Chapter Discussion One Piece Chapter 957: Ultimate

Rate the Chapter


  • Total voters
    87
Status
Not open for further replies.

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
.... guys, does Garp know about the void centuries?! ?
Yikes!
I think ye. Another reason why the WG wont go against him. Of fear that he would spread crucial informations.
 
Messages
17
Reaction score
98
Points
735
Salty Doubloons
2,822
I can only say that "I need a Garp spin-off"

But dang, that was an awesome chapter, Teach is currently occupying Bee Hive? Hmmmm, he might know about the Rocks incident.

Also, I don't know if it's anime only, but wasn't WB ignorant of the name D. before Roger explained it.....?
 

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
Theory:
Shanks was reminding WB his scar. Because probably Shanks is the son of Rocks D Xebec and they have similair facial expression, making him Rocks D Shanks

Maybe WB snitched on Xebec and Xebec gave WB his scar. Thats why WB said this particular words back then at the meeting with Shanks.

I think Blackbeard and Shanks will fight about who will lead the "rocks". Possibly both Kaido and Blackbeard were apprentices on that ship.

Blackbeard could recruit the remainers of the Rox after Wano.
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Yikes!
I think ye. Another reason why the WG wont go against him. Of fear that he would spread crucial informations.
I mean...
Ok bear with this thought process...
So Roger's was going for the end and found Rafael *cough god valley cough* but because he got to the end without the pieces he didn't know what he found, other than a fight with the strongest pirate crews of the time. Garp was there too and what was he doing there if not with the Celestial Dragons. He teamed up with Rogers to protect not just the CD, there had to be a greater reason. Soooo Garp learns part of the truth of the world, maybe Rogers fills him in on the rest before execution since he's a fellow D. Which let's math a bit Dragon a teenager? Is Dragon told a bit or the Rocks fight? Learns to hate CD more and revolutionary army idea starts forming (I mean I'm making Dragon pretty old now, but...) with knowledge of the world but not a complete knowledge.

....and that's where I'm at ?
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
I mean...
Ok bear with this thought process...
So Roger's was going for the end and found Rafael *cough god valley cough* but because he got to the end without the pieces he didn't know what he found, other than a fight with the strongest pirate crews of the time. Garp was there too and what was he doing there if not with the Celestial Dragons. He teamed up with Rogers to protect not just the CD, there had to be a greater reason. Soooo Garp learns part of the truth of the world, maybe Rogers fills him in on the rest before execution since he's a fellow D. Which let's math a bit Dragon a teenager? Is Dragon told a bit or the Rocks fight? Learns to hate CD more and revolutionary army idea starts forming (I mean I'm making Dragon pretty old now, but...) with knowledge of the world but not a complete knowledge.

....and that's where I'm at ?
I'm following lol, makes sense to me!!!! I mean, 'Roger and Garp teamed up to protect Celestial Dragons and their slaves' is obvious gaslighting on Oda's part lmao I 5,500,000,000% agree that there is way more to it than that. Maybe an Ancient Weapon involved?
and yeah, 'Oh yeah so totes randoze everybody--but Garp, some CDs and their slaves, the strongest pirate crew to ever exist, 3 outa 4 yonko, and this bro named gold roger all just happened to be on this same island (that isn't raftel) at the same time as one another.' RIP IM DEAD ODA I CAN'T
 
Messages
2
Reaction score
7
Points
100
Salty Doubloons
500
Goddam Oda what a chapter. 20 flipping pages of juicy world building.


What about shakky??? :(
She wasn't mentioned at all. I guess you can kick that theory off the plank.
 

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
I mean...
Ok bear with this thought process...
So Roger's was going for the end and found Rafael *cough god valley cough* but because he got to the end without the pieces he didn't know what he found, other than a fight with the strongest pirate crews of the time. Garp was there too and what was he doing there if not with the Celestial Dragons. He teamed up with Rogers to protect not just the CD, there had to be a greater reason. Soooo Garp learns part of the truth of the world, maybe Rogers fills him in on the rest before execution since he's a fellow D. Which let's math a bit Dragon a teenager? Is Dragon told a bit or the Rocks fight? Learns to hate CD more and revolutionary army idea starts forming (I mean I'm making Dragon pretty old now, but...) with knowledge of the world but not a complete knowledge.

....and that's where I'm at ?
Im baffled it makes sense. That way the god valley incident was probably forging the ideals of Dragon.
I still feel that maybe Garp got blackmailed to join the marines. Maybe he has no other choice plus there is an inner drive. Explains how he was able to connect with Roger...AT SUCH A YOUNG AGE. Both were in their twenties and they were rookies.

