[FIN] Regular Mafia Round 1: Monster Mafia - ROMANCE DAWN

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
180
Reaction score
752
Points
1,450
Salty Doubloons
500
You underestimate what a dick I actually am and how no one should ever talk to me let alone play a game of mine, friendos
I always know you're a dick. It's why I enjoy your company.

Stray Cat's assertion could be tested in the upcoming days by seeing if the players are cured after all. But then again no one would subject themselves to damage for the vague promise of recovery.
[automerge]1567898664[/automerge]

Not true. There's plenty of town killing roles and town blocking roles. In essence both town and mafia can have all types of roles to eliminate the other faction.
That's a yes and a no. It depends on how her role works and what it actually does. There's a few problems with her assertation.

1. Her attacks will take away an avoid and that doesn't sound like it will be healed based on what she said, so that initself harms town if she targets a townie because it's removing avoids.
2. She kills you then you come back. If its a converstation of the dead to stray's minion then you're not going to get a truthful action out of that depending on how it shows up in the day phase
3. She' has a kill, if she can be redirected, mafia has a kill they can control to where ever they want it to go.

Honestly, no her ability can't 100% be confirmed based on how the nights go, on top of that you're letting a kill actually harm town at night because stray is doing so it opens up those stray attacks to any old day kill.

I don't trust stray, and unless there's a better target a 3rd party(if that's what she is) that is harming and weaking town to "heal" them doesn't sound like a wise thing to keep around or at least not keep in check.
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
I always know you're a dick. It's why I enjoy your company.



That's a yes and a no. It depends on how her role works and what it actually does. There's a few problems with her assertation.

1. Her attacks will take away an avoid and that doesn't sound like it will be healed based on what she said, so that initself harms town if she targets a townie because it's removing avoids.
2. She kills you then you come back. If its a converstation of the dead to stray's minion then you're not going to get a truthful action out of that depending on how it shows up in the day phase
3. She' has a kill, if she can be redirected, mafia has a kill they can control to where ever they want it to go.

Honestly, no her ability can't 100% be confirmed based on how the nights go, on top of that you're letting a kill actually harm town at night because stray is doing so it opens up those stray attacks to any old day kill.

I don't trust stray, and unless there's a better target a 3rd party(if that's what she is) that is harming and weaking town to "heal" them doesn't sound like a wise thing to keep around or at least not keep in check.
Fine I change my vote from @Kibi to @Stray Cat
Can I do that @Chris Mic ?
Keep your eyes peeled for Kibi tho. That cat suspicious as hell
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Now @Stray Cat... I don't like that 2 lives get lost and then tadaa! Become a zombie with your lives back again, but a zombie. And the fact she has not mentioned how being a zombie effects people makes me nervous.
  1. Do zombies get lynch votes?
  2. Can zombies still do actions as normal?
  3. They have their lives back but can they be killed? (Imagine a mafia member who can not be killed cus they are a zombie)
  4. Also, 6 people are likely to be affected. That's 6 possible townies going down.
  5. And while being "disected" for 2 night periods aren't the victims usually roleblocked?
  6. Is Stray getting abilities from these disections?
  7. Can zombies talk like regular? Press F for doubt.
If Stray can answer this questions (all of them) I will consider letting her live past day 1. Otherwise best lynch target.
Get lots of info to see if the attacks on Rej were coordinated with mafia or just folks who like night 1 target Rej.
 
Messages
1,155
Reaction score
5,065
Points
3,250
Salty Doubloons
1,150
I always know you're a dick. It's why I enjoy your company.



That's a yes and a no. It depends on how her role works and what it actually does. There's a few problems with her assertation.

1. Her attacks will take away an avoid and that doesn't sound like it will be healed based on what she said, so that initself harms town if she targets a townie because it's removing avoids.
2. She kills you then you come back. If its a converstation of the dead to stray's minion then you're not going to get a truthful action out of that depending on how it shows up in the day phase
3. She' has a kill, if she can be redirected, mafia has a kill they can control to where ever they want it to go.

Honestly, no her ability can't 100% be confirmed based on how the nights go, on top of that you're letting a kill actually harm town at night because stray is doing so it opens up those stray attacks to any old day kill.

