[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

[Stray Cat]

how? when i flip town?

You flipping anything could help me reevaluate stuff. But for now you seem better. Although you could just be pulling an Igner again.

 

[Nessos]

With my first post I expected to get an reaction from the accused players Joby and Gambit.
Instead I got a salty reaction from Michelle. She countered my post by downplaying it not waiting for the response of Gambits or Joby. For me an active defense Not letting anyone throw shade in her. Thats why I called her defensive.
Then Beky jumps in "how dare you making Michelle mad, she is towniest town, I perfectly know her play. If you ever talk bad about it once again I will misslynch you" (This Kind of reaction super scummy for me thats why I voted for him)
Then you comes into play "OMG Nessos the destinated misslynch". Loved your whole analysis but that one part was scummy af, a tipical "I told you post". Called you out for it, but never got a real response and you became more and more scummy for me, just these lowmey shade based on the one Towngame from me you read through.

Law get Towncreds for me having the balls to call out Beky for what I got harrased.

Its super hard for me to read Gambit, we played Town and Scum so many times successfully together, we know many our tactics and thoughts. Its so hard he knows what to post.

I really like Onadagawagalaga play. Its super hard to read him, he is like the perfect neighbour, but I can't say If there skeletons in his closet.

Michelle Townread so far, couldn't find anything bad about her play.

Jobys play is unreasonable I am just waiting for a slip. Was hoping to get some reactions frim.my buddy bait.

I really don't like Dragos shitty counterquestioning "How do you yourself think about it?". People ask questions to get reactions and instead of Firmung something himself he acts smart with counterquestiong. Thats just weird.

Stray tend to have tunnelvision in everygame on me. So far nothing changed, so I keep ignoring most of her post.

Oreki easily jumps on the self-running trains which gives me scumvibes.

Not much to say about Samael and Poison, they are quote inactive.

And Rej, well Rej is Rej the pro
If he is scum I am sure he is going to slip otherwise he is town.

My tunnelvision so far

And sure Juliet is missing she is genuine Town for menso far. And Orekis push against her gives him some extra scumcreds

 

[Gambit]

You flipping anything could help me reevaluate stuff. But for now you seem better. Although you could just be pulling an Igner again.

lol. so you telling me that when i flip town, it will give info who the scum is or clarify drago's alignment?

 

[Stray Cat]

lol. so you telling me that when i flip town, it will give info who the scum is or clarify drago's alignment?

A bit of both. Because it opens a new view on things. But for now I don't want to lynch you. Do you have any reads so far?

 

[Rej]

I hate doing lists since i tell my stuff through the game anyway but fine just for you since i don't want no more pocket sand i'll repeat most stuff i said

Dragomir - Like i said , he is calm and collected from his usual self. He thinks before speaks and isn't afraid to ask questions. He isn't static he is active and will push the game forward anyway he can. His small questions are not something i generally consider scummy, i like to ask small questions too to generate responses and view points. He did same this game and most of the questions he asked had an ending point of him developing certain read. He smells townie to me

Michelle - Idk what more to say. Player with her enough to know how she is and no one can change my mind

Rej - He has same chaotic energy as Gambit but unlike Gambit his energy is meme enough i can read it. If you read past his meme stuff and crazy theories i actually see someone focused on the game and willing to push it to the end. Big boy points for me there so i see him as townie

tedxtr - Dislike him, cherry picking posts , doesn't bother to iso, ignores posts by accident or purpose, doesn't wanna argue when it doesn't fit him and had a crap defense for Nessos. All around there isn't anything i particularly like about him this game - smells scummy

Poison Chan - I honestly can't remember anything of notice when it comes to her. Most stuff i remember is her telling she is busy - null

Juliet - Didn't pay attention to juliet this game which isn't something that usually happens. Juliet is a very good player and her posts overall stick in my eyes. So far not one did for some reason - null

joby/Gambit - I'll just be honest here and say i gave up on these two. I played enough games with them i just don't have mental fortitude to deal with their chaotic energy

Nessos - Stubborn, arrogant and all around pain to deal with. He will call you scum for solely responding to him and then will play a victim. This game he didn't do anything to push the game forward. His posts are static like a thunder rod and it will suck in an endless loop of arguing with someone who doesn't care what you say - scum smell

Samael - I am a dick , he is a dick and i love dick players. He feels quite confident for someone who just joined and was target of several scum reads. I see no panic in his words only confidence. townie smell

