[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
And you've voted for Ona, Juliet, Gambit, and myself and no one is talking about how scummy that was.
:datea:
Yes, I did, Shottie, yes I did. Blame joby for giving me so many shades.




But you suspect Drago, too, right? So don't you find it odd only those two read him as Town when legit all other players don't?
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
Ted and Drago are a scum team or it is scum leeching on a townie.

As for who might be third scum i can see Rej
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
As it's been noted
"I onLy HaVE rEaDS oN OreKi :pepega: "

So I have no idea where you got that I sussed Drago at any given time.
:datea:
Your game notes :datea: . Duh. Like...I have suspected other people, too, and yet you say I tunneled Gambit for 96 hours straight. Just like you remember my tunnel I remember yours. Can we stop the fight now and focus on working together? Thanks.
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
Your game notes :datea: . Duh. Like...I have suspected other people, too, and yet you say I tunneled Gambit for 96 hours straight. Just like you remember my tunnel I remember yours. Can we stop the fight now and focus on working together? Thanks.
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
My notes and reads are all given for today by your instance might I add.
My case against you Stray Cat is building, why else do I need to be productive this DP? Your scum push on Ted is ridiculous. You were arguing with him when he claimed I was a town read and you did you "stress test" on me. I still don't understand how that helped you when you're still stuck on the 2 posts Joby made. Oh wait and her post claiming Gambit was town. My bad. 3 post Joby made last week.
What happened to your sus on Law suddenly, was that faked?
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
My notes and reads are all given for today by your instance might I add.
My case against you Stray Cat is building, why else do I need to be productive this DP? Your scum push on Ted is ridiculous. You were arguing with him when he claimed I was a town read and you did you "stress test" on me. I still don't understand how that helped you when you're still stuck on the 2 posts Joby made. Oh wait and her post claiming Gambit was town. My bad. 3 post Joby made last week.
What happened to your sus on Law suddenly, was that faked?
You know I wouldn't have had to do that if some Townies just stopped playing so scummy, right? What would you do if somebody tried discrediting your points as much as joby did to me or if somebody became all defensive over you just stating your first impressions like Gambit did? If you could place yourself in the situation I'm in, you'd do the same. Oh wait, you're doing it right now. Your case against me is logical enough from a Town's perspective.

We are both Town. We literally just did the same thing. So can you please get your game together? Thank you!

And it's not only Ted, but also Drago, Oko, Rej and Samael I'm focusing on.


Drago said Sam's votes on Beky and you were horseshit. Why would he say that when Beky is his main scum read? And Sam already stated he suspects Beky a while back?

Then enter Ted. He doesn't mind Drago joining him on the Beky wagon. Both read each other as Town for some reason. And he legit doesn't read Beky's posts at all. Either he's a really stubborn Townie and Drago is capitalizing on that or they are scum buddies.


Samael's play reminds me whole lot of his last game on NF, so much that I'm having a dejavu.

He keeps pushing a player for a petty reason (Ted's backpedalling).
He keeps buddying with me and Ted.
He keeps pushing for Drago who I read as scum. He does like bussing as scum. Also pushed for Drago last time, too, when they were on a team.
Also, he was distancing himself from all main wagons.


Okosan is another weird case. Read me and Gambit correctly, suspects Ted and Wai when both were arguing and then somehow voted Wai.

Rej is buddying with you and Ted now and tries painting me as scum.

I really think the scums are amongst the five players I listed now.


Possible teams:

Samael, Rej and Drago.

Visible dynamics between Rej and Samael, Samael and Drago with Rej pretty distanced from Drago, despite Town reading him?

Ted, Drago and Rej:

Ted and Drago are openly buddying. Rej has dynamics with Ted. Still distanced from Drago.


Okosan, Ted and Drago:

Although this constellation would be weird.


Okosan, Ted and Rej:

General Town read on Drago, Ted and Rej could now be bussing Oko.



Law doesn't fit there due to lack of dynamics with my other suspects.
 
Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
lol bro that was a paranoia read you are neutral until people or I myself change my mind sometimes you are townier sometimes less...paranoia. same as I have it with Stray.

The same scummyness as you have it

@tedxtr Stray proved to lose her cool this DP and after rehunching the current DP I rly feel she could be scum.

I am at page 122 (catching up at work).
Shotties read on Stray is something I agree on. It makes me think Shottie and Flower are counter aligned. One of them is scum. I like Shottie more.

@Okosan why Gambit was clear town? I suspect you of a TMI read there. But ill give you time to explain and keep on making cases.
[automerge]1587551789[/automerge]

Will after I am home. Note me.
Cooooooo! (Okosan mentioned in his reads on D2 how Gambit was just town, and how scum didn't really want to jump in on that early argument that day even though it was "scummy" because it would reflect badly on them later for pushing the easy mislynch. He probably listed other things, though Okosan can't remember how much he posted in thread and how much Okosan just kept in his notes)

COOO? (Nobody even tried to direct the thread in a new direction really. Which if Gambit was scum in that scenario, and the two teammates didn't want to publicly read Gambit town to help, is what they should've been doing)
[automerge]1587556435[/automerge]
Coooo! (It's why Okosan is pretty sure both are just town. Unless mafia has that much faith their partner can come out on top in that argument. Which feels very iffy)
[automerge]1587556609[/automerge]
COO! (We literally just need to lynch any of Wai, Ted, or Oreki today. All of them have been on the leading wagon lynching town. Those three all voted Gambit last, which if they were scum following the plan that Okosan posted is when they would have felt comfortable voting. And Okosan still scum reads the first two in the first place. With Oreki just being null at the moment)
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
You know I wouldn't have had to do that if some Townies just stopped playing so scummy, right? What would you do if somebody tried discrediting your points as much as joby did to me or if somebody became all defensive over you just stating your first impressions like Gambit did? If you could place yourself in the situation I'm in, you'd do the same. Oh wait, you're doing it right now. Your case against me is logical enough from a Town's perspective.
It's HILARIOUS that you think pleading with me this day period will erase my read on you.
 
Messages
453
Reaction score
746
Points
1,750
Salty Doubloons
658
Cooo! Cooo! (There's guaranteed at least 1 mafia in that group of three)
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
It's HILARIOUS that you think pleading with me this day period will erase my read on you.
Do whatever makes you happy, then. I stated my points and won't waste my time arguing with you.
[automerge]1587556842[/automerge]
Cooo! Cooo! (There's guaranteed at least 1 mafia in that group of three)
What is your take on Rej?
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
Man reading this guy going COOO makes me laugh every time

It's HILARIOUS that you think pleading with me this day period will erase my read on you.
My lady. Can i borrow you from stray cat for a second
 

Shottie

Wait... whaaaaa?
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
5,256
Points
8,950
Salty Doubloons
119,096
My lady. Can i borrow you from stray cat for a second
I will give you one additional tidbit.
You and Ted are having similar reads but you don't like that because he's taken lead.
:sarcasticshottie:
 
Messages
3,336
Reaction score
10,079
Points
9,000
Salty Doubloons
1,061
I will give you one additional tidbit.
You and Ted are having similar reads but you don't like that because he's taken lead.
:sarcasticshottie:
Bullshit. Dude's reads until now were Waindo, Wainduh, Wai, Waindo and me, then when he got called out for tunneling he threw out a random sus list.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom