General RP General Chat

Ziosa

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,138
Reaction score
24,715
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,795
kakashi did a good example, Black Leg is this but even better as it gets a MA; a elemental style and now with status effects burns too all in one stat. so it would still be way better than Electro even with this, and ofc rokushiki would still be much better too

im just talking basic stuff
Dream said:
it's weird that Ziosa changing the stance on this when it's been like that and most GM's stated you will require mastery in something else too.
Click to expand...
we can change our stance if we realise it doesnt make sense/have always thought it should be like this and assumed other people did do and never mentioned it lol. If it just does electricity, electro is the worse MA in the entire RP; and would be buffed anyway even if it didnt do this lol
 
Ziosa

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,138
Reaction score
24,715
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,795
kakashi19283 said:
Who are these GMs? I feel like literally every argument you keep referring back to Larsi or something, as if he's a current GM and Ziosa is not. Ziosa is the current GM, and that's how he sees it. But he did tag Frayz and Ranger if they want to intervene. Until they do, there's no point in all of us repeating our stance 15 times. It stands as is until another GM pops in and disagrees, then the GMs can talk about it and give the final decision.
Click to expand...
plus was a very long time ago, the RP has evolved many times since these discussions anyway
 
Kaka

Kaka

Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
System and rules change over time, and if there's a logical argument for it, then it's fine. I do think the Diable Jambe and the Dial examples are both very logical examples.

But anyway, up to the GMs at the end of the day. I'm never making a Mink personally so for me it's w/e. xD
[automerge]1608336433[/automerge]
Another example is Fishman Karate too. It gets both water control and an actual martial art. Not just one of the two. Now if you wanted water swordsmanship, then you'd need the extra MA.
 
Ziosa

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,138
Reaction score
24,715
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,795
kakashi19283 said:
System and rules change over time, and if there's a logical argument for it, then it's fine. I do think the Diable Jambe and the Dial examples are both very logical examples.

But anyway, up to the GMs at the end of the day. I'm never making a Mink personally so for me it's w/e. xD
[automerge]1608336433[/automerge]
Another example is Fishman Karate too. It gets both water control and an actual martial art. Not just one of the two.
Click to expand...
and ittoryu is bascially two different styles as you get nittoryu combined with it lol
 
Kaka

Kaka

Messages
12,100
Reaction score
29,371
Points
29,550
Salty Doubloons
3,847
Plus even on the wiki, there are various punching and claw swiping techniques listed under Electro specifically. If it was a different fighting style it'd be listed elsewhere, just like how Fishman Karate and Fishman Jujitsu are differentiated.
 
Oreki

Oreki

Messages
5,349
Reaction score
21,907
Points
16,150
Salty Doubloons
2,479
Maybe just make electro a perk of being Mink rather than a MA. Remove all the fighting benefits it gives and only usable to electrify your weapons or whatever fighting style you choose.
 
Ichimonji

Ichimonji

Messages
4,207
Reaction score
10,703
Points
12,250
Salty Doubloons
58,052
Oreki said:
Maybe just make electro a perk of being Mink rather than a MA. Remove all the fighting benefits it gives and only usable to electrify your weapons or whatever fighting style you choose.
Click to expand...
That’s how we had it at WURP. Cause honestly, you’re already taking a stat boost for it (at least for tieflings), this just makes up to it. We’re already losing stats because of it
 
Magimasterkarp

Magimasterkarp

Messages
2,562
Reaction score
8,458
Points
10,050
Salty Doubloons
2,816
But most of the other races have their special fighting style as well. Humandrills have mimikry, dwarves have tontatta combat, fishmen have fishman karate, and maybe giants could get that Ikoku sovereignty attack. Those will then be available as an extra MA with that martial arts perk.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom