General RP General Chat

Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
I just feel like that's not enough of a reason to dislike an anime.

Even Naruto for example, did this. When Naruto got all the Bijuus, he suddenly was able to use all of their elemental natures. Same with Sasuke when he got Rin'negan, etc..

Bleach also, Ichigo was a Shinigami/Hollow/Quincy by the end of it, etc..

As long as it's not pulled out of the ass it's fine. And I don't think it was pulled out of the ass at all, given the core of the One for All quirk is a quirk that hands down power. We simply found out that it's not just physical strength. That's much less of a stretch than many other animes lol.
For me it is. The examples you've given are pretty much my exact reasons why I didnt like the later parts of Naruto and Bleach lol. This is highly personal. For me bha started with powers akin to the x-men, evolved humans with mutations in their dna. When powers go outside the scope of that is when you lose me

Even all for one in the beginning was a toned down version compared to what it is now.
[automerge]1650531196[/automerge]
The quirks that get introduced later on are pretty out there if you ask me at least.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
Finding an anime/manga without power creep in shonen is nearly impossible. 😅
That's the thing. I tend to judge anime based on what it's supposed to be. And given the type of anime MHA is (shonen, and the exact type of shonen it is), this was to be expected, so I wouldn't fault it based on that.

You know what I mean?

That's like taking a basketball and then faulting it for being all bouncy and rolling around instead of staying solid in place like a brick. lol

Can't call it a bad basketball, it's just a basketball, and things come with it. Just like MHA is a superhero shonen and things will come with that. But at least they were foreshadowed well enough.
 
Messages
13,594
Reaction score
41,874
Points
31,850
Salty Doubloons
11,062
I feel far to fatigued to do another post :toolazyplz:

@Mugiwara_Ryan I'll post for Cactus tomorrow @Emperor Cross I'll check if you made a post in Enies Lobby and you too @QuickZilver708 for Ergastulum
Imma post tomorrow, I have an interview today. :catcry:
____
Good manga you have : Dreamland and Radiant as a Furyo fan I can vouch for Crows and Worst.
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
That's the thing. I tend to judge anime based on what it's supposed to be. And given the type of anime MHA is (shonen, and the exact type of shonen it is), this was to be expected, so I wouldn't fault it based on that.

You know what I mean?

That's like taking a basketball and then faulting it for being all bouncy and rolling around instead of staying solid in place like a brick. lol

Can't call it a bad basketball, it's just a basketball, and things come with it. Just like MHA is a superhero shonen and things will come with that. But at least they were foreshadowed well enough.
I could give more examples, but I don't want to go too far into spoiler territory, I feel like I've already spoiled way too much, lol. Perhaps I just had different expectation from the start, but something really weren't foreshadowed and to me felt like an ass pull. But I get what you're trying to say. It's the exact reason why I don't fault JOJO even if it pretty much does the same thing to BHA and other shōnen I just feel like it set that baseline way quicker and earlier than BHA who gradually got way more out of hand.
[automerge]1650533732[/automerge]
I feel far to fatigued to do another post :toolazyplz:

@Mugiwara_Ryan I'll post for Cactus tomorrow @Emperor Cross I'll check if you made a post in Enies Lobby and you too @QuickZilver708 for Ergastulum
If you're wondering if I posted in Ergastulum. I did earlier this week.
 
Messages
11,159
Reaction score
38,426
Points
29,500
Salty Doubloons
139
I must admit I'm very much looking forward to you being back at full strength :)
Also, I'm very much hoping @Ichimonji is able to post Friday :D
Give me 3 weeks, 2 weeks left of fasting and a week go recuperate
[automerge]1650533802[/automerge]
I could give more examples, but I don't want to go too far into spoiler territory, I feel like I've already spoiled way too much, lol. Perhaps I just had different expectation from the start, but something really weren't foreshadowed and to me felt like an ass pull. But I get what you're trying to say. It's the exact reason why I don't fault JOJO even if it pretty much does the same thing to BHA and other shōnen I just feel like it set that baseline way quicker and earlier than BHA who gradually got way more out of hand.
[automerge]1650533732[/automerge]

If you're wondering if I posted in Ergastulum. I did earlier this week.
I haven't checked but I'll make a post tomorrow as I'm far too beat right now.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
I could give more examples, but I don't want to go too far into spoiler territory, I feel like I've already spoiled way too much, lol. Perhaps I just had different expectation from the start, but something really weren't foreshadowed and to me felt like an ass pull. But I get what you're trying to say. It's the exact reason why I don't fault JOJO even if it pretty much does the same thing to BHA and other shōnen I just feel like it set that baseline way quicker and earlier than BHA who gradually got way more out of hand.
[automerge]1650533732[/automerge]

If you're wondering if I posted in Ergastulum. I did earlier this week.
To be the devil's advocate (I do love Jojo, one of my absolute faves), but did it really set that baseline early? lol

Stands got introduced in like the 3rd season, prior to that it was extremely tamed in terms of powers. Just normal brawling, with a very entry level Ripple and some tame vampiric abilities.

Then stands came with insane powers like stopping time, etc..

So I really can't agree that it set the power baseline very early at all. But, it was always a show that took itself less seriously (all the funny poses and whatnot), and that's why one can't fault/hate it much. But in terms of pure ''power talk'', it went from tame to crazy just like MHA. xD
 
Top Bottom