[FIN] Traditional Mafia Attack on Titan Mafia

Larsi

Silver Hair
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
29,611
Points
28,100
Salty Doubloons
13,412
not very satisfying answer if im being honest
i think my preferred direction if ratchet turned out town would be you
I didnt have much else to go on day 1, mostly was just looking at people's reactions and going off of that.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
Based on the setup, how likely is a mafia strongman?

We have our Doctor, presumably, but they had a role tracker to find him and kill him. And we had a Roleblocker. And a Redirector, presumably.

How many shots do you think the strongman has/had? Can they choose when to use them, or is only their first (two/three/whatever) shot(s) unblockable?
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
Based on the setup, how likely is a mafia strongman?

We have our Doctor, presumably, but they had a role tracker to find him and kill him. And we had a Roleblocker. And a Redirector, presumably.

How many shots do you think the strongman has/had? Can they choose when to use them, or is only their first (two/three/whatever) shot(s) unblockable?
very likely if larsi and einseur are both town, probably a 1 shot due to game size
or maybe they have a roleblocker instead
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
i cant answer those beyond the speculations i was doing today
But you can see how not killing that night took that factor of suspicion off you, allowing you to use your hypothetical deep wolf cred to lynch another player, and then, if Nessos did the kill N1 and you are a 2 shot strongman, you can use your second shot to get into f3 while being the town leader.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
Also, Nessos trying to CFD you when he died might have been him reverse bussing you.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
But you can see how not killing that night took that factor of suspicion off you, allowing you to use your hypothetical deep wolf cred to lynch another player, and then, if Nessos did the kill N1 and you are a 2 shot strongman, you can use your second shot to get into f3 while being the town leader.
but its unnecessary, i dont think i wud be suspected either if i did the kill. now i have to drive 2 more mislynches instead of 1 to win. the risk isnt worth it

basically i can do the kill and suspect railgun like ive been doing today. the kill wud be on you for instance. this way larsi, einseur, and rail are viable people i can try to mislynch, and id only need 1 mislynch to win
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
also ratchet has a death wish so we will deliver it to him
if hes town shud be able to easily solve this one and defend himself. shud do so as scum as well. probably intentionally trolling
???

I've given you reasons why I'm Town. You've just disregarded them. Not sure why you have to continue taking these silly shots - are you that desperate to remove agency from yourself for your poor read? I've told you I'm sick, I'm not going to put more out than I have because I don't think you have the ability to pick up where I leave off anyway. There is no dearh wish here - if you're not going to listen to anything I bring up that's on you, not me.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
You completely make up the idea that I'm a double voter, or a Jester, with 0 evidence to suggest either being present. What do I do with that lol? I'm not going to reach an understanding with someone who has a hate-boner for me and needs to project his fragile ego at me every game we play together. There is no defence for the above two things because they're complete nonsense, you've just invented them because you feel like it.

I think I'd like to see you lynched tomorrow to be honest.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
but its unnecessary, i dont think i wud be suspected either if i did the kill. now i have to drive 2 more mislynches instead of 1 to win. the risk isnt worth it

basically i can do the kill and suspect railgun like ive been doing today. the kill wud be on you for instance. this way larsi, einseur, and rail are viable people i can try to mislynch, and id only need 1 mislynch to win
But you (the hypothetical you that is scum) had to suspect potential power roles.

Reiner had some psychological issues where he would sometimes forget he was an infiltrator.
Maybe there is a mechanic that you can only kill every two rounds, or only have the strongman every two rounds. If you knew Einsauer had the redirector ability you couldn't risk killing without it, so you had to wait a round.
(Actually this also implicates me, as I've been throwing shit at Einsauer D2 and D3)

I suggest Ekko and I to be suspects if we go into another night.
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
You completely make up the idea that I'm a double voter, or a Jester, with 0 evidence to suggest either being present. What do I do with that lol? I'm not going to reach an understanding with someone who has a hate-boner for me and needs to project his fragile ego at me every game we play together. There is no defence for the above two things because they're complete nonsense, you've just invented them because you feel like it.

I think I'd like to see you lynched tomorrow to be honest.
Why did you claim princess in the first place?
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
???

