[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

[Rej]

Yeah, reading back...Nessos is just annoying Town... . He does scum hunting, at least, but I'm not liking him mocking everyone who suspects him. Beky vs Nessos seems like TvT to me now.

Vote lynch Gambit.


Don't really get why he'd vote for Michelle in the first place tbh.
[automerge]1587123554[/automerge]
@Rej Nessos is just annoying Town. Unless he is toying with us and pretending I don't see how he could be scum anymore. Although he seems more cautious than usual.

Gambit on the other hand is scummy af.

Same goes for Onadaga, but this could be a case of too scummy to be scum. Although I did get some TMI vibes from him at the beginning. And how he defends Nessos gives me those vibes again. Could still be his experience, but we should be keeping this in mind for further reference.

Can you find the suspected TMI post of Onadaga? I found nothing scummy in his early game it just evolved as consistency break on a mental level.

 

[Stray Cat]

Can you find the suspected TMI post of Onadaga? I found nothing scummy in his early game it just evolved as consistency break on a mental level.

Back when he Town cleared Beky so quickly. Those posts are on Page 1 or Page 2 I think. Don't like how he did that given that Beky barely even posted anything back then.

 

[Shottie]

Oof. Now I suddenly remember why I was semi retired from Trad games.
I'm not going to be able to process many of these pages I missed atm. Too much circle talk, and I'm not sure if I'll be awake at EoD. Sooo, i'll probably have to catch up best I can when I wake up. Tag me if there's a clear suspect I should blind vote on.

 

[Stray Cat]

@Rej

V

perhaps a slight townread on becky. this is probably too ridicilous to come from scum

 

[Gambit]

vote lynch Gambit

I rly dont have to justify this vote. I just hope others see what I see.
[automerge]1587123028[/automerge]
Just came back from work, looking forward to play with Shottie tbh. I caught up, glad the pace went down. Now we can prepare for a proper EoD.

Onadaga is so utterly scummy but he is entertaining.

Ask me questions. And what do others think? Who is scummier/townier between Nessos and Gambit and why?

no you have to justify lol.

 

[Stray Cat]

Another thing I don't like was Onadaga bringing up the JOAT thing regarding Gambit and protecting him so much this game. This lowkey seemed like fishing for the JOATs because Gambit didn't give off PR vibes at all.

So I think I'm putting Onadaga on my neutral list for now since I don't know what to make of him yet tbh.

 

[Rej]

@Rej

V

I see, seems the very early posts are still jewels

no you have to justify lol.

Nah I firmly explained why Michelle is the worst D1 lynch and that she is a valuable player, no harmful intends.
I discredit your read accuracy since your early posts which makes me think you could be scum who couldn't form proper reads due to TMI. You are an entertainer this game but you also didn't manage to entertain me. Maybe it is some bias from my side but convince me differently.
I mean I see you are trying your best, but it is not AI from my perspective.

 

[Trafalgar Law]

Actually, I second Ted's scum read on Samael. Reading back he seems to be doing what he also did last game, tunneling on a minor thing and pushing people for a petty reason. I find Ted to be more Town-ish after their elaborate post and share of views, so I can assume Sam could be pushing for a mislynch and trying to capitalize on a Townie's "wrong move" which he implies ted's backpedalling was. Does that make sense to anyone?

Yes, that makes sense. You already memorized his scum meta from the NF game? Damn.

I think I'm more confident on Samael than Beky but I still think they're both scum. I endorse a Samael lynch just as much as I do a Beky lynch right now.

Yeah, Karma explained quite a lot in our Mason Chat. Fun time xD.
[automerge]1587034349[/automerge]
Vote lynch Samael.

I'm thinking he is a good lynch for this DP.

Page 14 ! This lineup is quite interesting....

Could elaborate on this a bit


why would he push someone just because their gut made them feel some type of way? That’s pretty iffy to me. It’s counter productive as well. It was a gut feeling based off your text so pushing them would result in what? Them listing false reasons possibly or just outright stating it’s a gut feeling again.


You backed off a bit here. Your previous post came off as extremely confident, don’t like the change of tone.

Above reactions were for this one post of Samael !!

Was it worth 2 votes on him..
So tell me...
Do you buy Ted / Stray / Drago reasoning...
Or which one do you think was genuine ? And Who's post was wolfy ? Or they all sound townish

 

[Stray Cat]

I see, seems the very early posts are still jewels

Nah I firmly explained why Michelle is the worst D1 lynch and that she is a valuable player, no harmful intends.
I discredit your read accuracy since your early posts which makes me think you could be scum who couldn't form proper reads due to TMI. You are an entertainer this game but you also didn't manage to entertain me. Maybe it is some bias from my side but convince me differently.
I mean I see you are trying your best, but it is not AI from my perspective.

