[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 7: Final Fantasy XII- The Mafia Age

[novaselinenever]

Hayumi and Nana's emoji game are giving me the heebie jeebies lol. It doesn't feel natural most of the times in their post

 

[novaselinenever]

No unless this was weeb game, otherwise I have never heard of it.

Not sure if this a townslip, or an elaborate play lol. Like would he actually believe that it'd fly here? Also does anyone remember being scum with Ryu in a Trad game? That'd help

Leaning towards it being the former tbh

 

[novaselinenever]

I wonder though why Naomi asked about it. Bit weird

 

[novaselinenever]

Hi, the scummiest scum here

Bad entrance post. Using previous banter to break the ice, it doesn't feel natural with the immediate tone switch to rebuff someone asking a question.

Feels more like an uncomfortable scum trying to ease into the thread, rather than a townie trying to banter and have fun.

 

[novaselinenever]

Srsly Mich? Shade throwing this early on?

The indignation feels fake here, and like what is the point of this post? I'm also not sure what "shade throwing" there was, nor how exactly it is bad. No follow up from him as well.

 

[novaselinenever]

Vote Count so far,

Nova - Dragomir > Oreki
Michelle - Gambit
Naomi - Gambit
Dragomir - Hayumi
Normalizer - Nana

Gambit - 2
Oreki/Hayumi/Nana - 1

Spoiler

[Vote Lynch Dragomir]

Vote lynch: Gambit

Vote Lynch Gambit

Vote Lynch Hayum

Vote Lynch Nana

Vote Lynch Oreki

We have around 10 hours left

 

[Oreki]

Oreki, why didn't you answer Naomi's question instead of trying to ask her motives first?

Gambit only had one or two post before and I ain't genius to give my opinion on someone based on one post... Not to mention why she would even tag me?

 

[novaselinenever]

Drago is such a copycat lol. Not sure how to feel about the prodding of Michelle, feels a little bit to narrow minded to me and he kind of jump started. The kind that looks like scum nitpicking stuff to get some scum reads and navigate the game through prodding like that. He dropped it so there is some progression

 

[novaselinenever]

Gambit only had one or two post before and I ain't genius to give my opinion on someone based on one post... Not to mention why she would even tag me?

I don't think it's about being a genius or not lol. I don't think someone asking your thoughts on something would expect you to give a final verdict that has to be correct, but rather just what you think at that exact moment. You can develop a read based on any number of posts and entrance, doesn't have to be fleshed out, it's just thoughts. Who knows lol, I'm sure she'll tell you. It's more about why not just answer before rebuffing her.

 

[Oreki]

Bad entrance post. Using previous banter to break the ice, it doesn't feel natural with the immediate tone switch to rebuff someone asking a question.

Feels more like an uncomfortable scum trying to ease into the thread, rather than a townie trying to banter and have fun.

How can you even tell that my post was forced? Are you some psychic?
[automerge]1588910160[/automerge]

nitpicking stuff to get some scum reads and navigate the game through prodding like that.

I just saw someone was doing that while ago
[automerge]1588910402[/automerge]

I don't think it's about being a genius or not lol. I don't think someone asking your thoughts on something would expect you to give a final verdict that has to be correct, but rather just what you think at that exact moment. You can develop a read based on any number of posts and entrance, doesn't have to be fleshed out, it's just thoughts. Who knows lol, I'm sure she'll tell you. It's more about why not just answer before rebuffing her.

Let me ask you one question why are you answering on Naomi's place? What if I wanted Naomi to address my post and then I answer my question to her? the main point is that you shouldn't have addressed my post and but Naomi to see how she will react but no matter what she will not react to my post in the way she might have because you have shown your opinion that which might make her conflict with her opinion

 

[novaselinenever]

How can you even tell that my post was forced? Are you some psychic?

I described it. Do you think someone has to be a psychic for a post to give him thoughts?

I just saw someone was doing that while ago

Yikes. Snarky comments with an emoji to sweeten the tone, you're free falling Oreki

 

[novaselinenever]

Let me ask you one question why are you answering on Naomi's place? What if I wanted Naomi to address my post and then I answer my question to her? the main point is that you shouldn't have addressed my post and but Naomi to see how she will react but no matter what she will not react to my post in the way she might have because you have shown your opinion that which might make her conflict with her opinion

How exactly am I answering in her place? You asked her why she asked you that question, and I didn't theorize on why she did. In my own post, I told you "who know" to that very question.

I'm engaging you on the reason you evaded her question and instead answered it with a pseudo loaded question for your own. That's the behavior I'm gripping with. You're moving the goal post here lol.

What if I wanted Naomi to address my post and then I answer my question to her?

Did you?

the main point is that you shouldn't have addressed my post and but Naomi to see how she will react but no matter what she will not react to my post in the way she might have because you have shown your opinion that which might make her conflict with her opinion

How exactly would this exchange conflict her opinion exactly?

 

[Oreki]

I described it. Do you think someone has to be a psychic for a post to give him thoughts?

No, the question is how do you define serious and forced posts.... if it's that easy for you then I can assume so far every post you saw is genuine?

Yikes. Snarky comments with an emoji to sweeten the tone, you're free falling Oreki

You were making that comment yet you were doing the same thing with me. I just wanted to give you a taste of your own medicine
[automerge]1588912320[/automerge]

Did you?

I wasn't really that interested but I do wanted to her reason

I'm engaging you on the reason you evaded her question and instead answered it with a pseudo loaded question for your own. That's the behavior I'm gripping with. You're moving the goal post here lol.

If I wanted to evade that question I would've never have addressed that post and I am hell sure no one would have asked me question why I ignored Naomi post, not even Naomi herself since question like that get no attention in the early game

I wanted to know why would she ask my opinion on Gambit when he only had one or two posts and I had zero posts means I was not even present.

 

[novaselinenever]

No, the question is how do you define serious and forced posts.... if it's that easy for you then I can assume so far every post you saw is genuine?

You define them with their tone and content. The analysis of your post pain the picture pretty fucking clearly, townies having fun and bantering have a more at ease tone and constancy in their posting. You made a joke using previous banter from me & Drago's entrance to break the ice, and immediately switched tones rebuffing Naomi's question. It's usually scum indicative and makes you feel nervous and the immediate switch of tone makes it feel even less natural.

I also don't like the emoj in it lol

Why would you assume it's that easy? Are you oblivious to being able to get reads and thoughts clearer on some behavior and posts instead of on everything? You're trying to set up false equivalencies here.

 

[novaselinenever]

You were making that comment yet you were doing the same thing with me. I just wanted to give you a taste of your own medicine

How exactly is what I'm doing to you the same lol? I'm prodding and confronting you directly, he's using Michelle's post and wording about myself and Naomi as some "gotcha moment" of TMI. Also I'm not exactly holding it against Drago completely, I even said I'm not sure how I feel about it and mentioned the progression. It's more about him immediately going for the theory that it's TMI rather than "hmmm maybe she meants, if he's town he'll show himself". It's a low hanging fruit kind of wording posts, and usually townies mindset would try to figure peeps out and consider all paths. The immediately cold prodding and accusation resemble scum using those kind of pseudo scummy thing to generate scum reads and navigate the game. Kind of like why I suspected you that ToS game lol. I noted the progression of him on her though, that was a good point for him

 

[novaselinenever]

I wasn't really that interested but I do wanted to her reason

Would her reason changed how you responded?

If I wanted to evade that question I would've never have addressed that post and I am hell sure no one would have asked me question why I ignored Naomi post, not even Naomi herself since question like that get no attention in the early game

I wanted to know why would she ask my opinion on Gambit when he only had one or two posts and I had zero posts means I was not even present.

Doubt that, it struck my attention since I was interested in why she asked you specifically and I mentioned the prod being weird lol.

Ok, you wanted that. That's good. But why not answer first instead of rebuffing and waiting to know why she asked you first? That's my grippe lol. It's usually scum behavior to hold things tight to their chest, they don't give in and they always want to know the thoughts and agenda of people questioning them so that they can navigate their prodding and come up with good enough responses.

A townie's mindset would be less self-aware and usually answer before prodding back if that question ranged some alarm for them. Especially when it's such a mundane question and like you said gambit having only had 1/2 posts which would make your answer probably short.

 

[novaselinenever]

jup, you novas and naomi

tbh right now I have no reads, but for a new guy you are pretty townish, you know the gameplay
if I would townread two people it's you and Naomi, idk about the rest yet

Why would you sheep me and Michelle if we aren't Town reads? Lmao

 

[novaselinenever]

This is roughly where I'm at right now

Naomi
Normalizer
Ryu Kishi
Michelle
Pepper
Rej
Mat D Bizzo
Dragomir
God_Usopun
Gambit
Nana
Hayumi
Waindo
Oreki

 

[novaselinenever]

Rej is in a lighter shade of green and not in my current towncore 'cause while he feels genuine in how he's disengaged and his care free attitude, I think it's not entirely outside of his scum range and also it's potentially NAI 'cause he is in fact burned out and have been like this for a while.

It's going to be tough to sort him out completely, I usually rely on his paranoia of me lmao

 

[novaselinenever]

The odd man out in that core would be Ryu tbh, he's presence there is more about what I'm thinking is a townslip rather than good tone.

The middle of the rainbow is big fat mess lol