[FIN] Traditional Mafia Attack on Titan Mafia

Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
And the argument for Einsauer is he forgot, and then made up his redirection history to pocket us, and deliberately chose me as his alleged redirect during the round he forgot so he could target me later.
The only problem with that is that he isn't really appealing to you to vote for me, which he would do if he were scum.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
The problem is, both setups make sense:
A RoleTracker and an alternating Strongman to kill/bypass the Roleblocker/redirector to make them give false reads, or a Role tracker and a Redirector to find and redirect the doctor and Roleblocker.
 

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
29,611
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,412
And the argument for Einsauer is he forgot, and then made up his redirection history to pocket us, and deliberately chose me as his alleged redirect during the round he forgot so he could target me later.
The only problem with that is that he isn't really appealing to you to vote for me, which he would do if he were scum.
He is though, he's saying that I couldnt possibly be scum. I'm not 100% hes the scum out of you two, but thinking its far more likely. He's giving me another option if I cant convince you, something that to me is 50% chance of win instead of 33%.

Also he's committed to the bit since day 1.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
He is though, he's saying that I couldnt possibly be scum. I'm not 100% hes the scum out of you two, but thinking its far more likely. He's giving me another option if I cant convince you, something that to me is 50% chance of win instead of 33%.

Also he's committed to the bit since day 1.
To which bit?
 

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
29,611
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,412
Einsauer came back very early during N1, maybe 3 hours after EoD.
And how would nessos know that if they werent scum? Plus you also have to assume that scum has day chat which isnt a given, or else there's no way nessos could pass on the information, since he'd get that after night ends.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
And how would nessos know that if they werent scum? Plus you also have to assume that scum has day chat which isnt a given, or else there's no way nessos could pass on the information, since he'd get that after night ends.
Good point. How common is day chat? We're tilting the occams razor towards Einsauer. Another necessary assumption to make you the killer.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
I never had a night actuon before, do they resolve after talks in the night chat are stopped?
 

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
29,611
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,412
Good point. How common is day chat? We're tilting the occams razor towards Einsauer. Another necessary assumption to make you the killer.
Most games only have night chat for mafia
I never had a night actuon before, do they resolve after talks in the night chat are stopped?
You get the information as night ends, so unless there's day chat you cant pass on the info
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
I also find his claimed actions last night sus.
First he seems hesitant that following Ekkos plan will leave me uncovered, but then he does it anyways and accuses me next round.
I think had there been a blocked kill he would have claimed he redirected me onto Ekko, knowing that you tried to protect him.
Or he really did redirect you onto yourself, and he was already sure he could sus me.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
Also, I can't really believe he can just make people self target if he is town.

In Town's hands, it is a little more powerful, due to the risk that it can be used to wrest control of the Mafia's nightkill into Town's hands. For similar reasons, it is normally a bad idea to allow a player to force another player to self-target, especially if that player is Town-aligned; this would give them the effect of a Vigilante kill that only worked on anti-Town players (who typically have kills).
He could have make mafia players kill themselves, that's kinda broken.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
Imagine if day 4 had ended like:

A failed soldier. Rainer Braun @Larsi fucking killed himself. Town wins, I guess.
 

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
29,611
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,412
Im glad someone appreciated my use of the aot meme in an aot game
 
Top Bottom