Btw I asked Gambit for reads yesterday and still haven't gotten a reply yet .
[automerge]1587125766[/automerge]

Page 14 ! This lineup is quite interesting....

Above reactions were for this one post of Samael !!

Was it worth 2 votes on him..
So tell me...
Do you buy Ted / Stray / Drago reasoning...
Or which one do you think was genuine ? And Who's post was wolfy ? Or they all sound townish

I just played a game with Samael where he was scum and wanted to cause a mislynch using a similar reasoning. But his reaction to the accusation was fine, he faced the accusations head on and didn't try buddying with anyone yet. So this makes him Town in my book.

 

[Trafalgar Law]

Did Gambit share his reads...I checked couldn't find it...Michelle and Gambit locked votes on each other..!

 

[Stray Cat]

Did Gambit share his reads...I checked couldn't find it...Michelle and Gambit locked votes on each other..!

No, asked for his reads yesterday and he didn't give me anything yet.

 

[Trafalgar Law]

What was Oreki's OJ name ?

 

[novaselinenever]

Vote Count

Onadaga – Gambit > Dragomir > Gambit > Beky > Dragomir
Dragomir – Nessos
Nessos – Beky > Nessos > Tedxter
Tedxter – Beky > Samael > Beky > Shottie > Nessos
Stray Cat – Samael > Gambit > Nessos > Gambit
Oreki – Nessos > Juliet
Michelle – Gambit
Gambit – Gambit > Michelle
Rej – Juliet > Gambit

Total -

Gambit – 3
Nessos – 2
Juliet / Tedxter / Michelle / Gambit / Dragomir – 1

@Waindo has subbed in for Poison-Chan

Spoiler: Vote History

Vote: Gambit

Vote Lynch Nessos

Vote lynch Beky

Vote : Beky

Vote lynch Samael.

Vote : Samael

Vote lynch Gambit.

Vote Lynch Nessos

Vote lynch: Gambit

Vote lynch: Dragomir

Vote lynch Gambit

Vote lynch Onadaga

Vote : Beky

Vote: Becky

Vote lynch @Juliet

Vote: Dragomir

Unvote.
Vote lynch Nessos.

Vote : joby

Vote : Nessos

Vote lynch Nessos

Unvote

Vote lynch tedxtr

Vote Lynch Juliet

Vote lynch michelle

vote lynch Gambit

Vote lynch Gambit.

 

[Rej]

 

[Stray Cat]

I don't like this silence now.

 

[tedxtr]

Dead air dead villager?
[automerge]1587133082[/automerge]
Vote : Michelle

 

[Stray Cat]

Dead air dead villager?
[automerge]1587133082[/automerge]
Vote : Michelle

Can you explain that vote?

 

[tedxtr]

Michelle should be a way more confident town lean this game and I don't sense that at all.

She's not driving the game one way or the other.
[automerge]1587133311[/automerge]
She's firmly within my Null spot and I'd like to re-evaluate Beky and Shottie tomorrow, as well as the whole Nessos / everyone else beef. I feel like I need a reality check and to be reminded that the thing that loses town the most games is by focusing on town that do outrageous stuff rather than the silent scummy people.

Shottie / Michelle / Waidon should be points of contention tomorrow, all of them.
[automerge]1587133466[/automerge]
I feel like I have a somewhat average town core still, so a huge chunk of scum might actually be in my nulls

Which were Dragomir / juliet / Michelle / Trafalgar Law

I think Dragomir is town.

 

[Stray Cat]

Michelle should be a way more confident town lean this game and I don't sense that at all.

She's not driving the game one way or the other.
[automerge]1587133311[/automerge]
She's firmly within my Null spot and I'd like to re-evaluate Beky and Shottie tomorrow, as well as the whole Nessos / everyone else beef. I feel like I need a reality check and to be reminded that the thing that loses town the most games is by focusing on town that do outrageous stuff rather than the silent scummy people.

Shottie / Michelle / Waidon should be points of contention tomorrow, all of them.

Good point. Although ngl, but the timing of your vote made it seem like you are trying to get the attention away from Gambit who is the current lead wagon. Not to forget that he voted Michelle as well. This seems rather odd tbh.

 

[tedxtr]

I think Gambit is town.