[FIN] Traditional Mafia Attack on Titan Mafia

Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I don't believe I accused you of tunneling. Just that you started from the conclusion and then have worked backwards from there.
you actually did accuse me of it

also no i didnt start from a conclusion either, again i went through every player 1 by 1 and arrived at you

for it to be eins he'd have forgo last night kill but somehow submit the redirect? i cant really get my head around it, there is alot of silly stuff happening here. for one i disagree with his target choices but i dont think the way he claimed them in an attempt to clear other players was scummy offhand. it's almost a xadlin in terms of how he was "clearing" players that are already town read by seeing them go no where. but the difference here is he is a new player unlike xadlin

for him to be scum he'd have to forgo the kill, use the redirect, then clear the players that are his last hope of mislynch in F3. how does he ever win in this position?
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I'd probably vote Larsi from where I'm currently at.
i asked larsi how experienced he is, because i think his play can come off as calculated / too safe. i dont have anything hard clearing him outside of beliving eins's result. this wud require us to belive larsi used strongman n2 (to kill gambit of all people at the time) or accurately roleblocked eins
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
Do we want to suggest actions for the claimed PR roles? If there is a strongman, we'll lose someone regardless, but if not, it might be best to know what they were doing if they die during the night.
The possible strongman role is gonna create a lot of wifom, but we need data.
Maybe we can give them two targets to chose from.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
i asked larsi how experienced he is, because i think his play can come off as calculated / too safe. i dont have anything hard clearing him outside of beliving eins's result. this wud require us to belive larsi used strongman n2 (to kill gambit of all people at the time) or accurately roleblocked eins
Shrug. Well, not my problem!
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
Why? Because you say so?
because apparently am reading the game state better than you are right now. either me or karp will die, likely karp since he actually suspects larsi/eins while i have them both as town, and i also am suspected for being alive and am likely to vote wrong tomorrow or 50-50

karp has more meta knowledge on his friends as well
 
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
8,475
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,823
for him to be scum he'd have to forgo the kill, use the redirect, then clear the players that are his last hope of mislynch in F3. how does he ever win in this position?
But if he is scum he just didn't do the redirect.
You seem awfully sure he has the redirector role.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
because apparently am reading the game state better than you are right now. either me or karp will die, likely karp since he actually suspects larsi/eins while i have them both as town, and i also am suspected for being alive and am likely to vote wrong tomorrow or 50-50

karp has more meta knowledge on his friends as well
What does the first sentence add to your point? Again you just can't help but project lmao.

After my flip you're going to have to suspect them anyway, so him suspecting them in advance doesn't really mean anything.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
But if he is scum he just didn't do the redirect.
You seem awfully sure he has the redirector role.
we dont have a way to verify it, but why claim it if he doesnt have it. he could have risked being caught in a lie since he claimed the first in the day
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
What does the first sentence add to your point? Again you just can't help but project lmao.

After my flip you're going to have to suspect them anyway, so him suspecting them in advance doesn't really mean anything.
was a direct response to your "because you say so"
you get a level of reply equal to your post
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
ofcourse it isnt, but u see the issue here yeah? i have to assume much more to make them scum than to make you scum
I mean you also have to assume I wanted to bus my mate day 1 and rely on Rej of all people to start a random wagon on a townie elsewhere to delay his death, and then instead of doubling down and getting credit from Nessos' flip I get greedy and go for the Rej mislynch that I can easily get after Nessos anyway before Nessos solely to harm my thread position. Apparently that makes sense to you, I dunno.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
the players getting killed are mango and gambit. they have more knowledge on TB players than i am. i expect karp to go next since he knows his friends more and can likely have a better vote than me tomorrow. im basically gonna have to RNG it more likely than not
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
was a direct response to your "because you say so"
you get a level of reply equal to your post
Well no, you made a comment without any supporting evidence hence why I added that - tends to fit into posts that are made in response to those without any evidence backing them.
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
I mean you also have to assume I wanted to bus my mate day 1 and rely on Rej of all people to start a random wagon on a townie elsewhere to delay his death, and then instead of doubling down and getting credit from Nessos' flip I get greedy and go for the Rej mislynch that I can easily get after Nessos anyway before Nessos solely to harm my thread position. Apparently that makes sense to you, I dunno.
yeah but look - the alternative is zolo, who had 0 posts day 1. i cant make anything off of this
or larsi, who voted nessos when his wagon was growing and never moved. how can he also predict what rej will do?
 
Messages
632
Reaction score
141
Points
3,025
Salty Doubloons
633
larsi voted nessos before you

your vote on nessos came after rej started the other wagon i belive, or when he was starting it
 
Top Bottom