Stray Cat - I didn't like few of her posts early on but she made up on it with composure and smart approach to situations. I so far like what i am seeing from her and i am happy i was right when i said she is a force to be reckoned with when focused

Trafalgar Law - He came in late but wasn't afraid to but heads. I respect that. Radiates big dick energy - townie smell

Onadaga - I see you as a mentor like figure this game. Most of the stuff you said is to direct players in a right direction. That in itself is enough for me. You aren't static

Oreki - He is sleepy to me, he doesn't bother to leave a good impression but coincidentally he leaves a good impression doing that. I like his relaxed attitude and it is def a positive sign to me - townie smell

I wanted to comment on this, I can see where you come from with most of your reads, they are genuine, I think sometimes people are destinied to disagree, we have no common scumreads but the same strong townread. I like it for some reasons. Something to begin with.


adding this:
Catching up the past 4 pages makes me wanna smoke another. Ngl XD Sheeeeesh.
[automerge]1587070518[/automerge]

Nessos, Gambit, and joby were getting scum read the most by most of the players. I was feeling wary a scum player would want to focus on those 3 players if they are really town or if there is scum in one of those players. I never do pushes and I'm the kind of player who wants to make sure if my read is right first and then I will vote. I also wanted to hear more from you afterwards.

Nessos is always an enigma for me and I scum read him a lot. This one post I found from Nessos looked like something town would say. What did you think of Nessos post I quoted? joby is a new player who gets scum read a lot and she is always hard to read. Gambit is also one of those players who is always hard to read and he came off aggressive.

even with a vote on her she is collected, I like that Juliet, town Juliet is a slow starter and she makes her own progress, chases her own PoE and presents it, quite natural, hmmm

Unvote

I dont see Juliet as scum anymore, for now

 

[Oreki]

And sure Juliet is missing she is genuine Town for menso far. And Orekis push against her gives him some extra scumcreds

Is that how you imagine I'd play as scum within a game of scale of this many vocal players? ._.

 

[Stray Cat]

Is that how you imagine I'd play as scum within a game of scale of this many vocal players? ._.

Are you doing WIFOM ?

 

[Rej]

Gambit accuses Dragomir and there is some slight possibility Drago could be scum. Thought a Gambit lynch would clarify things on that.

how? when i flip town?

I dislike the irrationality there in these statements lmao, both of ya

 

[Stray Cat]

Btw we should consider the post limit, looking at you @Onadaga .

 

[Oreki]

Are you doing WIFOM ?

Nah... I just wanted to see how would he reply. He seems to be cautious of me yet he seems to not doing anything about it
[automerge]1587071080[/automerge]
Also, I will head to bed now... Night.

 

[Stray Cat]

Nah... I just wanted to see how would he reply. He seems to be cautious of me yet he seems to not doing anything about it

That's an interesting take on things. That goes with what Beky said about him being static and my take on things, too. Yeah, guess you're Town.
[automerge]1587071219[/automerge]
Will be observing now to save up some posts for tomorrow morning.
[automerge]1587071254[/automerge]
So good night in advance!

 

[Nessos]

The post counting on TB is super flawed.
@novaselinenever how do you handleerged double post and on the other hand the not merging double posts of coaches?

Does @Beky and @Dragomir has a disadvantage?
(Or one may call it Advantage since they seem to be more active if one look at the flawed post count )
[automerge]1587071637[/automerge]

Nah... I just wanted to see how would he reply. He seems to be cautious of me yet he seems to not doing anything about it

And thats what I mean with others responding too fast not waiting for the reaction of the called Out player.

It doesn't matter what I respond now. It will called out as "slip". Either one would call me cautious or stubborn.
[automerge]1587074455[/automerge]
I think I have to prepare myself that my Game will be called static by Stray in every game from here on out. This will be a pain

Little sidenote for the guestplayers thats the way how you get the MVP awards in this forum

 

[Rej]

Aye I will go to bed, quite super tired today, will revisit my other weaker reads "tomorrow". Good night!

 

[Samael]

Gambit accuses Dragomir and there is some slight possibility Drago could be scum. Thought a Gambit lynch would clarify things on that.

I may have you mixed with someone else but what are your thoughts on Dragomir exactly?

Suspicion has to be there Or am I reading wrong.

Not feeling anyone who’s putting to much into reads, it’s to early.

 

[Stray Cat]

I may have you mixed with someone else but what are your thoughts on Dragomir exactly?

