General RP General Chat

Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
@Gintoki 20th century boys doesn't have an anime sadly, I did read it though.

it would require massive changes to the rp to do; things like BGs was added so people can do stuff outside of canon. and with 2 characters i feel adding the ability to go to more islands will just make actvity worse as players will have to post in so much stuff
I can tell you out of personal experience (because we used to be a very spar/BG heavy RP that then transitioned to canon-only) that replacing BGs for allowing people to be in multiple canon contents is far better. Posting somewhere that's canon is far more rewarding to a player. Of course you can still keep BGs as well.

As for ''activity will go worse if people have to post in so much stuff'', no one would force them to post in a lot of stuff, just like no one is forced to make a second character. The option is simply there for those who want it.
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
@Gintoki 20th century boys doesn't have an anime sadly, I did read it though.



I can tell you out of personal experience (because we used to be a very spar/BG heavy RP that then transitioned to canon-only) that replacing BGs for allowing people to be in multiple canon contents is far better. Posting somewhere that's canon is far more rewarding to a player.

As for ''activity will go worse if people have to post in so much stuff'', no one would force them to post in a lot of stuff, just like no one is forced to make a second character. The option is simply there for those who want it.
i just dont think adding it will improve the game; it stops things from making sense as people can be in 2 places at once
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
i just dont think adding it will improve the game; it stops things from making sense as people can be in 2 places at once
By that logic every game that has safe points and respawn is not good. Doesn't make much sense. That's like saying the only games that are good are ones where if you die your character gets deleted and you start all over. Sure, it's more realistic, but no one would play those games.
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
By that logic every game that has safe points and respawn is not good. Doesn't make much sense. That's like saying the only games that are good are ones where if you die your character gets deleted and you start all over. Sure, it's more realistic, but no one would play those games.
i never said it wasnt a good idea. it just stops the main point of it; which is to be canon
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
i never said it wasnt a good idea. it just stops the main point of it; which is to be canon
I mean, if you're so concerned with that, why not allow people to have one main timeline and one ''flashback''/back story thing going on at the same time?

That way a player can be on an island that is ''now'' and also in an island 2 years ago?
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
I mean, if you're so concerned with that, why not allow people to have one main timeline and one ''flashback''/back story thing going on at the same time?

That way a player can be on an island that is ''now'' and also in an island 2 years ago?
problem with that is mainly territory. how do you explain someone taking over an island 2 years ago when in the present someone else is on it etc.
You complain a lot don't you xD
this is tame lol
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
problem with that is mainly territory. how do you explain someone taking over an island 2 years ago when in the present someone else is on it etc.

this is tame lol
I mean, that's easy to fix. Just make islands that aren't ''take over'' type islands with rewards, etc.. Simply somewhere for people to post canon and end up getting exp for it.

Example: A giant ass whirlpool phenomenon at Sea with a couple of Sea King beasts and it's home to a Fishman. Boom, go RP. You won't make the damn whirlpool your territory. xD
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
I mean, that's easy to fix. Just make islands that aren't ''take over'' type islands with rewards, etc.. Simply somewhere for people to post canon and end up getting exp for it.

Example: A giant ass whirlpool phenomenon at Sea with a couple of Sea King beasts and it's home to a Fishman. Boom, go RP. You won't make the damn whirlpool your territory. xD
so that means all islands are out as 90% are terriorty lol; that severly limits flashback stuff
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
so that means all islands are out as 90% are terriorty lol; that severly limits flashback stuff
We can just make some new ones. I thought new islands can be made anyway. That way it's even better, makes sure no one can go and have a flashback on an already existing island that someone might've been gunning for for their main story.

I really like this idea, it lets you flesh out your character's past actions canonically as you RP the main story. I can't see a fault in it. Provides for more canon places to be active. Not mandatory. Doesn't interfere with anything. And it lets you flesh out your character's past without just putting it in the bio. Brings more character to those past stories as opposed to just making it up and putting it in the bio.
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
We can just make some new ones. I thought new islands can be made anyway. That way it's even better, makes sure no one can go and have a flashback on an already existing island that someone might've been gunning for for their main story.

I really like this idea, it lets you flesh out your character's past actions canonically as you RP the main story. I can't see a fault in it. Provides for more canon places to be active. Not mandatory. Doesn't interfere with anything. And it lets you flesh out your character's past without just putting it in the bio. Brings more character to those past stories as opposed to just making it up and putting it in the bio.
they can but forcing islands to not be territory feels wrong to me, why can you have one island as a territory but not the other
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
they can but forcing islands to not be territory feels wrong to me, why can you have one island as a territory but not the other
I mean you're not ''forcing'' them not to be territory. They're simply set up as non-territorial places and stories.

Look at at the canon Battle of Edd War. It's a battle at sea. Nothing to conquer. No territory. Plus it's not like every damn place ya go to has to be for conquer lol. That doesn't even happen in the canon story. xD

Plus, again, your initial concern was what if you conquer a territory during the flashback that someone else is trying to conquer during the present timeline.

If that's your concern, you can still let the flashback islands be territories that can be conquered. But they're simply new islands that no one has been gunning for up until now, since they're new.
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
I mean you're not ''forcing'' them not to be territory. They're simply set up as non-territorial places and stories.

Look at at the canon Battle of Edd War. It's a battle at sea. Nothing to conquer. No territory. Plus it's not like every damn place ya go to has to be for conquer lol. That doesn't even happen in the canon story. xD

Plus, again, your initial concern was what if you conquer a territory during the flashback that someone else is trying to conquer during the present timeline.

If that's your concern, you can still let the flashback islands be territories that can be conquered. But they're simply new islands that no one has been gunning for up until now, since they're new.
naval battles cant be territory, most islands are. adding them just so they can be used as a flashback kinda takes the point away as you can only do flashbacks on very few things
 
Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
I feel like you're being very closed-minded but that's just me. xD

0 benefit to making it completely impossible to participate in more than 1 slow-paced 1 year long story. That's not good for activity in any sense of the word.

Anyway, I gave my opinion, you can do something with it if you wish. :D
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,735
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,808
I feel like you're being very closed-minded but that's just me. xD

0 benefit to making it completely impossible to participate in more than 1 slow-paced 1 year long story. That's not good for activity in any sense of the word.

Anyway, I gave my opinion, you can do something with it if you wish. :D
i just dont wanna restrict it, an easy fix is to make it so you cant claim territories in flashbacks and either you cant be on an island that someone is doing a flashback on or you cant use certain NPCs etc.
:pepeclown: ha ha. could you imagine being level 80?
:pandacry: we need a low level alliance
 
Top Bottom