Theoretically the more pirates you bring down the more your paycheck increases. So you should defeat all the named pirates that are in that story.
@Ziosa is World's DF available as a reward in the naval battle?
That DF is insane for a gunslinger. Can speed up the speed of the bullets, as well as increase their size. So you can shoot a bullet and then it turns into a cannonball-sized projectile or even bigger.
Could shoot a Muggy Ball and turn it into a much bigger explosive before it erupts. Many many possibilities.