Suspicion has to be there Or am I reading wrong.

Not feeling anyone who’s putting to much into reads, it’s to early.

Personally I'm reading him as Town, but I'm not excluding a possibility that he could be scum. What Gambit did looked like deflecting to me, so a lynch on him could clarify if it was sincere suspicion on Dragomir or just deflecting, depending on his flip.

However, rn I would not go for a Gambit lynch, but for a Nessos lynch. Because Nessos vs Beky gives off TvW vibes.

Town vs Town: Nessos' defense is too weak while Beky seems strong compared to him. Given how Nessos usually plays a weak defense is no good look on him. Especially since his mockery regarding me seems faked this time. So I'm leaning towards TvW.


Although we cannot exclude WvW here either since their behaviour towards Michelle could have been a good scum, bad scum scenario in which the one player acts scummy towards a Townie and the other friendly. Then they fight and it doesn't matter who of them gets lynched because the other would gain Town creds for this.
In this case the third scum would be neither of Gambit, joby, Michelle and Onadaga who Nessos and Beky buddied with respectively, but likely somebody more distanced and not or only slightly involved in this like Poison chan or Law.

What makes the latter scenario less likely in my book is my Town read on Beky. His behaviour towards me and his reevaluating of me seem natural and not faked, so this is why I'm leaning Town towards him. So this is just some food for thought as of now.


And now Good Night, will come back later this DP.

 

[Dragomir]

Why are so many people town reading me? I'm on page 26 right now.

 

[novaselinenever]

Vote Count

Onadaga – Gambit > Dragomir > Gambit > Beky > Dragomir
Dragomir – Nessos
Nessos – Beky > Nessos
Tedxter – Beky > Samael > Beky > joby > Nessos
Stray Cat – Samael > Gambit > Nessos
Oreki – Nessos
Michelle – Gambit
Gambit – Gambit
Rej – Juliet > *

Total -

Nessos – 5
Gambit – 2
Dragomir – 1

Spoiler: Vote History

Vote: Gambit

Vote Lynch Nessos

Vote lynch Beky

Vote : Beky

Vote lynch Samael.

Vote : Samael

Vote lynch Gambit.

Vote Lynch Nessos

Vote lynch: Gambit

Vote lynch: Dragomir

Vote lynch Gambit

Vote lynch Onadaga

Vote : Beky

Vote: Becky

Vote lynch @Juliet

Vote: Dragomir

Unvote.
Vote lynch Nessos.

Vote : joby

Vote : Nessos

Vote lynch Nessos

Unvote

 

[Dragomir]

then tell us where do you place him here?
his play on the other game running right now is similar to what he has been doing today.. is he a scum?

Mafia Drago =/= SK Drago. Big difference. SK Drago plays a lot more like Town Drago. But, it all won't matter at the end cause I'm going to fix this meta shit. Can't be out here having a meta.

 

[novaselinenever]

Post Count -

Reminder - Each individual player may make a maximum of 150 posts* per day phase. This restriction is lifted 2 hours before the deadline, that is 12 p.m EST.

@Onadaga - 112
@Stray Cat - 111
@tedxtr - 85
@Beky - 77
@Dragomir - 53
@Rej - 47
@Gambit - 42
@Nessos - 41
@Michelle - 41
@Oreki - 35
@Trafalgar Law - 13
@Juliet - 9
@Samael - 9
@Poison Chan - 7

*Merged posts count as 1 until further notice.​

 

[Gambit]

Post Count -

Reminder - Each individual player may make a maximum of 150 posts* per day phase. This restriction is lifted 2 hours before the deadline, that is 12 p.m EST.

@Onadaga - 112
@Stray Cat - 111
@tedxtr - 85
@Beky - 77
@Dragomir - 53
@Rej - 47
@Gambit - 42
@Nessos - 41
@Michelle - 41
@Oreki - 35
@Trafalgar Law - 13
@Juliet - 9
@Samael - 9
@Poison Chan - 7

*Merged posts count as 1 until further notice.​

Ona and Stray sure are noisy clasmates.. Lol
Oreki this doesn't sound like you are sleepy at all. More like sneaky. But meh.
[automerge]1587083348[/automerge]

Mafia Drago =/= SK Drago. Big difference. SK Drago plays a lot more like Town Drago. But, it all won't matter at the end cause I'm going to fix this meta shit. Can't be out here having a meta.

Ok.