[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
570
Reaction score
530
Points
1,950
Salty Doubloons
1,176
Rej first posts until his first reads and sorry for the wall

Ah don't worry I found out it's not worth to take the struggle and front you D1. Because emotional and angry Mich is hard to read.
[automerge]1586978118[/automerge]

but a past Michelle doesn't matter, what matters is the player right now xD
he could expose himself as mafia in a confrontation with me but he didn't give up to insert an early doubt.
that is interesting, pings me a bit as a deepwolfy persona, do you like to powertown and take lead or are you rather consistent and take a chill?
How he talked with a confirmed townie
what what what, how you came to this possible scenario my friend??

btw catching up but this instantly pinged me
idem
I also think Stray is town
tmi for anyone who wants a proof
No tbh he didn't sound frustrated, you should know ted is rational or his scumplay consists of wishthinking. He replied with sarcasm and sounded genuine I feel. Genuine is rational, no frustration. That's how I interpreted it
scummy analysis
Sounded pushy but okay, I am curious how you will proceed.
not w/w interaction
Maybe Pushy is still to hard for what I tried to express. But I found it interesting that your first take on the game was revisitting the ted/Rej interaction. I was just irritated that you interpreted him as frustrated, that made me think that your post was forged with another possible intend.
backtracking here. So not scum theathre.
How come you interpreted it as frustration
idem
You know that moment when Stray Cat got her ferocious eyes on you and raises her claws against you? While being a confused towny? That's the feel I got.
lol
Anyway to poison chan: I guess you cant make anything of the other reads too then? I mean we use them to find ourselves and see where one stands. The earlier reads the better town starts with a PoE.

I need to get behind your player impressions...alot of recap talk. Who is the towniest towny in your opinion?
idk how to think at this tbh
I second this. What you think about dragos minimalistic playstyle?
also i dislike the tone of this. Pocketing or buddying?
Werent you the one downplaying town dynamics and call it buddying? In your shady language.
Then dont wonder when town tackles you and downplays your statements. You are out of flow.
defending himself or moving scumchat itt?
Unconsciously calling town the ppl who are interacting with Nessos here. Nagl
What you prefer.
I will do one when home.
For now I side with those that suspect Nessos, joby, Samael, seems like a good lynchpool.
i can't think he put both his mates here, there is maximum one i think.
Dude what is "open buddying" it sounds so negative. They are just collabing imho. Seems like opportunistic townies try to convince people.

Gosh I am finally cought up, time to make reads baby and I second what Drago said. 48 hour DPs are nice :catcorn:
[automerge]1587046251[/automerge]

I see it like Nessos challenging people in his language he tries to say:
"Lynch me, and you will see for yourself, but still please put your focus on others too".
That is Nessos in short. Lmao.
forced joy. I think Nessos'slot is worthy to think at
I will, for me Nessos is unclear alignmentwise, but what he does is stupidly townish, I just dont get behind his ideas/agenda.
Do not quote me, except you have a huge question towards me or a case. I will go back to Dragos GTH read and do my own one.
It just will take 30-60 mins (since I just arrived home and I am going to smoke and reread the past half of the DP!
I am not gone!
Defending the slot in a weird way. Different that he was talking with Ted and Ona for sure.
RAINBOW


Rej mafia
tedxtr town
Michelle
Dragomir town
Stray Cat protected by Joat Ted when we didn't have NKs
Beky
Onadaga town

Nessos
Gambit town
Juliet town
joby
Poison Chan

Oreki
Samael


Trafalgar Law town

I feel like somewhere setting here, where blue represents the towncore, while I don't see myself as the most proactive player, but damn, this is just my own info 🤷 kapoapapp

It means everyone whos is green coloured might be able to shift redish, but for me personally I would lock 4 people town.
Maybe it is just uber metafeeling because I also use to play with Mich, ted and Poison in a community.
Hence why I am not townreading Poison yet and she has to gain her speed and input as hypothetial town. Dunno if it is just wishthinking but I like playing with her nevertheless.

Samael had a weird posts here I really want him to be revisitted this DP, also by others and we need him to give more input.
In the recent pages I miss Oreki being more deductive and taking less the backseat. Oreki is a player who likes to grasp opportunities and chase them, maybe that is what I miss.
@Oreki come join the read list fun and maybe I will change your placement.


Interesting list, I personally question your reads in those three and would wish some more thoughts about them, what do you mean with "meh"? Why is Sam good? What about Poison do you like? And what about Oreki do you dislike?


Also yes my rainbow is a more detailled GTH read list with multiple brackets. Red equals Dragos "bad" and blue equals Dragos "great".
(Statement is aimed at others, who ask themselves what is going on here rn :pepeclown: )
I personally don't like his questions i bolded

Being his upper reads of villagers except him, that means he put his mates in the middle of the list somewhere and in null should be one and Nessos fits perfectly.

