Traditional Mafia Game Round 9 - Knives Out

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
227
Reaction score
170
Points
2,475
Salty Doubloons
277
Vote mechanic:
Everyone votes for 3 they suspect in tame thread and for 3 they have a strong townread in PM.

-> top townreads decides who gets lynched among top suspects.
[automerge]1596833769[/automerge]
And since townreads/observer are made in pm, scum can give themselves an advantage pushing themselves secretly.

Thats why I recommend that we start to discuss who shall become observer ~12h before day ends.
Just found this thanks this helps clarifiy what i need to do.

Now i have to look more over other stuff my one vote usally doesn't make an inpact now i have to make 3.
Atleast tope 3 town seems really easy to vote for the other side.
 
Messages
934
Reaction score
834
Points
1,300
Salty Doubloons
956
What's her usual tone and how is different compared to now?

Could you elaborate on that Hayumi read? I haven't seen him/her(Hayumi are a girl or a boy? Your avatar make me think the former) really attack Juliet in any shape or form.
It’s hard to describe tones over text, but like. Her posts are weird is all I can say. Uncharacteristic. Like the points she’s making aren’t necessary. “In my experience scum accuses people who write a paragraph” Like????? What?


:pepeclown:
[automerge]1596858510[/automerge]
@Hayumi gotta get the pronouns right.
Oh, I’m a boy lmao.

:chuu:
 
Messages
861
Reaction score
1,097
Points
5,400
Salty Doubloons
1,929
Maybe I should just claim if I'm the one who's going to be sent to trial and I have the most votes. I also don't trust the players who voted me since the votes were really weak and shaky.
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
It’s hard to describe tones over text, but like. Her posts are weird is all I can say. Uncharacteristic. Like the points she’s making aren’t necessary. “In my experience scum accuses people who write a paragraph” Like????? What?


:pepeclown:
[automerge]1596858510[/automerge]

Oh, I’m a boy lmao.

:chuu:
Well, I've come to notice that from Juliet that she makes a lot of unnecessary posts. Not scum indicative of her.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
No. It's been abolished. It will never be a thing, again. Never
I mean, as I was one of the people who introduced the concept to OJ, I am interested in why this is.

As for other comments, they'll have to wait. I'm trying to catch up in a minute, but I'm not really taking a lot in.
[automerge]1596868402[/automerge]
Oh, I’m a boy lmao
Poor Juan.
[automerge]1596868536[/automerge]
Wait, I just read, 10 posts within 48 hours? Idk if I'm going to be able to keep up with that honestly, I'm going to be hosting shortly and playing in more games.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
I mean, as I was one of the people who introduced the concept to OJ, I am interested in why this is.
I discovered that it is pointless. If the purpose of the entire thing is to make millers claim then why does everyone else need to say innocent. Millers can claim on their own without all that innocent stuff. It's an unnecessary thing to do and I've grown to hate it.

I will say, I am excited to play with you Rail. It's been a while and you've always been one of the mafia players that I looked up to on OJ.
 
Messages
4,617
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,740
find several statements from him questionable, I guess I quoted them.
This is a tipical vague scum statement.
May oberste your points to look less scummy?

What I want to convey is that.. I still haven't seen Waindo, Fallen Prince and Salah?
This one could be cause Drago subbed in for him :blobthinkhappy:



Also @Nessos I was calling your vote RVS cause that's pretty common for everyone to vote a random person at SOD with no reason. I thought you follow the same thing.
Until reading this post I was thinking to replace you with Juliet :blobthink:
Panicing cause of an early Vote?!? I meam there are still ~30h left.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
I discovered that it is pointless. If the purpose of the entire thing is to make millers claim then why does everyone else need to say innocent. Millers can claim on their own without all that innocent stuff. It's an unnecessary thing to do and I've grown to hate it.
All Innocent does is show that everyone is complying. Someone who claims neither could turn around and claim Miller later, and say they were not following the Innocent/Guilty thing. It's just a way to tick people off a checklist, nothing more than that.
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
Maybe I should just claim if I'm the one who's going to be sent to trial and I have the most votes. I also don't trust the players who voted me since the votes were really weak and shaky.
No. You're town.

Guys, unvote Juliet. I don't think she's scum and I'd rather not use a claim this phase on her.

Rej and Beky are on my baddies list atm.
 
Messages
250
Reaction score
221
Points
5,350
Salty Doubloons
252
Maybe I should just claim if I'm the one who's going to be sent to trial and I have the most votes. I also don't trust the players who voted me since the votes were really weak and shaky.
With the amount of time you have left, if you are against the reasoning why would you claim? You should be able to illustrate why they would be better claim candidates than you.
 
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
11,302
Points
8,850
Salty Doubloons
4,705
All Innocent does is show that everyone is complying. Someone who claims neither could turn around and claim Miller later, and say they were not following the Innocent/Guilty thing. It's just a way to tick people off a checklist, nothing more than that.
I still think it's an unnecessary thing to do. If they're going to come out and claim Miller later then you can pressure them for why they didn't do it at the start of the phase.

I won't dive deeply into it since we can't even do I/G based on the claim restrictions, just know that it's not a thing we do here anymore.

