~22.5h to go.

More than enough to figure out inconsistencies, overcautious plays amd buddy plays.You should also be able to rule out fake cases.

What do you plan to do, if noone got any real Info from N1? Another no lynch?
Come on Beky what is this noob behaviour? Its not like the first time you play trad.
[automerge]1582836239[/automerge]

Ok can everyone please give me an updated vote tally. Who is in the lead at the moment and who are the majority of you feeling should be lynched, whether for information or because of really strong scum vibes now is a good time to share if you haven't already

And what are you plan to do? Blindly guts sheeping? How about trying to build up a case on your own?

 

[Beky]

you can't see that my posts are making others talk and by doing so producing content for reads

Yes that's exactly what you are doing
You come in - throw some shade - and then dip and let people figure it out
You basically cause more commotion than help doing that

Not a blindlynch. You already have 387+ posts on 20 pages to analyze and still ~22.5h to go.

He said She said

More than enough to figure out inconsistencies, overcautious plays amd buddy plays.You should also be able to rule out fake cases.

He said She said

What do you plan to do, if noone got any real Info from N1? Another no lynch?

Yes and thus preserving a townie miss lynch

Come on Beky what is this noob behaviour? Its not like the first time you play trad.

It isn't. And if it is nooby behavior to preserve numbers and not blind lynch a townie based on he said she said then yes i am a noob.
Go and miss lynch someone. And i bet you will miss lynch a townie and then go and say next day phase: Well he appeared scummy.

 

[Beky]

What do you plan to do, if noone got any real Info from N1? Another no lynch?

Oh and btw you and al would be my top candidates for a lynch if i was to vote for one

 

[Hayumi]

Not a blindlynch. You already have 387+ posts on 20 pages to analyze and still ~22.5h to go.

More than enough to figure out inconsistencies, overcautious plays amd buddy plays.You should also be able to rule out fake cases.

What do you plan to do, if noone got any real Info from N1? Another no lynch?
Come on Beky what is this noob behaviour? Its not like the first time you play trad.
[automerge]1582836239[/automerge]

And what are you plan to do? Blindly guts sheeping? How about trying to build up a case on your own?

I have been building cases since I started posting lmao. As if I can't ask somebody else's opinion for insight? Your attitude isn't doing you favors tbh. I already know who I would vote if I had to right this second but it's too early for me to be sure about someone when there's a lot of time left and opportunities for stuff to happen.

 

[Nessos]

Oh and btw you and al would be my top candidates for a lynch if i was to vote for one

An your reasoning for this would be?
Plz in detail share your reads Mr "I don't like lynches if they are not 100% safe".
[automerge]1582836868[/automerge]

I have been building cases since I started posting lmao. As if I can't ask somebody else's opinion for insight? Your attitude isn't doing you favors tbh. I already know who I would vote if I had to right this second but it's too early for me to be sure about someone when there's a lot of time left and opportunities for stuff to happen.

Yeah your reasoning against me was gutes and thats was enough for you to jump on a train 24h before the dp ended.
[automerge]1582836969[/automerge]
No to mention that directly row back after a few spoke out their dobts about my lynch.

 

[Beky]

An your reasoning for this would be?
Plz in detail share your reads Mr "I don't like lynches if they are not 100% safe".

Oh i will go for lynches even if they aint 100%
But i am no fool going for ones that are below 30%
And your borderline condescending behaviour aint doing any favours to you.

You are more than willing to go for blind lynches - yes blind lynches - they are that because you are going of on someone said this and that. If that would be a base to lynch someone i can gurantee you 100% majority of people would lynch for you right now

You are wiling to blind lynch and very possibly miss lynch a townie to gain "info" in a game where we lack info.

Didnt it occure to you that keeping as many townies alive benefits us more because we can generate more into that way by just sharing what we got?

Meanwhile you are suggesting here we go for very possible miss lynches that would in the end result in us having way less information to work with.

That kind of mentality this game is borderline ridicolus. You are single handendly making me wanna lynch you which i know for a fact i shouldnt do.

I aint no hypocrite

 

[Hayumi]

An your reasoning for this would be?
Plz in detail share your reads Mr "I don't like lynches if they are not 100% safe".
[automerge]1582836868[/automerge]

Yeah your reasoning against me was gutes and thats was enough for you to jump on a train 24h before the dp ended.
[automerge]1582836969[/automerge]
No to mention that directly row back after a few spoke out their dobts about my lynch.

I already explained my reasoning for lynching you, tbh I forgot this was a 48 hour day phase until a few mins ago when I full read through the rules again, which is why I took back my vote for you and was just feeling stressed to vote someone. You aren't the person who I'm getting the most scum vibes from at all and I havent fully dissected your posts. I admit that I shouldn't have jumped to lynch you without solid reasoning since there's someone else I want to lynch more, but as already stated the whole Al/Stray/Drago situation had me all messed up, and nobody else has given me scummy enough vibes or hints for me to want to vote them. But I'm not just some townie who relies on everybody else's opinions. I started attacking Stray's logic since the start of the phase if you haven't already seen all my posts.

 

[Nessos]

You are more than willing to go for blind lynches - yes blind lynches - they are that because you are going of on someone said this and that.

You have to focus on how and when do people say this or that. And then its not a blind a lynch and thats how Mafia works.

Thats why we have a 48h DP1 and are forced to be active. People do mistake when they have to be active.

Sure my play often leads to upset many players, but thats actually a good thing. I always get reactions based on my Playstyle which leads to be able to read people.


Look @joby OMGUS case against me. Right after I mentioned her cautious play is iffy she came up with

1. Tagging a few she likes to look at me
2. Directly voting for me once someone posted he has something against me
3. Trying to twist my posts
4. Pointing out that I already threw shade on her in some game, I can't remember myself

Does this sound like a Town or a Scum reaction for you?

 

[Hayumi]

Also @Beky I need to analyze your posts more as well, but right now I'm getting town vibes from you. I also just noticed that you subbed in for Oreki who was a little sus to me only because they didn't do that much in his short time playing except for like all my posts and agree with what others were saying. Although I'm not getting that same vibe from you

 

[Beky]

You have to focus on how and when do people say this or that. And then its not a blind a lynch and thats how Mafia works.

Thats why we have a 48h DP1 and are forced to be active. People do mistake when they have to be active.

You arent forced to be active.
I will much rather have 20 pages of important stuff than 60 pages of people just screaming at each other throwing OMGUS to the point even the townies of townies can appear as scum

If you have to force activity it will be shit. Just like if you have to force taking a shit. It will be shit

Look @joby OMGUS case against me. Right after I mentioned her cautious play is iffy she came up with

1. Tagging a few she likes to look at me
2. Directly voting for me once someone posted he has something against me
3. Trying to twist my posts
4. Pointing out that I already threw shade on her in some game, I can't remember myself

Does this sound like a Town or a Scum reaction for you?

Thats meta joby and i gave up long ago on trying to reason with joby - Monster Mafia flashbacks
Still love him no homo