[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

[Rej]

Rej
Stray Cat
Shottie
Ted
Okosan/Nessos
Gambit
Oreki
Trafalgar Law
Samael
Waindo
Beky
Michelle

I partially agree with this list, I would just put Michelle into the green with ted, and I am unsure where Beky, Gambo and Trafa are staying.
I like ted's cases on Wai and I would vote there. I think you might just misinterprete Michelle's playstyle. But I will wait for her to reply. She celebrates Eastern today and we still have almost a full day.

I am still catching up.
[automerge]1587328240[/automerge]

Rej taking a backseat is also quite weird tbh.

today people around me celebrate eastern and I take a bit time for myself, I don't feel like throwing in unneccessary statements or get involved in a tizzy so I try to be accurate and still give my thoughts without participating in the big flood, I will probably be more active later and tomorrow

 

[tedxtr]

Waindo, the citizens of the Town City don’t wish to deport you into Lazy Gallows, you may have won the battle for some weird reason but you have not won the battle

I need to sleep

 

[Stray Cat]

I partially agree with this list, I would just put Michelle into the green with ted, and I am unsure where Beky, Gambo and Trafa are staying.
I like ted's cases on Wai and I would vote there. I think you might just misinterprete Michelle's playstyle. But I will wait for her to reply. She celebrates Eastern today and we still have almost a full day.

I am still catching up.
[automerge]1587328240[/automerge]

today people around me celebrate eastern and I take a bit time for myself, I don't feel like throwing in unneccessary statements or get involved in a tizzy so I try to be accurate and still give my thoughts without participating in the big flood, I will probably be more active later and tomorrow

It's alright, man. Take your time. I was just sayin'.

 

[Dragomir]

Funny is when I said to him his posts have an agenda he completely ignored that, too.

Cool tinfoil, do you have any evidence that supports this agenda theory?

I did a really good job at ignoring that didn't I?

 

[Dragomir]

Why would you answer when you don't want to make things clear from the get go?
I see now what Ona saw when he said you are scum.

I am a mood based player. At that time I wasn't in the right mood. I was doing what I felt like. Now, I'm fine and sober. You may ask any question you'd like.

 

[tedxtr]

Drago vote Waindo and remain under my protection

 

[Okosan]

Coooooooo! (Alright so this might take a really long time / Okosan might start skimming or skipping a bit once he gets a little bit through and has all these initial reads set up already. Here are some highlights from Okosan's notes though. He'll try to keep these posts brief as until Okosan gets to more relevant posts he understands that a lot of this isn't relevant anymore

First 10 pages

Biggest Scum Reads: Ted and Oreki. As of right now Okosan really feels like there's always at least a scum between these two for a variety of reasons. First off Ted,

Spoiler: Ted

Basically this Ted read comes from two things Okosan has seen so far. First off is that Ted seems so... hesitant? The whole time. There's a lot of examples of this early. First Ted pushes Michelle by expressing a similar opinion as Ona did, but then backed off and seemed unsure about himself.

I mean I don't necessarily disagree with how you view it, I am just a little psyched out about how you went around your read and the confidence behind it, I guess.
[automerge]1586977602[/automerge]

Good post if you're scum, because that made me feel less tempted to chase you.

This whole post reeks of not wanting to push anything too early with too strong of a read. Another example of this indecisiveness is here. This post is in regards to Rej pushing how ted came to the conclusion that Ona's town core was all correct, and that Stray was scum

I mean it’s not something insane to think about. I don’t see why a wolf would crumble there and try that hard to stand out unless town was doing incredible and Stray’s wolf buds weren’t there so she wanted to derail somehow. Discrediting the person building the flawless town core might create that reaction.

Basically, I don’t see a wolf spazing out there unless it’s for that exact reason. There was nothing else to be psyched out about, she wasn’t being pushed.

It was just something off the cuff I guess.
[automerge]1586983234[/automerge]
I don’t think I scum read Stray anymore though, I’ll have more coherent and confident takes tomorrow, as said. Right now I’m observing until I fall asleep.

Notice though how Ted is infinitely more unsure abut explaining his read about the town core than about how Stray was scum. Ted was innately more confident about that, even if ted does go on to backtrack on it later in the post just a tad

Second off has to do with what Okosan just talked about with Ted pushing Stray Cat (who Okosan is reading as town btw) and how that seemed like the easiest push ever. Will get more into that later

Next off Oreki
This read isn't as developed as Ted's and does rely on Ted's a little bit, but Okosan still feels it's worth mentioning. There are also two reasons for this read. First off is Oreki's first real post in this game.

 

[tedxtr]

Ok my PoE isn’t that bad, Okosan is still probably scum

Who did he replace again?

 

[Dragomir]

Drago vote Waindo and remain under my protection

How about you do me this favor Ted? I want you to pinpoint the shallow reasoning I had against Michelle. I've seen it be called that a lot but I just can't find any explanation for why. You think you could do that for me?

 

[tedxtr]

Ok I’ll just let him talk because it’s a page 10 read, I’ll see how he develops it in the morning

 

[Dragomir]

Ok my PoE isn’t that bad, Okosan is still probably scum

Who did he replace again?

Nessos.

 

[tedxtr]

How about you do me this favor Ted? I want you to pinpoint the shallow reasoning I had against Michelle. I've seen it be called that a lot but I just can't find any explanation for why. You think you could do that for me?

You could ask the people calling it shallow.

 

[Stray Cat]

I did a really good job at ignoring that didn't I?

Yep. You brushed the agenda "theory" off like your usual scum self. You obviously have an agenda...to convince others that Michelle is scum. Are you denying that now?

 

[Shottie]

Ok I’ll just let him talk because it’s a page 10 read, I’ll see how he develops it in the morning

to be fair in those first couple pages of posts I wasn't even seeing you.

 

[Trafalgar Law]

Ok my PoE isn’t that bad, Okosan is still probably scum

Who did he replace again?

You know what ? You are basically calling everyone scum who point out finger at you...
Let him finish his read first...this post look bad
[automerge]1587329188[/automerge]

Ok I’ll just let him talk because it’s a page 10 read, I’ll see how he develops it in the morning

Yup...! That's how you response

 

[tedxtr]

You know what ? You are basically calling everyone scum who point out finger at you...
Let him finish his read first...this post look bad
[automerge]1587329188[/automerge]

Yup...! That's how you response

Hello guy that claims to not have read any of my wallposts where I also clear people calling me scum among other things

 

[Dragomir]

You could ask the people calling it shallow.

Will you do it or not?

Yep. You brushed the agenda "theory" off like your usual scum self. You obviously have an agenda...to convince others that Michelle is scum. Are you denying that now?

What the hell? I literally asked you for the evidence. How the hell is that brushing it off?

Are you fucking with me Flower? This is the big bad agenda that you're talking about? Oh my goodness...

 

[Dragomir]

@Trafalgar Law do you actually scum.read me or do you just want to lynch me for info?

 

[Oreki]

I mean, one year meta is a lot. Do you think she’d need more than that?

Yep... She'd need more than that if she consider me mafia lol

 

[Dragomir]

Will you do it or not?


What the hell? I literally asked you for the evidence. How the hell is that brushing it off?

Are you fucking with me Flower? This is the big bad agenda that you're talking about? Oh my goodness...

@tedxtr you see this nonsense and you want me to ask the people that say my reasons are shallow?