With the amount of time you have left, if you are against the reasoning why would you claim? You should be able to illustrate why they would be better claim candidates than you.
Is this your first game with Juliet? I'll entertain you a bit on her meta. For any time she gets pressured, she always jumps to claiming as to her, it's how she deals with getting off the best way cause it'll make her confirmed town. Or at least more likely to be one.

Only town Juliet does that. Scum Juliet want claim immediately.

So, if you're a bit suspicious of Juliet for wanting to clam, then I suggest that you shouldn't cause I think she's more likely to be town in this scenario.

I'm going to go to sleep soon. Let me do some quick Gun to Head reads here.
1. @Nessos - Good
2. @Poison Chan - Good
3. @Gambit - Good
4. @Pepper - Good
5. @RAIL_GUN - Good
6. @Beky - Bad
7. @Alice The Menace - Good
8. @Rej - Bad
9. @Juliet - Good
10. @Fallen Prince - Good
11. @Hayumi - Bad
12. @Larsi - Bad
13. @oddoddfruit - Good
14. @Trustworthy Liberal - Good
15. @Waindo - Good
16. @Salah Eddine Good
Damn. That looks terrible with the black text. I'm hitting the sack. Goodnight.

Shit, I forgot.

Vote Rej
Vote Beky


Not sure who between Hayu and Larsi to vote for yet.
 
Messages
861
Reaction score
1,097
Points
5,400
Salty Doubloons
1,929
Until reading this post I was thinking to replace you with Juliet :blobthink:
Panicing cause of an early Vote?!? I meam there are still ~30h left.
I asked what was the reasoning behind the votes since they were empty and naked votes and I don't like those kind of votes since I always find them scummy. If you're talking about panicking over a vote scum don't need to panic over a vote since they can easily tell their scum buddies in the scum chat to coordinate votes.

With the amount of time you have left, if you are against the reasoning why would you claim? You should be able to illustrate why they would be better claim candidates than you.
Sometimes I feel like as if no matter what I post questioning players they will ignore me. I asked Gambit a question and he never answered my question and he is being dodgy and evasive, Hayumi's play is also weird and I was getting a bit of shade throwing vibe from them and they made a wifom post, and Rej never came back.
 
Messages
4,617
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,740
I asked what was the reasoning behind the votes since they were empty and naked votes and I don't like those kind of votes since I always find them scummy. If you're talking about panicking over a vote scum don't need to panic over a vote since they can easily tell their scum buddies in the scum chat to coordinate votes.
Scum votes are public coordinating them is dangerous. (Obvious shifting is dangerous)
Only obeserver votes can be coordinated, cause they are might private thats why I suggested this.

Thinking about we should discuss here in public he we are going to vote up as observer.

16 player role madness
-> Mafia team of ~4
-> every member of Mafia would have 3 insta votes for observer

Don't want scum to control the lynch.

Thats why I suggest 12h before Day ends we start a public voting and everyone follows the result.

How doy you think about it?
 
Messages
877
Reaction score
1,772
Points
4,750
Salty Doubloons
1,231
I asked what was the reasoning behind the votes since they were empty and naked votes and I don't like those kind of votes since I always find them scummy. If you're talking about panicking over a vote scum don't need to panic over a vote since they can easily tell their scum buddies in the scum chat to coordinate votes.



Sometimes I feel like as if no matter what I post questioning players they will ignore me. I asked Gambit a question and he never answered my question and he is being dodgy and evasive, Hayumi's play is also weird and I was getting a bit of shade throwing vibe from them and they made a wifom post, and Rej never came back.
It's the paragraphs Juliet, people get scared by big boxes of text. I never do them anymore
 
Messages
239
Reaction score
556
Points
1,500
Salty Doubloons
212


So I'm basically here at this moment. I am trying out the spreadsheets for the first time let's see how it turns out or if it's of any help in reality.

The thing is, i did a little re read while making this and more than a few stuff caught my eyes. I'll be going player to player with their isoes before giving them an alignment certificate. but I will be doing that after having lunch and watching a movie.

Mafia is hurting my head right now for I'm playing 3 games atm, and thinking about the upcoming @RAIL_GUN 's game is making me shiver. [I CANNOT PLAY MORE THAT ONE GAME, IT GETS REALLY CONFUSING. DO NOT ASK ME WHY I CHOSE THIS MANY THEN, THE ANSWER IS, I HATE ME]
 
Messages
4,617
Reaction score
8,057
Points
12,150
Salty Doubloons
5,740
It's the paragraphs Juliet, people get scared by big boxes of text. I never do them anymore
Why should people get afraid of big text boxes?
:pepethinking:
[automerge]1596874517[/automerge]


So I'm basically here at this moment. I am trying out the spreadsheets for the first time let's see how it turns out or if it's of any help in reality.

The thing is, i did a little re read while making this and more than a few stuff caught my eyes. I'll be going player to player with their isoes before giving them an alignment certificate. but I will be doing that after having lunch and watching a movie.

Mafia is hurting my head right now for I'm playing 3 games atm, and thinking about the upcoming @RAIL_GUN 's game is making me shiver. [I CANNOT PLAY MORE THAT ONE GAME, IT GETS REALLY CONFUSING. DO NOT ASK ME WHY I CHOSE THIS MANY THEN, THE ANSWER IS, I HATE ME]
You should change your name to Mr Analytic :pepethinking:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom