Man knowing she was already part of Whitebeards crew back then leaves me wondering how old she actually is
the ship is out of nowhere though
Not out of nowhere. WBP started with 5 commanders. Lets look at division commander 1-5.
Taking another look on the flashback one will realize Thatch didn't appear yet, Jozu was 14 and Marco was 17.
We can clearly say neither Thatch nor Jozu were Division commanders back then, but also 17 year old Marco as commander of first Division?
So we have
Now some might say fill position with current higher numbered division commander, but then there was the statement "numbers don't mean anything". So we have to fill the empty spots with other characters.
And actually there were 3 core members back then who became captains on their own.
Whitey Bay, Andre and Epoida. Thinking about Epoida wanted to become commander like Vista makes him perfect candidate for 4th. Andre looks like a tank similiar to Jozu, so Jozu end up replacing Andre makes sense or not?
So missing one is first division commander. How about Whitey Bay who ordered around Marco?
So we have
- Whitey Bay
Now think about the realtionship between Oden and Whitebeard. Among all male crewmembers Oden was the only one treated as little brother and not as son. He was the 2nd Commander what do we have to expect from 1st commander?
Thats how I came to Whitey x Whitey.