I've given you reasons why I'm Town. You've just disregarded them. Not sure why you have to continue taking these silly shots - are you that desperate to remove agency from yourself for your poor read? I've told you I'm sick, I'm not going to put more out than I have because I don't think you have the ability to pick up where I leave off anyway. There is no dearh wish here - if you're not going to listen to anything I bring up that's on you, not me.
oh okay get well soon, i thought u meant sick of something in game

well, i've been doing most of the leg work for you in terms of exploring larsi and eins 2.0, i dont think its fair to tell me im not listening or trying to work things out from your PoV
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
But you (the hypothetical you that is scum) had to suspect potential power roles.

Reiner had some psychological issues where he would sometimes forget he was an infiltrator.
Maybe there is a mechanic that you can only kill every two rounds, or only have the strongman every two rounds. If you knew Einsauer had the redirector ability you couldn't risk killing without it, so you had to wait a round.
(Actually this also implicates me, as I've been throwing shit at Einsauer D2 and D3)

I suggest Ekko and I to be suspects if we go into another night.
i think we shud not be expanding the suspect pool here no

if einseur had a redirector and i knew he did i'll probbaly kill him instead of kill you. im 90% sure he will not target me after i lynched nessos

i dont know why did he redirect people to me tho. einseur stand out the most suspect via his actions
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
oh okay get well soon, i thought u meant sick of something in game

well, i've been doing most of the leg work for you in terms of exploring larsi and eins 2.0, i dont think its fair to tell me im not listening or trying to work things out from your PoV
But you're not listening at all - you've literally invented two scenarios with no evidence or basis in reality for either of them to push through a lynch. Like what do you want me to do about that? How am I supposed to argue against a scenario completely divorced from reality except to point out that it's divorced from reality?

It's so silly. Also you haven't really been canvassing the others - everything has come under the impression that I'm scum, so you've decided to find reasons for them to be town to satisfy your read. I don't know what the process is supposed to be, feels like you arbitrarily decided I must be scum and then have fit everything else around that
Why did you claim princess in the first place?
Felt like it would be a relatively harmless reaction test - anyone pushing my kynch would have to reconcile past it and I don't think it made any difference as to whether I'm lynched today or not.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
You completely make up the idea that I'm a double voter, or a Jester, with 0 evidence to suggest either being present. What do I do with that lol? I'm not going to reach an understanding with someone who has a hate-boner for me and needs to project his fragile ego at me every game we play together. There is no defence for the above two things because they're complete nonsense, you've just invented them because you feel like it.

I think I'd like to see you lynched tomorrow to be honest.
there is no "hate-boner", i said multiple times i parsed through the rest of the players and i see them as town more than i see you. i barely mentioned you or suspected you the other days so this is an obvious exaggeration and irrelevant to what im trying to discuss

also town works via speculating and piecing things together. flavor wise a double voter and/or strongman and/or mafia roleblocker makes a lot of sense. this is where the basis of it is coming from

you arent being scum read because i think you are a double voter or what not. the scum read came first after town reading the other players. speculating that you are a double voter was simply my own headcannon to fill out the gaps onto why would you abstain there
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
But you're not listening at all - you've literally invented two scenarios with no evidence or basis in reality for either of them to push through a lynch. Like what do you want me to do about that? How am I supposed to argue against a scenario completely divorced from reality except to point out that it's divorced from reality?

It's so silly. Also you haven't really been canvassing the others - everything has come under the impression that I'm scum, so you've decided to find reasons for them to be town to satisfy your read. I don't know what the process is supposed to be, feels like you arbitrarily decided I must be scum and then have fit everything else around that
Felt like it would be a relatively harmless reaction test - anyone pushing my kynch would have to reconcile past it and I don't think it made any difference as to whether I'm lynched today or not.
do u think there r holes i left behind in their play? i am unfamiliar with any of them so the town reads might be given too easily
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
might be another case of xadlin with einsaur. will gladly inspect that more if im alive tomorrow
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
do u think there r holes i left behind in their play? i am unfamiliar with any of them so the town reads might be given too easily
I think Larsi very plausibly can be scum when you consider the totality of his play. He has no real I interest in the points of discussion. Eisenhower on claim and likelihood to forget to send a kill also lines up - I think both of these are very easy to reconcile as scum under the right lens of thought.
 
Top Bottom