I don't trust stray, and unless there's a better target a 3rd party(if that's what she is) that is harming and weaking town to "heal" them doesn't sound like a wise thing to keep around or at least not keep in check.
You have a good point. I'm surprised that such a quirky role was revealed so early into the game and there's probably more downside to it than good points in the case of the victim.
 
Messages
660
Reaction score
1,311
Points
3,050
Salty Doubloons
1,155
Dunno why is everyone suspecting Flower & Joby, if u pay attention to WU, both attacked and were attacked so it's obvious this isn't organized stuff, we have some 3rd among these:

Ghoul attacked Criminal Mastermind who attacked Scientist who attacked Weapon Meister
So we definitely have a 3rd or two among these 4

Also i don't think Mafia would waste two attacks on a single target, that is a huge waste & risk and i would never do that if i were them, and that's why i don't think Witch & Scientist are same affiliation

As for Actions, this is from WU:

Weapon Meister --->
Witch ---> Weapon Meister (Attack)
Scientist ---> Weapon Meister (Attack)
Pacifist --->
Evil Spirit ---> Pacifist (???)
Dimension Hopper ---> Pacifist (Coerce)
Dinosaur ---> Pacifist or Evil Spirit (???)
General ---> Pacifist (Invite)
Paranoid Doggo ---> (Watching)
Criminal Mastermind ---> Scientist (Attack)
Best Imouto --->
Hunter ---> Best Imoutou (RB)
President ---> Best Imoutou (???)
??? ---> Hunter (Attack)
Dominatrix ---> (Follow)
Apprentice --->
Flower ---> Apprentice (RB)
Blonde ---> Gullible (RB)
Gullible --->
Set Man --->
Onii Chan ---> Set Man (Steal)
Minister --->
Student --->
Wanderer --->
Ghoul ---> Criminal Mastermind (Attack)
Onmyouji --->
Sexual Object --->

Please correct me if i made a mistake somewhere
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
Now @Stray Cat... I don't like that 2 lives get lost and then tadaa! Become a zombie with your lives back again, but a zombie. And the fact she has not mentioned how being a zombie effects people makes me nervous.
  1. Do zombies get lynch votes?
  2. Can zombies still do actions as normal?
  3. They have their lives back but can they be killed? (Imagine a mafia member who can not be killed cus they are a zombie)
  4. Also, 6 people are likely to be affected. That's 6 possible townies going down.
  5. And while being "disected" for 2 night periods aren't the victims usually roleblocked?
  6. Is Stray getting abilities from these disections?
  7. Can zombies talk like regular? Press F for doubt.
If Stray can answer this questions (all of them) I will consider letting her live past day 1. Otherwise best lynch target.
Get lots of info to see if the attacks on Rej were coordinated with mafia or just folks who like night 1 target Rej.
This makes sense to me.
@Smileyman is either townie or Neutral
@Larsi probs re-destro
 
Messages
180
Reaction score
752
Points
1,450
Salty Doubloons
500
Now @Stray Cat... I don't like that 2 lives get lost and then tadaa! Become a zombie with your lives back again, but a zombie. And the fact she has not mentioned how being a zombie effects people makes me nervous.
  1. Do zombies get lynch votes?
  2. Can zombies still do actions as normal?
  3. They have their lives back but can they be killed? (Imagine a mafia member who can not be killed cus they are a zombie)
  4. Also, 6 people are likely to be affected. That's 6 possible townies going down.
  5. And while being "disected" for 2 night periods aren't the victims usually roleblocked?
  6. Is Stray getting abilities from these disections?
  7. Can zombies talk like regular? Press F for doubt.
If Stray can answer this questions (all of them) I will consider letting her live past day 1. Otherwise best lynch target.
Get lots of info to see if the attacks on Rej were coordinated with mafia or just folks who like night 1 target Rej.
You forgot to ask if become a zombie changes your wincon or faction as well.
 
Messages
180
Reaction score
752
Points
1,450
Salty Doubloons
500
Meh. I thought that was implied when I was asking if they were actions as normal. But yes I'll ask directly.


@Stray Cat #9) do the wincons or faction alliance change?
Well actions aren't really the same as wincon/faction right? So stray could easily dodge that.

Not saying I trust stray at all right now, this zombie thing is fishy.
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
:thonkcool:
Actually with Stray being a 3rd party she won't die with just one lynch. And with there being townie lives on the line that may be best lynch option for this dp.

Ok so anyway. Time to work on night action plans.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom