General RP General Chat

[Kaka]

pretty sure islands are the majority by alot, but yeah theres enough to make it worth at least

Plus anyone can make more, so in essence, the supply of naval battles is limitless. xD

And it ain't even just naval battles at the surface of the water, there's even underwater battles vs other water beasts, so definitely Fishman would be hella fun. xD

 

[Ziosa]

Plus anyone can make more, so in essence, the supply of naval battles is limitless. xD

And it ain't even just naval battles at the surface of the water, there's even underwater battles vs other water beasts, so definitely Fishman would be hella fun. xD

i should do an island where you fight the island itself rather than NPCs lol

 

[Kaka]

brawling is a filler MA anyway tbh; it has no canon stuff and is pretty generic. Yet we see characters use claws and fists etc with it, which to me makes it part of the fighting style. Plus it gives a reason to use these racial MA

Plus brawling can still be used by other races that don't have Electro/Toxia/Fiero etc.
[automerge]1608335461[/automerge]

i should do an island where you fight the island itself rather than NPCs lol

Lmao sounds kinda cool xD

 

[Ziosa]

Plus brawling can still be used by other races that don't have Electro/Toxia/Fiero etc.
[automerge]1608335461[/automerge]


Lmao sounds kinda cool xD

i literally only use brawling as a filler stat when idk what else to put lol

 

[The Fool]

brawling is a filler MA anyway tbh; it has no canon stuff and is pretty generic. Yet we see characters use claws and fists etc with it, which to me makes it part of the fighting style. Plus it gives a reason to use these racial MA

Brawling entails pretty much anything but yeah i agree it's a filler MA

Though Electro/Fierro/Toxia will just be mastery of that respective thing, where as when they use a Claw/Fist they will require mastery within Brawling/Rokushiki/Black Leg or a second MA no?

As how will they have mastery for even throwing a punch?

 

[Kaka]

Brawling entails pretty much anything but yeah i agree it's a filler MA

Though Electro/Fierro/Toxia will just be mastery of that respective thing, where as when they use a Claw/Fist they will require mastery within Brawling/Rokushiki/Black Leg or a second MA no?

As how will they have mastery for even throwing a punch?

Think of it like how Zoans have basic fighting included, it can be the same with Electro/Toxia/Fiero.

Otherwise it's honestly useless. No point investing 100 into a MA that can just make some fire (with Fiero for example), when Diable Jambe can do that + includes all the martial arts stuff.

Fiero/Electro/Toxia is essentially brawling with an element as a perk of that special race.

 

[Ziosa]

Brawling entails pretty much anything but yeah i agree it's a filler MA

Though Electro/Fierro/Toxia will just be mastery of that respective thing, where as when they use a Claw/Fist they will require mastery within Brawling/Rokushiki/Black Leg or a second MA no?

As how will they have mastery for even throwing a punch?

i think they can get kinda a free MA if you have electro so you can throw at least decent punches so you have something to use electro with. Otherwise like i said it is just static and needs a second MA, which shouldnt be required tbh. If you wanna do more advanced stuff etc then yeah but for basic stuff it shouldnt be needed

 

[The Fool]

Think of it like how Zoans have basic fighting included, it can be the same with Electro/Toxia/Fiero.

Otherwise it's honestly useless. No point investing 100 into a MA that can just make some fire (with Fiero for example), when Diable Jambe can do that + includes all the martial art stuff.

tbh to me it sounds like your merging two MA's really.

It's like should i have Electro and Ittoryu, would i require mastery in both or do i just put Electro Ittoryu?

 

[Ziosa]

tbh to me it sounds like your merging two MA's really.

It's like should i have Electro and Ittoryu, would i require mastery in both or do i just put Electro Ittoryu?

thats not basic lol, you would need both for that

 

[Ziosa]

of course the other GMs might just disagree lol

 

[Kaka]

tbh to me it sounds like your merging two MA's really.

