General RP General Chat

Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
What I understand is you might have not considered the possibilities of weapon being destroyed.

The question is how a free weapon you began your adventure with can be as durable as a legendary sword ? But aight, let’s go that way. Daddy-Sama ain’t no swordsman.
It’s more a matter of game mechanics. It just isn’t balanced otherwise. Martial artists with weapons or swordsmen would be at a huge disadvantage compared to every other combat style stat investment.
 
Messages
13,594
Reaction score
41,874
Points
31,850
Salty Doubloons
11,062
if someone breaks your weapon, half your stats are useless and you can do hardly any damage
But isn’t it the weakness of all the weapons users ? It’s like saying : « Oh don’t use Kairoseki on DF users, they will not be able do do anything after. »
I might be a dick saying it but if you don’t want want your weapon to break, buy a better sword. It’s the best investment.
 
Messages
5,349
Reaction score
21,907
Points
16,150
Salty Doubloons
2,479
But isn’t it the weakness of all the weapons users ? It’s like saying : « Oh don’t use Kairoseki on DF users, they will not be able do do anything after. »
I might be a dick saying it but if you don’t want want your weapon to break, buy a better sword. It’s the best investment.
If you have maxed out your mastery that means you're capable of using your blade in the manner that no one can break it.

You probably not gonna stop using Rokushiki leg movements if someone pierces through your leg.. only Durability damage will decrease you still gonna use all attacks. No?

That's why we have a default fighting style where you can't make player handicap
 
Messages
13,594
Reaction score
41,874
Points
31,850
Salty Doubloons
11,062
If you have maxed out your mastery that means you're capable of using your blade in the manner that no one can break it.

You probably not gonna stop using Rokushiki leg movements if someone pierces through your leg.. only Durability damage will decrease you still gonna use all attacks. No?

That's why we have a default fighting style where you can't make player handicap
If Shaarib get hurt at his arms or legs, yes, following the damage, he will not be able to use his moves. It’s logic, if one of fingers break, shigan will be inutilisable with it. He ain’t indestructible.
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
if someone breaks your weapon, half your stats are useless and you can do hardly any damage
this.

Say I invest 100 stat points into 2 styles of sword MA, you break my sword....because it isn't made out of diamond, then all of a sudden, even though i'm lvl 90 and you are lvl 60, I can't even strangle you because I didn't bother to spend another 50 stat points to learn a hand to hand combat style so my blocks and punches are all D rank--and there is nothing I can do about it because you destroyed my sword and you don't have a sword so I can't even steal yours.

What other way is there in the game where you can do this to someone? The answer--there really isn't! The only things that come close don't even come close. Using seastone requires constant contact and doesn't effect static boosts given by simply consuming a DF. Yami Yami can erase those passives but also has to be in contact and this is literally the signature defining feature of the fruit--if other things could do this to DF users then the yami wouldn't be significant in any way.

So in order to balance the idea that an unnamed sword that a master swordsman is using can be destroyed, you'd have to make a mechanic that could effectively completely erase the combat stat investment of an opponent using any of the other kinds of combat styles--right? Does this sound like a head-ache? Is this making no sense? Cool, lets just keep it simple and keep doing what we have been doing :blobsweatwipe:
[automerge]1586375353[/automerge]
If Shaarib get hurt at his arms or legs, yes, following the damage, he will not be able to use his moves. It’s logic, if one of fingers break, shigan will be inutilisable with it. He ain’t indestructible.
then break their arm so they can't swing their sword.
 
Messages
13,594
Reaction score
41,874
Points
31,850
Salty Doubloons
11,062
this.

Say I invest 100 stat points into 2 styles of sword MA, you break my sword....because it isn't made out of diamond, then all of a sudden, even though i'm lvl 90 and you are lvl 60, I can't even strangle you because I didn't bother to spend another 50 stat points to learn a hand to hand combat style so my blocks and punches are all D rank--and there is nothing I can do about it because you destroyed my sword and you don't have a sword so I can't even steal yours.

What other way is there in the game where you can do this to someone? The answer--there really isn't! The only things that come close don't even come close. Using seastone requires constant contact and doesn't effect static boosts given by simply consuming a DF. Yami Yami can erase those passives but also has to be in contact and this is literally the signature defining feature of the fruit--if other things could do this to DF users then the yami wouldn't be significant in any way.

So in order to balance the idea that an unnamed sword that a master swordsman is using can be destroyed, you'd have to make a mechanic that could effectively completely erase the combat stat investment of an opponent using any of the other kinds of combat styles--right? Does this sound like a head-ache? Is this making no sense? Cool, lets just keep it simple and keep doing what we have been doing :blobsweatwipe:
[automerge]1586375353[/automerge]

then break their arm so they can't swing their sword.
You level 90 and you can invest in a sword ? If the player knew his weakness and couldn’t do something about it what can I say ? Ooopsie ?

It’s like a gunner with no ammo. Is it injustice ? no. A basic sword can’t be indestructible.
 

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,734
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,807
You level 90 and you can invest in a sword ? If the player knew his weakness and couldn’t do something about it what can I say ? Ooopsie ?

It’s like a gunner with no ammo. Is it injustice ? no. A basic sword can’t be indestructible.
basic swords arent indestructible, only cursed weapons and graded ones are
 
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
9,436
Points
7,700
Salty Doubloons
9,371
basic swords arent indestructible, only cursed weapons and graded ones are
Really????
[automerge]1586380626[/automerge]
Welp I’m mistaken. Go figure.
[automerge]1586381101[/automerge]
@Ziosa so does the rate at which someone heals their damaged limbs equal the rate at which they can mend their destroyed weapon? Or buy a new one? Cuz otherwise an injured limb’s time duration needs to be adjusted in order to be fair. Speaking of which, medicine stat and Marco df allow you to speed up your healing rate, so we would need to introduce a skill which would allow for increased rate of weapon repair no? Is there a skill like that?
 
Last edited:

Ziosa

Salutations
Messages
7,150
Reaction score
24,734
Points
22,700
Salty Doubloons
10,807
Really????
[automerge]1586380626[/automerge]
Welp I’m mistaken. Go figure.
[automerge]1586381101[/automerge]
@Ziosa so does the rate at which someone heals their damaged limbs equal the rate at which they can mend their destroyed weapon? Or buy a new one? Cuz otherwise an injured limb’s time duration needs to be adjusted in order to be fair. Speaking of which, medicine stat and Marco df allow you to speed up your healing rate, so we would need to introduce a skill which would allow for increased rate of weapon repair no? Is there a skill like that?
science is used to create weapons atm, so would be used to repair them too. tbh blacksmithing should be used rather than science but that would need a rework of lots of stuff too
 
Messages
11,159
Reaction score
38,426
Points
29,500
Salty Doubloons
235
science is used to create weapons atm, so would be used to repair them too. tbh blacksmithing should be used rather than science but that would need a rework of lots of stuff too
Iirc @Fire Tiger was the first to recommend Blacksmith as a mind stat

Though scientists should be able to also create say your own thunder or fire blade or even light saber lol
 
Top Bottom