In my oppinion Okosan is our next lynch, but i will continue to read and let this thought marinate.
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
Rej first posts until his first reads and sorry for the wall


he could expose himself as mafia in a confrontation with me but he didn't give up to insert an early doubt.

How he talked with a confirmed townie

idem

tmi for anyone who wants a proof

scummy analysis

not w/w interaction

backtracking here. So not scum theathre.

idem

lol

idk how to think at this tbh

also i dislike the tone of this. Pocketing or buddying?

defending himself or moving scumchat itt?
Unconsciously calling town the ppl who are interacting with Nessos here. Nagl

i can't think he put both his mates here, there is maximum one i think.

forced joy. I think Nessos'slot is worthy to think at

Defending the slot in a weird way. Different that he was talking with Ted and Ona for sure.


I personally don't like his questions i bolded

Being his upper reads of villagers except him, that means he put his mates in the middle of the list somewhere and in null should be one and Nessos fits perfectly.

In my oppinion Okosan is our next lynch, but i will continue to read and let this thought marinate.
I'm thinking it's either Sam+Hayumi or Sam+Okosan. Sam and Oko haven't interacted at all. And Oko's Town reads scream of TMI since Gambit, Drago and me are all Town.
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
Then we are on good track with Okosan
Rej, Samael, Hayumi and Oko were on my suspect list the DP before I was killed and protected.

Rej flipped scum and no need to try to kill me if it is only him. So either of those three others is a good lynch.

Samael would be my first pick because 1) Drago also suspected him and got killed and 2) He pushed Drago and with Drago being confirmed Town this DP he could have gone for Samael this DP.

Although I'm fine with the other two options, too.
[automerge]1588068347[/automerge]
Interesting posts here:

Coo!! (Unless Okosan is missing some vital piece of info, which is definitely possible, it doesn't really matter if Stray Cat is scummy or not today. We never lynch the person who was pretty likely confirmed as town by ted today. That's like, a final 5/3 lynch if Stray is still alive)
Here Oko suggests that I could be scum. But that lynching me would not be good.
Cooooo! (Oh yeah actually you know what we can no lynch this at some point to force scum to narrow it down. We don't lose a lynch by doing so, and we can't gain another at this point either. Okosan doesn't think we should do that today considering we probably just lose Stray, but that's something for tomorrow)
Here Oko says I would likely get killed.


How does this add up when he said I could be scum before?
[automerge]1588069347[/automerge]
@Beky what do you think about Oko?
[automerge]1588070665[/automerge]
Another inconsistency:

Cooo! (Something really interesting in the meantime (though it may have been discussed), Okosan finds it really interesting they killed a voter on the Juliet wagon last night. Sure Okosan can see why as Ona was pretty obviously town, but it's interesting right? If there was a lot of scum on that wagon Okosan thinks Ona is just never the kill there and you take out someone else strong instead. So Okosan thinks there's really max 1 scum voting Juliet yesterday)

How can he suspect Oreki and Wai and say that there was at max 1 scum on the Juliet wagon? When both of them voted Juliet?
Was it because only Rej was there of the scum team?
[automerge]1588071490[/automerge]
@Michelle @Beky @Oreki please state your top two suspects you wanna lynch this DP.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,336
Reaction score
10,079
Points
9,000
Salty Doubloons
1,061
I'm here, who's biting the dust? Do we have any info from Rej's before-lynch posts?
[automerge]1588073469[/automerge]
Is anyone planning going for Sam?
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
I'm here, who's biting the dust? Do we have any info from Rej's before-lynch posts?
[automerge]1588073469[/automerge]
Is anyone planning going for Sam?
We need to discuss the lynch.
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
Vote lynch Samael.

If I'm wrong here I gladly take the blame. But I don't see why scum would feel the need to cause confusion if we were on the wrong track.
 
Messages
934
Reaction score
834
Points
1,300
Salty Doubloons
956
I think Samael is the right choice here for reasons already explained. If he somehow flips town, Oko and Beky are most likely scum.
:pikachu:
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
I think Samael is the right choice here for reasons already explained. If he somehow flips town, Oko and Beky are most likely scum.
:pikachu:
Yeah, given their interactions and how salty Nessos was because of Beky's post I doubt that xD.
 
Messages
934
Reaction score
834
Points
1,300
Salty Doubloons
956
Yeah, given their interactions and how salty Nessos was because of Beky's post I doubt that xD.
I'm not sure if I missed something here, but I haven't seen much interaction at all between Beky and Oko, i.e distancing. I doubt Sam's going to flip town, but if he does, those two are on the top of my suspect list.
 
Messages
2,646
Reaction score
3,033
Points
7,450
Salty Doubloons
2,786
I'm not sure if I missed something here, but I haven't seen much interaction at all between Beky and Oko, i.e distancing. I doubt Sam's going to flip town, but if he does, those two are on the top of my suspect list.
Oko subbed in for Nessos.

Nessos and Beky had a big fallout before. They are definitely either both Town or a scum is amongst them, but definitely not scum vs scum.
 
Messages
570
Reaction score
530
Points
1,950
Salty Doubloons
1,176
Again all the votes

Vote Count 1 day 1 P#201
Gambit– 1 Ona

Vote Count 2 day 1 P#360

Gambit – 2 Ona, Cat
Samael – 1 Ted
Beky – 1 Nessos
Nessos – 1 Dragomir

Vote Count 3 day 1 P#697
Nessos – 5 Drago, Nessos, Ted, Cat, Oreki
Gambit – 2 Michelle, Gambit
Dragomir
– 1 Ona


Vote Count 4 day 1 P#774
Nessos – 3 Drago, Ted, Cat
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Michelle - 1 Gambit
Gambit - 1 Michelle
Dragomir - 1
Ona

Vote Count 5 day 1 P#793
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Nessos - 2 Drago, Ted
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Michelle - 1 Gambit

Drago - 1 Ona

Vote Count 6 day 1 P#879 2 hours before EOD
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Michelle - 2 Gambit, Beky
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Nessos - 1 Drago

Drago - 1 Ona

Vote Count 7 day 1 P#969
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Ted - 2 Nessos, Beky
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Oreki - 1 Juliet
Ona - 1 Law
Michelle - 1 Gambit
Nessos - 1 Drago

Drago - 1 Ona

Final vote count P#1044

Juliet - 5 Ona, Ted, Oreki, Rej, Waindo
Ted - 2 Nessos, Beky
Ona - 2 Law, Cat
Waindo - 1 Michelle
Oreki - 1 Juliet
Michelle - 1 Gambit

Nessos - 1 Drago

Note: Joby/Shottie and Samael didn't vote all day.

Day one VCs show how Rej is voting for Gambit in the 5th VC when the only wagon who wasn't on a villager is for Nessos. I think the possiblity for that slot to be scum is extremely high being that vote
. ​

Nessos self voting in VC3 and going to vote Ted and keep his vote until Eod is another clue of wolfy behaviour.
Nessos – Beky > Nessos > Tedxter
So Rej talking about Nessos with so much comprehension like i said previously makes me want to lynch Okosan.
Day one VC brings another idea in the same direction.

Back to search.
 
Messages
934
Reaction score
834
Points
1,300
Salty Doubloons
956
Oko subbed in for Nessos.

Nessos and Beky had a big fallout before. They are definitely either both Town or a scum is amongst them, but definitely not scum vs scum.
Oooh gotcha.
[automerge]1588077211[/automerge]
Again all the votes

Vote Count 1 day 1 P#201
Gambit– 1 Ona

Vote Count 2 day 1 P#360

Gambit – 2 Ona, Cat
Samael – 1 Ted
Beky – 1 Nessos
Nessos – 1 Dragomir

Vote Count 3 day 1 P#697
Nessos – 5 Drago, Nessos, Ted, Cat, Oreki
Gambit – 2 Michelle, Gambit
Dragomir
– 1 Ona


Vote Count 4 day 1 P#774
Nessos – 3 Drago, Ted, Cat
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Michelle - 1 Gambit
Gambit - 1 Michelle
Dragomir - 1
Ona

Vote Count 5 day 1 P#793
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Nessos - 2 Drago, Ted
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Michelle - 1 Gambit

Drago - 1 Ona

Vote Count 6 day 1 P#879 2 hours before EOD
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Michelle - 2 Gambit, Beky
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Ted - 1 Nessos
Nessos - 1 Drago

Drago - 1 Ona

Vote Count 7 day 1 P#969
Gambit - 3 Michelle, Cat, Rej
Ted - 2 Nessos, Beky
Juliet - 1 Oreki
Oreki - 1 Juliet
Ona - 1 Law
Michelle - 1 Gambit
Nessos - 1 Drago

Drago - 1 Ona

Final vote count P#1044

Juliet - 5 Ona, Ted, Oreki, Rej, Waindo
Ted - 2 Nessos, Beky
Ona - 2 Law, Cat
Waindo - 1 Michelle
Oreki - 1 Juliet
Michelle - 1 Gambit

Nessos - 1 Drago

Note: Joby/Shottie and Samael didn't vote all day.

Day one VCs show how Rej is voting for Gambit in the 5th VC when the only wagon who wasn't on a villager is for Nessos. I think the possiblity for that slot to be scum is extremely high being that vote
.

Nessos self voting in VC3 and going to vote Ted and keep his vote until Eod is another clue of wolfy behaviour.

So Rej talking about Nessos with so much comprehension like i said previously makes me want to lynch Okosan.
Day one VC brings another idea in the same direction.

Back to search.
You'd rather vote Oko over Samael?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom