[FIN] Traditional Mafia Attack on Titan Mafia

Messages
2,473
Reaction score
8,273
Points
9,750
Salty Doubloons
1,536
that doesn't quiet answer my question. i want to know why did you choose to redirect larsi n2. do you remember what was your thought process there?
Because if you ended up dead it would mean he was the killer, I didn't really choose you for any specific reason tbh.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
Because if you ended up dead it would mean he was the killer, I didn't really choose you for any specific reason tbh.
i get that part, well i was more interested in why larsi specifically, seeing as he voted nessos and never defended him, there were other players you could have redirected to see if they were the killers, like rej for instance
 
Messages
2,473
Reaction score
8,273
Points
9,750
Salty Doubloons
1,536
But since you weren't dead I assumed he was hard-cleared since another kill happened elsewhere, then Karp (but nobody got killed last night) so he could still be the killer and I honestly think he is more suspect than Larsi.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
But since you weren't dead I assumed he was hard-cleared since another kill happened elsewhere, then Karp (but nobody got killed last night) so he could still be the killer and I honestly think he is more suspect than Larsi.
tbh i belive you because when larsi claimed protecting me you thought that you redirected karp's kill to me but larsi saved me, this thought came off genuine
 
Messages
2,473
Reaction score
8,273
Points
9,750
Salty Doubloons
1,536
I was just trying to build a network of people I could trust, my thought process probably wasn't as deep as it should've been.

And regarding the Ein v1 killers, I was just gonna try to lynch them regardless for the bit. But then they all dropped dead within 2 days and nights and I realized I looked pretty bad and Karp made sure to point that out, which makes me feel like he's taking my joke and framing me/keeping me alive as long as possible for a scapegoat.
 
Messages
2,473
Reaction score
8,273
Points
9,750
Salty Doubloons
1,536
I feel like it's just gonna be Rail and I'm gonna feel stupid for being so paranoid. :dogkek:
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I was just trying to build a network of people I could trust, my thought process probably wasn't as deep as it should've been.

And regarding the Ein v1 killers, I was just gonna try to lynch them regardless for the bit. But then they all dropped dead within 2 days and nights and I realized I looked pretty bad and Karp made sure to point that out, which makes me feel like he's taking my joke and framing me/keeping me alive as long as possible for a scapegoat.
i think its fair for karp to suspect u of getting rid of the people who voted for you. i dont think he has an evil agenda against u or is pushing u to get u lynched right now. we can revisit if ratchet flips town
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I feel like it's just gonna be Rail and I'm gonna feel stupid for being so paranoid. :dogkek:
well just a heads up - ive never seen ratchet defend himself this poorly as scum or town before, might be a jester lowkey
 
Messages
2,473
Reaction score
8,273
Points
9,750
Salty Doubloons
1,536
i think its fair for karp to suspect u of getting rid of the people who voted for you. i dont think he has an evil agenda against u or is pushing u to get u lynched right now. we can revisit if ratchet flips town
He's smart though, I feel like he would've at least theorized a potential frame-job, unless he didn't want it noticed.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
He's smart though, I feel like he would've at least theorized a potential frame-job, unless he didn't want it noticed.
if it's karp i hope im not alive the next day as im almost guaranteed to vote wrong lol

if u have another redirect u can try it on him again if ratchet turn out town, but he can just abstain again. it's just gonna be a game of chicken
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
so larsi is psuedo cleared n2 cuz the kill went on gambit when u redirected him to me. if he is reiner he can be a strongman so i cant say he is 100% cleared off that yet

going to be really hard to case this tho as its essentially going against mech based on setup speculation, and have to on top of that assume u r town and saying the truth

i had something else i wanted to say regarding this but i forgot lol

ratchet being jester wud make alot of sense, but if thats the case i legitimately wish to be dead next day lol
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
Jester, in a small mostly vanilla game. I'm lost for words.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
He's smart though, I feel like he would've at least theorized a potential frame-job, unless he didn't want it noticed.
Unless he's being framed, but that would be a bit too Wifom for me.
I was considering it. But most people didn't even acknowledge my accusations, so if you were framed, nobody really made use of the frame job.
I was getting doubts near the end of d3 that maybe I was reading too much into night 1. You getting roletracked and framed would fit with what happened. Also if the scum suspected a doctor they would have chosen a less obvious target like Mango to still get a kill off, which takes some more suspicion off you. (I hadn't really considered a doctor besides pinging Larsi as the likely candidate, so I missed that until now)
I am still suspicious of you, but I am suspicious of everybody.

@RAIL_GUN obviously has to go first. That princess lie was blatantly anti town.

I don't think we have two scum left. They would have won with the night kill, and I don't think two people working together would just forget to do their job for 24 hours. An x shot hitman is also more complicated than the other roles we've seen. The role pm examples on mafiascum.net mostly go "you can kill as long as nobody else does the night kill" (paraphrased), so either scum could have killed if it's like that in this game. So one scum is more likely.

My next guess would actually be Ekkologix playing a very deep wolf. They've been making too much sense to me, which is raising alarm bells. They've also been town reading me all game, so I'm worried I'm being pocketed.
@Ekkologix let's play a game called "If Ekko is mafia".
What reason would there be to skip the night kill if you were mafia?
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
With the claimed PRs we have we should be able to plan a pretty good night if we mislynch today or rail is a jester/not the last scum.

It would be 4 people left, with at most 1 scum.

If Einsauer redirects either Ekko or me onto an agreed upon target, and Larsi heals that target.

But then a possible strongman breaks that again.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I was considering it. But most people didn't even acknowledge my accusations, so if you were framed, nobody really made use of the frame job.
I was getting doubts near the end of d3 that maybe I was reading too much into night 1. You getting roletracked and framed would fit with what happened. Also if the scum suspected a doctor they would have chosen a less obvious target like Mango to still get a kill off, which takes some more suspicion off you. (I hadn't really considered a doctor besides pinging Larsi as the likely candidate, so I missed that until now)
I am still suspicious of you, but I am suspicious of everybody.

@RAIL_GUN obviously has to go first. That princess lie was blatantly anti town.

I don't think we have two scum left. They would have won with the night kill, and I don't think two people working together would just forget to do their job for 24 hours. An x shot hitman is also more complicated than the other roles we've seen. The role pm examples on mafiascum.net mostly go "you can kill as long as nobody else does the night kill" (paraphrased), so either scum could have killed if it's like that in this game. So one scum is more likely.

My next guess would actually be Ekkologix playing a very deep wolf. They've been making too much sense to me, which is raising alarm bells. They've also been town reading me all game, so I'm worried I'm being pocketed.
@Ekkologix let's play a game called "If Ekko is mafia".
What reason would there be to skip the night kill if you were mafia?
none, it makes 0 sense for me to abstain. there is no strategic benefit to it for me
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
There is the question of "Why isn't Ekko dead?" That now gets superceded by "Why didn't scum kill?"
i cant answer those beyond the speculations i was doing today

idk how larsi and eisnseur play..i think for instancd the kills r super weird and makes sense to be done by a TB player more than by ratchet but i town read them for other reasons

also ratchet has a death wish so we will deliver it to him
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
if hes town shud be able to easily solve this one and defend himself. shud do so as scum as well. probably intentionally trolling
 
Top Bottom