Again, canon NPCs only.
Register only the ones you took from somewhere else. If the NPC is part of your island that you're hosting, you don't have to register him. But before you start the hosting job, you do need to go check if the NPC is indeed still on the island, or if someone else took him for somewhere else.
Example...
Say I was hosting Germa Kingdom. I don't need to register Judge, Ichiji, Niji, Sanji, Yonji or Reiju. What I do need to do is check if any of those 6 were taken out of Germa to be used somewhere else. If that's the case, I can't use that character for the Germa story. And if I want to, for example, add Crocodile to my Germa story for whatever reason, I do need to register him (after making sure he's not being used somewhere else).
Hope this clarifies.
@Ziosa @Ichimonji @QuickZilver708 @Sea @tlgRen @Ebuk @Gambit @Emperor Cross @Magimasterkarp @Ranger @Gochi @Roogy @Mr. Anderson @Beerbottle @Dream @Mugiwara_Ryan @Frayz @Toyo @Larsi