Theory:
Shanks was reminding WB his scar. Because probably Shanks is the son of Rocks D Xebec and they have similair facial expression, making him Rocks D Shanks

Maybe WB snitched on Xebec and Xebec gave WB his scar. Thats why WB said this particular words back then at the meeting with Shanks.

I think Blackbeard and Shanks will fight about who will lead the "rocks". Possibly both Kaido and Blackbeard were apprentices on that ship.

Blackbeard could recruit the remainers of the Rox after Wano.
Back to that part of the theory. I feel Koby will have his growth and I feel pre-EoS Koby has to defeat a big Rocks caliber. Or Koby plus Luffy vs BB plus Rocks.
 
Messages
660
Reaction score
1,311
Points
3,050
Salty Doubloons
1,155
This Chapter actually answered many things
But also left us with many Questions

I don't think Rocks is Dead, i think this Chapter extremely hints that he is Im-Sama
The Height matches, his Ambition matches & we know that he met Celestial Dragons on God Valley
Not to mention that Oda wouldn't introduce such a Story to just tell us Rocks is Dead

Because before Rocks was even mentioned, everyone just assumed that WB was Roger's First Rival, Garp became Marine Hero for capturing Roger, BM & Kaido made fame on their own, no one questioned anything really
But the fact that Oda changed all of this and gave us a New Story means it leads somewhere, and Rocks & Im were mentioned at same time so makes sense, and let's not forget Rocks was very powerful so he fits someone who is sitting on Empty Throne
And WG hiding everything related to him is also another Major Hint

Rocks is extremely similar to 3rd Pirates of Caribbean Movie, basically the Best Pirates met in Pirates Island, chose their Leader and formed an Alliance even thought everyone hated each other, just like the Movie (PS: i find it interesting that Moriah had Oars & Ryuma & Captain John from Rocks in his Crew, that was Crazy, imagine if he found them better Shadows !!)

There is another connection that needs to be addressed, Teach & Rocks are heavily related
First of all both are D. and secondly both are Chaotic D.
Blackbeard's Ship is named "Saber of Xebec" and he is ruling in Pirate Island (Same place where Rocks was formed)
His Goal seems similar to Rocks and the way he collected Strong Crew Members is also similar
We can make Theories about Rocks = Teach or Rocks living inside of Teach or something like that but for now let's just say there is a Connection

Shichibukai Bounties are being updated, but don't imagine big increase, both Law & Jinbe didn't get big increases after leaving Shichibukai on their own so expect like Weevil's Bounty being less than 600, Hancock less than 500 .... etc ofc unless they did lot of damage in these few days

We were also introduced to Two New Pirate Names who became Famous along with Shiki & Captain John who are Silver Axe and another Chinese Named Pirate. Silver Axe is an Epithet for a Pirate who obviously fights with an Axe, i checked Wikia for those who use Axes and found nothing, only one that could have been that strong is Scopper Gaban but can't be him since he is associated with Copper & not Silver
As for that other Chinese Pirate, no one comes to mind or maybe he was from Kano Country and former Boss of Chinjao,
however it should be noted that Shakky, Bakkin & Streusen all could have being part of Rocks, maybe Shakky is Silver Axe, who knows

Now regarding "God Valley", it should be noted that Sengoku clearly said that Garp & Roger happened to meet there and protected Celestial Dragons and their Slaves, in other words, they made an Alliance there and not before because otherwise Roger would say "Garp & Roger made an Alliance to defeat Rocks as a Common Enemy" something like this

Now the question is, what is special about that Place that Rocks, Marines, Roger & Celestial Dragons all met there !!
For starters the name of the Place & the way Sengoku talked about CDs and their slaves suggests it's an Island that belonged to CDs
And it makes sense that Rocks would attack such a Place
But we are left with two questions:
Why Celestial Dragons had such a Place, what were they doing there ?
And why Roger & Garp protected them ? In Garp's Case, let's just say he wanted to fight Rocks and followed Orders but what about Roger ?
Why would he even go there in first place ? Theory Guys, this is your job

Another thing to notice is that each of Yonko had a Different Word to describe his Authority
Teach is Admiral, Shanks is Leader, Big Mom is Captain & Kaido is General
I think this clearly hints at the difference between them, their Personalities and how they approach the word "Pirate"

Now Power Level Wise, this Chapter shows us that Roger & Garp were basically the Stars of Old Era with Rocks being the Greatest Rival
Rocks Crew at that time was like having a Crew made of Shichibukai, imagine a Top Tier having like 5 or 6 Shichibukai under his Flag and at that time there weren't any Yonko to stop such a Force, there were only Marines & Roger and maybe few other Pirates
Kaido was young and BM too and even though they were strong, they didn't reach their Prime yet, according to Sengoku they are on a whole different level now, same for WB

