I also don't understand why but it's a vocal minority from what I gathered. Also surprises me you didn't like enies lobby as much, that and water 7 made me a lifelong fan of the entire show lol. Skypia was perhaps a better adventure story but I feel the arc after it really did develop the strawhats further. I still believe op peaked in terms of combat at that point, though. No fight or match up since then has come remotely close to the awesomeness of the SW vs CP9. Even the most recent wano match ups with their power boosts felt hollow compared to the fights in Enies Lobby. But that's on me.
Rankings for me would be the following.
1. Enies Lobby
2. Skypiea
3. Marineford
4. Wano
5. Arabasta
6. Whole Cake Island
7. Water 7
8. Sabaody
9. Thriller Bark
10. Arlong Park
11. Impel Down
12. Dressrosa
13. Fish-Man Island
14. Punk Hazard
Hmm, so just going off of your list cause I don't feel like making my own, I'd put Skypiea 1, Alabasta 2, Impel Down 3, those 3 are for sure the best for me. Then it's Sabaody for sure, because I love Kizaru, Rayleigh and Kuma, and all 3 played a huge role there. Followed by arcs like Marineford/Wano/Water 7...
Least favorites and what almost killed One Piece for me, were Fishman Island and Punk Hazard, those two were just shit. And they even came one after the other, sad times. lol
The rest (Enies Lobby, WCI, TB, Arlong) are somewhere inbetween.
Also, another unpopular opinion... for me, water 7 was 10 times better than Enies Lobby. xD