You’re the GM, so it’s be up to you. However, one can canonically eat a DF in the middle of an arc. See Kaku/Kalifa.
I would
personally handle it one of two ways:
- Eat the DF. Use any stat gain since started IC to that stat. I.E. if he gained 4 levels since Alabasta started, his DF stat would be 16. No shuffling of stats. That makes perfect canonic sense - it’s basically what Kaku/Kalifa did.
- Eat the DF. Enter second arc. Allow a shuffle of stats but without the level gain since started - I.E. same level.
Again, I think it should be up to the host. I would personally take into account this is for fun - if bending rules a little (and it’s minor) is for the betterment of the experience, why not? That’s why I typically allow a second arc in the story with new levels (like we did in Wano).