Also something to mention, this Chapter doesn't hurt Mihawk's Portrayal at all, it actually shows how Important he is
Of course, not everyone fight with just Swordsmanship but the Fact that Oda puts a Sword on basically everyone with a Famous Name is clear indication of the importance Oda gives to Swords, honestly right now, u can't say Pirate without saying Sword
Oda draws Legends like Roger, Rocks, Shiki, BM, Oden, Shanks, Kizaru, Rayleigh, Aokiji, Fujitora, Ryuma, Captain John, Noland, Streusen, Giant Legends ... etc with Swords, even Current Era, we have Shiryu, Vista, Law, Hawkins, Drake, Cavendish, Oars Jr., Cracker, Smoothie, Jack, Inurashi, King, Snack, Nine Red Scabbards and much much more, even who don't fight with Swords now, trained in Swordsmanship before such as Akainu & all Marines, Marco, Sanji & Germa ... etc and not to mention those who have a Blade & Weapon similar to Sword such as WB, Weevil, Katakuri, Enel ...... etc
And ofc almost all Vice Admirals, Most Fodders anywhere, WB Commanders, Minks, Giants, Samurai .... etc
Of course, not all of these are "Swordsmen" but my point is that Oda associates Swords & Swordsmanship with One Piece so much that you can't ignore it, it's impossible, so Title of "World's Greatest Swordsman" isn't a Joke
I mean even if they aren't really trained in Swordsmanship, but like 99% of anyone who fights in One Piece holds a Sword, so when they hear someone holds title of "Greatest Sworsman In The World", it means a lot, and puts him among Best of Best
(Sorry, i wanted to say this as Reply for those who try to downplay Mihawk after seeing Roger & Rocks holding Swords)

Finally we got confirmation that Akainu won't send Troops to Wano Country, since he said they are Busy (With Shichibukai ofc but also with Revos most probably), also something to notice is that Garp is shown leaving Fishmen Island which means this Chapter is happening One Day before Raid and few days after Last Chapter (756), in other words, this is Present Day or like Few Hours Earlier

Fujitora seems to be in Calm Belt, possibly going after Hancock, and if this is true then Kizaru & Ryokugyo were sent after the others too
Actually the fact that Marines send Admirals for Shichibukai hypes them so much
It's not the fact that an Admiral is needed to beat a Shichibukai that is interesting, since this applies to Commanders too and even Supernova but the fact that Marines can't ignore Shichibukai and rush to capture them as fast as possible and send most their Force to catch them asap, speaks of how much of a Threat they are (Law & Jinbe escaped because they were in Yonko Territory & Moriah was presumed Dead)

Last question is the Bomb that Sengoku dropped at the end, hyping Oden Flashback more and more, suggesting that he isn't just some Samurai who joined Legends and was killed by Kaido, Wano Country definitely have lot of Secrets we still don't know about
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
I'm following lol, makes sense to me!!!! I mean, 'Roger and Garp teamed up to protect Celestial Dragons and their slaves' is obvious gaslighting on Oda's part lmao I 5,500,000,000% agree that there is way more to it than that. Maybe an Ancient Weapon involved?
and yeah, 'Oh yeah so totes randoze everybody--but Garp, some CDs and their slaves, the strongest pirate crew to ever exist, 3 outa 4 yonko, and this bro named gold roger all just happened to be on this same island (that isn't raftel) at the same time as one another.' RIP IM DEAD ODA I CAN'T
Thanks for enjoying my hype thoughts :ROFLMAO:
Im baffled it makes sense. That way the god valley incident was probably forging the ideals of Dragon.
I still feel that maybe Garp got blackmailed to join the marines. Maybe he has no other choice plus there is an inner drive. Explains how he was able to connect with Roger...AT SUCH A YOUNG AGE. Both were in their twenties and they were rookies.
I thought Garp was in his later 60s though :blobcoolthink if he's 50s he's definitely Hot stage George Clooney.
 
Messages
45
Reaction score
371
Points
825
Salty Doubloons
200
Best chapter ever, such a great storytelling... I just want a flashback about Garp and Roger teaming up against Rocks. Please sense... :toolazy:
 
Last edited:
Messages
5,349
Reaction score
21,907
Points
16,150
Salty Doubloons
2,479
When you think about it, it was Law who started all this with leading Luffy to defeat Doffy. At the end of the day, this is the type of shit that Law wanted. Absolute chaos and a disruption of the peace that the old generation created in the new world.
 
Messages
45
Reaction score
371
Points
825
Salty Doubloons
200
The island Blackbeard was shown is the same as Garp fought against Rocks.
No, the island Roger and Garp fought against Rocks was God Valley. Kurohige's island is Beehive island, the island where the Rocks pirates were formed as a crew.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom