General RP General Chat

Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
I voted for group B so far, but we get 2 votes, I have to think about the second vote lol.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
That's highly extreme diff for the Marines with 7 top tiers.
None of them are quite Yonkou level though aside from Garp.

Probably takes 2 Admirals to take down a Yonkou. Don't get me started on trying to take down Gear 5 Luffy or Roger or Rocks.

I did vote for Marines too, but you get a second vote too, and that one is hard for me.
 
Messages
15,332
Reaction score
45,329
Points
33,800
Salty Doubloons
644
None of them are quite Yonkou level though aside from Garp.

Probably takes 2 Admirals to take down a Yonkou. Don't get me started on trying to take down Gear 5 Luffy or Roger or Rocks.

I did vote for Marines too, but you get a second vote too, and that one is hard for me.
2nd vote would prolly go to prime Roger's line-up. Rayleigh sb pretty close to Roger and they got Oden who is assumed to be equal to Scopper who is close to Rayleigh. And Mihawk is highly portrayed as God.
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
The marines group seem like a no brainer as a vote. I went with C as a second since Kaido mentioned that Haki can transcend all, with both Roger and Rayleigh there at their prime they'd do a lot of heavy lifting. Oden and Mihawk are not too bad themselves.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
2nd vote would prolly go to prime Roger's line-up. Rayleigh sb pretty close to Roger and they got Oden who is assumed to be equal to Scopper who is close to Rayleigh. And Mihawk is highly portrayed as God.
The fact that a whole Yonkou group is not getting votes shows the poll is quite good lmao.

I was thinking Roger's group too, but you got Roger vs Whitebeard who were equal, you got Shanks vs Mihawk who were equal... are you taking Rayleigh and Oden vs Kaidou and Big Mom? That's a tough call xD

Then there's the last group... you got Luffy + Law + Kidd who did just beat Kaidou + Big Mom, and I'm confident Dragon can take on anyone equally, and then Sabo. Also very tough.

Group D looks maybe the weakest, but you do have Rocks who took on both Roger and Whitebeard, and you got Blackbeard who's obviously totally top tier... Shiki didn' get justice done in the movie but he's up there... the group probably suffers from Enel and Crocodile, but both of those two were defeated by the main character in an unfair fight, probably they'd do well against others.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
I went with Yonkous for my second vote... can't see the four Yonkous losing lol.

Whitebeard and Roger are an equal match, so are Shanks and Mihawk. And I'm not taking Rayleigh and Oden against Kaidou and Big Mom.

I wonder if Marines would still get the votes if I took out Sengoku to make it 6 people. Still Garp and 5 Admirals.
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
The marines with their insane devil fruit powers combined are just nuts to fight against. Akainu does his lava meteor shower, Fujitor manipulates it somewhere else. Aokiji controls the battle field with his ice, impeding movement and debuffing opponents. Kizaru gives long range support with speed and overwhelming fire power. Garp and Sengoku are bonkers together and then you have Green Bull whose devil fruit seems insane.
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
I still feel that Roger in his prime was unmatched hence why he received his nickname. With Whitebeard a close second.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
The marines with their insane devil fruit powers combined are just nuts to fight against. Akainu does his lava meteor shower, Fujitor manipulates it somewhere else. Aokiji controls the battle field with his ice, impeding movement and debuffing opponents. Kizaru gives long range support with speed and overwhelming fire power. Garp and Sengoku are bonkers together and then you have Green Bull whose devil fruit seems insane.
It's the same reason that made me choose group A over C.

Yes, Haki is strong, and Kaidou did say what he said, but these are group fights, and 4 swordsmen fighting against earthquakes, fire and lightning homies and a dragon firing fire, wind and lightning attacks from all directions, seems too much. xD

Especially since Haki is the other team's argument and this team actually has Shanks, who is probably better at Haki than the other team aside from maybe Roger (who gets equalled by Whitebeard).
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
It's the same reason that made me choose group A over C.

Yes, Haki is strong, and Kaidou did say what he said, but these are group fights, and 4 swordsmen fighting against earthquakes, fire and lightning homies and a dragon firing fire, wind and lightning attacks from all directions, seems too much. xD

Especially since Haki is the other team's argument and this team actually has Shanks, who is probably better at Haki than the other team aside from maybe Roger (who gets equalled by Whitebeard).
I think Rayleigh in his prime is still the better fighter than Shanks. Roger and Rayleigh together could've been Yonko's on their own imo.
 
Messages
15,332
Reaction score
45,329
Points
33,800
Salty Doubloons
644
Hmm, actually Im calling group c. Rayleigh has the title of dark king and it still intrigues me what it does plus, he's also a coc so that should merit how strong he is. His portrayal is crazy enough to be match against either BM or Kaido. I think he can break them. Oden may be the only one taking an L but still they got 3 wins.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
I think Rayleigh in his prime is still the better fighter than Shanks. Roger and Rayleigh together could've been Yonko's on their own imo.
Maybe, though One Piece does have a theme of the new generation surpassing the old, so I think Shanks probably surpassed Rayleigh. Though that's hard for me to say cause I'm not a Shanks fan at all, while Rayleigh is my top 3 fave. xD
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
Kinda crazy that Dragon and Gear 5 Luffy ain't getting votes :O
I know nothing of Dragon so I'm not putting votes to speculation. The others have actual fights and story beats in the manga/anime. The only thing we know off dragon is that he's the most wanted criminal. And we haven't seen Luffy in his prime yet so that's also too much speculation for me.
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
Curious though, taking Sengoku away from Marines, would you two still vote for them? And what if Garp was taken too, and it was 5 Admirals?
 
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
10,550
Points
12,100
Salty Doubloons
2,050
Hmm, actually Im calling group c. Rayleigh has the title of dark king and it still intrigues me what it does plus, he's also a coc so that should merit how strong he is. His portrayal is crazy enough to be match against either BM or Kaido. I think he can break them. Oden may be the only one taking an L but still they got 3 wins.
This is also my reasoning. He's the only first mate to have received a moniker besides Roger that's not derived from a devil fruit or anything. Also, Dark King Rayleigh gives me uncrowned king vibes. As like, if it wasn't for Roger he'd have been the strongest in the crew.
[automerge]1657643816[/automerge]
Curious though, taking Sengoku away from Marines, would you two still vote for them? And what if Garp was taken too, and it was 5 Admirals?
I'd change my vote. While 5 admirals are strong. With Sengoku and Garp together it's a crazy group.
 
Top Bottom