[FIN] Regular Mafia Round 18: Fate/ Mafia

Messages
1,112
Reaction score
1,332
Points
4,650
Salty Doubloons
1,485
Sorry, but with 2 people with hard evidence, I didn't want to drag it any further.

GG, everyone. Congrats to winners.

Thanks for hosting, Mango and Rej.
Thanks for joining, and it was a valiant effort.
Though your loss of Chris Mic that early was a huge blow. Honestly think you had a great chance of winning if you didn't lose him that early, lmao.
 

ZFR

Messages
116
Reaction score
80
Points
675
Salty Doubloons
134
Thanks for joining, and it was a valiant effort.
Though your loss of Chris Mic that early was a huge blow. Honestly think you had a great chance of winning if you didn't lose him that early, lmao.
Can you post what actions happened each Night (and the RNGs)?

Regarding feeback: While a rolemadness in itself can be difficult for Mafia, since towards the end of the game, Town can start confirming themselves with their roles. However, it can still be fun.
What I would like to be changed however, is to give less feedback of Night actions during Day start. Since you practically list what actions took place, it becomes extremely difficult for Mafia to lie about doing something they didn't do.
Also I think the players themselves should be given less feedback about their actions and any actions taken on them. Unless your role is investigative in nature, you shouldn't be told (your action failed/succeeded... etc). You submit your actions, look at the bodies next Day and try to figure out what happened).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Messages
11,531
Reaction score
35,886
Points
28,800
Salty Doubloons
323
Thanks for the game bud. I don't deserve this win. I threw it.
 
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
1,332
Points
4,650
Salty Doubloons
1,485
Can you post what actions happened each Night (and the RNGs)?
I can post at a later time, I only have for the current nightphase, as I just noted it down on notepad, and cleared it each new phase.
Regarding feeback: While a rolemadness in itself can be difficult for Mafia, since towards the end of the game, Town can start confirming themselves with their roles. However, it can still be fun.
What I would like to be changed however, is to give less feedback of Night actions during Day start. Since you practically list what actions took place, it becomes extremely difficult for Mafia to lie about doing something they didn't do.
Yeah, The plan was to have just a fully anonymous writeup, but I got the better of myself and tried using aliases, but I defintely went too far. I probably should have backtracked, but I thought I had to be consistent. But I'm definitely noting this for future reference.
I realize in hindsight it's really bad for Mafia, but in your defense nobody read the writeups anyway :pepelaugh:
I mean you had a major slip, but nobody caught it.
Also I think the players themselves should be given less feedback about their actions and any actions taken on them. Unless your role is investigative in nature, you shouldn't be told (your action failed/succeeded... etc). You submit your actions, look at the bodies next Day and try to figure out what happened).
I'm pretty sure this game mode in general people will know what happens to them.
But I'd defnitely not do this informative WU style again, I'll keep it more standardized in the future, if any.

Again thanks for the feedback!
Thanks for the game bud. I don't deserve this win. I threw it.
Haha, I was like you're not actually gonna do this, are you?
But well there you go lmao.

I pretty much made town a bit too stacked all things considered. Was doing this to compensate, though I think I pretty much overconpensated.
 

ZFR

Messages
116
Reaction score
80
Points
675
Salty Doubloons
134
Ah, part of me wishes now I at least saw this Day through to see if I could at least get 1 mislynch. Then concede at Night.
 
Messages
4,277
Reaction score
7,600
Points
9,450
Salty Doubloons
5,382
Sorry, but with 2 people with hard evidence, I didn't want to drag it any further.
Had to check the one that buddied me Day 1.

And I had to check out my tinfoil about this one.
A magnificent leader knew exactly what was going on, though he knows that he himself cannot do things himself, that's why he has such a way with words, he rallied someone he knew he could rely on.
As I mentioned in my role PM the only real Bastard mechanic in this Game was giving me the role I received. Mafia had no chance of winning without being able to scratch me the first 3 Night Phases.

Also sry If someone felt offended by me. I was forced to talk they way I talked.
 
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
1,332
Points
4,650
Salty Doubloons
1,485
Honestly. Town had too many investigation abilities.
Yep I overcompensated for the clear Mafia favored winrate on this forum since the "relaunch", since thread game is like it is, scums usually comes out of it on the winning end. But I do definitely agree that I might've gone overboard
 
Messages
179
Reaction score
130
Points
2,725
Salty Doubloons
179
Yep I overcompensated for the clear Mafia favored winrate on this forum since the "relaunch", since thread game is like it is, scums usually comes out of it on the winning end. But I do definitely agree that I might've gone overboard
The game ended the moment we started confirming each other. Mafia never stood a chance
 
Messages
114
Reaction score
51
Points
425
Salty Doubloons
114
I think Town might have killed more Townies than Anti Town did lol
 
Messages
54
Reaction score
14
Points
75
Salty Doubloons
54
Yeah, it was pretty townsided, but I had fun! ZFR played well, he just got screwed by cop checks
 
Messages
113
Reaction score
29
Points
260
Salty Doubloons
116
didn't use any power two nights in a row and scum conceded lol
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rej

Rej

Messages
4,833
Reaction score
12,800
Points
12,450
Salty Doubloons
90,447
Thanks for playing everyone!

This is the first time I coached someone and then even in a foreign mode while being busy. :pepeclown:
If any mistakes were made then I partake in those and not everything is Mango's fault. After all he did good job to bring an entertaining but swingy game from that we both me and Mango can learn. Nevertheless town used alot of actions correctly and against mafia they lost their scum competition which could help in decimating town. Sadly due to the swing of nature in swingy games the game fell into the hands of town.

As also stated this game was experimental and we learned alot. Glad that the new peeps also played it and enjoyed themselves, thank you!

I won't rate anyone here, everyone is an experienced player, some put more effort some put less it is how it is. I just wasn't proud of Nessos claiming/hinting his flavour, I wasn't there in time to judge about it and due to some misunderstandings forgot about the fact that it was modkill worthy based on the rules. This goes on me, else I am looking forward to see Mango grow as a host, gotta still learn alot tho but I see alot of potential in Mango's capabilities.:pepesmug:


Also just to mention: the calendar is empty you guys can line up for hosting if anyone wants to! I would also prefer to see some classic traditional mafia again. I really would like to host myself but I am currently too busy this month...
 
Top Bottom