Most people in favor of a hard-restart are the people who don't participate in the RP anymore anyways; from what I've seen at least.
However now that I'm thinking it out, I think I am in favor of a soft-reset:
Player characters would remain untouched (with an optional free-change), Major plot points in the RP would remain untouched.
The 'reset' would be along the lines of:
- Overall uneventful islands or islands that have been inactive for a long time being reset.
- Unclaimed fruit going back into circulation of the world.
- Giving the current events a deadline.
Also, maybe giving some kind of a bonus to anyone in an underrepresented faction would help.
i.e. Playing as a marine when there are 0 marines would give you an exp and/or beri bonus.
At the end of the day though, I think everyone needs to chill and wait for things to go back to normal before jumping to the conclusion that the community is dead.