It's like should i have Electro and Ittoryu, would i require mastery in both or do i just put Electro Ittoryu?

I can make the same argument that Zoans are essentially merging a DF and a MA. But it makes sense, and so does this, imo.

As for the Ittoryu example, no. Cause that's not brawling.

 

[The Fool]

i think they can get kinda a free MA if you have electro so you can throw at least decent punches so you have something to use electro with. Otherwise like i said it is just static and needs a second MA, which shouldnt be required tbh. If you wanna do more advanced stuff etc then yeah but for basic stuff it shouldnt be needed

This really goes against most of the stuff GM's have stated in the past really

It's like the example i gave in my reply to kakashi, So if you have Ittoryu and Fierro, do i need to put mastery in both or do i create Fierro Ittoryu as a single MA?

 

[Kaka]

This really goes against most of the stuff GM's have stated in the past really

It's like the example i gave in my reply to kakashi, So if you have Ittoryu and Fierro, do i need to put mastery in both or do i create Fierro Ittoryu as a single MA?

Again, only brawling can be included. Just like with Zoans.

 

[The Fool]

i don't know i just feel Electro and Brawling are two different MA's even if its just a filler MA it's still better than having Electro. though that's just me as from the start of RP that's what i was told.

 

[Ziosa]

This really goes against most of the stuff GM's have stated in the past really

It's like the example i gave in my reply to kakashi, So if you have Ittoryu and Fierro, do i need to put mastery in both or do i create Fierro Ittoryu as a single MA?

without this, electro is kinda useless as an MA; its fine to have it if it makes it useable. And it wouldnt be anything crazy, the focus is on electro itself not punching

Again, only brawling can be included. Just like with Zoans.

i think it should depend on the mink, if they have claws it can be them instead; no reason they should need a claw MA too

i don't know i just feel Electro and Brawling are two different MA's even if its just a filler MA it's still better than having Electro. though that's just me as from the start of RP that's what i was told.

A MA shouldnt need another MA to make it useful lol, its a terrible and useless MA to have if it does lol

 

[The Fool]

A MA shouldnt need another MA to make it useful lol, its a terrible and useless MA to have if it does lol

But with Brawling i have it's just not all about punching though it includes the use of the body as a weapon with kicks, use of tail, claws and fang itself

 

[Kaka]

Imo if all Electro/Fiero/Toxia does is release the element, there's no point getting it. At that point you might as well get Dials. You can release fire/toxins with those, on top of having 10 other Dials to mess with, including heat, water, eisen, etc.. xD
[automerge]1608336086[/automerge]

But with Brawling i have it's just not all about punching though it includes the use of the body as a weapon with kicks, use of tail, claws and fang itself

That should all come natural to the Mink anyway, it's part of their body. So for them that's brawling.

Now obviously if your MA includes something on the level of unleashing long-range flying slashes by swiping with your claws, then that'd probably be its own MA at that point.

 

[The Fool]

That should all come natural to the Mink anyway, it's part of their body. So for them that's brawling.

it's weird that Ziosa changing the stance on this when it's been like that and most GM's stated you will require mastery in something else too.

 

[Ebuk]

Talking from my Mink that uses both Ittoryu and Electro.
My electro is basic punches and two perks (CoA and Electro) that grants a bigger range and stronger effects per say.
The moves aren't Rokushiki moves, but still consists of basic attacks like punches and kicks imbued with electro.
The Ittoryu it's just the same with the sword imbued with Electro

 

[Kaka]

it's weird that Ziosa changing the stance on this when it's been like that and most GM's stated you will require mastery in something else too.

Who are these GMs? I feel like literally every argument you keep referring back to Larsi or something, as if he's a current GM and Ziosa is not. Ziosa is the current GM, and that's how he sees it. But he did tag Frayz and Ranger if they want to intervene. Until they do, there's no point in all of us repeating our stance 15 times. It stands as is until another GM pops in and disagrees, then the GMs can talk about it and give the final decision.