[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 4 - Crazy Noisy Bizarre Town

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I'm online from the moment i first Posted till the DP ends, still lot of Hours for me

And yet you are here, using your time to do things other than trying to catch mafia.
[automerge]1581253997[/automerge]

Nahh... Just from your earlier post saying you hadn't played for some time... But you still seem pretty sharp

You got it wrong, last game I played was a month ago.

What I meant is that it's been some time time I last ventured into a community besides the two I always play at.

 

[Kibi]

Where I usually play, D1 is the most dangerous time for Mafia lol. You just have to overwhelm them and make them uncomfortable with an active thread. They don't like spicy takes and energy.

True... Most mafia don't want to be too active and accidentally end up on a train to Lynchester
[automerge]1581254212[/automerge]
I see @Gambit is developing a new meta of being whimsical in games... I'll figure you out

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I love whimsical people but I hate having to figure them out.

 

[Salah Eddine]

True, but choosing to jump into such seemed uncharacteristic of you

I didn't jump to anything, my First Post was my honest opinion on how i wished we started with D1 after N1 (It was very short Post anyway)
but it triggered lot of replies, you can go and check how Three Players replied to me and started all this Debate

So from my point of view, most of Players are just jumping on this little discussion to appear Active & Useful

 

[novaselinenever]

Nahh... Just from your earlier post saying you hadn't played for some time... But you still seem pretty sharp

Do you agree with his takes?

Above

Hmm not sure I agree, I've seen him talk about starting D1 and the lack of info before I believe. What does it being uncharacteristic of him from your PoV tell you about him this game?

 

[novaselinenever]

What I meant is that it's been some time time I last ventured into a community besides the two I always play at.

Sup DDL

 

[Kibi]

I think we should come up with new rule, like make games start with Night Phase but restrict certain actions, make N1 totally safe but few Roles can perform their Actions. This way we at least have a small chance of finding something to talk about D1

Or maybe make N1 kills a delayed kill, like the target is informed he will die next NP, i dunno just find a solution because imo both N1 deaths & D1 without info are bad

Oh my bad... I thought this was your first post

 

[Salah Eddine]

And yet you are here, using your time to do things other than trying to catch mafia.

Reading Posts isn't trying to catch Scum ?
I have all my time to observe & reply to anything i deem worthy of mentioning
My first post was a simple short comment on D1, i don't decide how others reply and prolong discussions

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Sup DDL

Hey.

You scum?

 

[Jinri]

So from my point of view, most of Players are just jumping on this little discussion to appear Active & Useful

This is how I read that squabble as well. Apparently, though, forum mafia always needs to have a "is D1 useful" discussion for some reason.

 

[Kibi]

Do you agree with his takes?

Hmm not sure I agree, I've seen him talk about starting D1 and the lack of info before I believe. What does it being uncharacteristic of him from your PoV tell you about him this game?

I agree with them... Except AFH I know nothing about his meta

Oh really, I haven't. but I had thought he joined the conversation not knowing he started it

 

[novaselinenever]

Hey.

You scum?

I'm the towniest townie

 

[A famous historian]

You are Alwaysmind from NF, correct? Nice to see you again.

You make a crappy vote and when prompted to explain it you dismiss it with the classic "town just sucks in day 1" which suggests you don't give a damn if town wins.

Please start giving a damn or you will go to my scum pile.

Correct, i am Alwaysmind. Got to see you too.

Now I didn’t dismiss it as “Town you suck” I dimissed it as “day 1 votes are pure speculations.”

Kind of a big difference

 

[novaselinenever]

I see that some decide to get caught up in useless talk about whether D1 is useful or not--noted.

This is how I read that squabble as well. Apparently, though, forum mafia always needs to have a "is D1 useful" discussion for some reason.

I don't like this entrance much. Subtlety complains about the D1's usefulness discussion, but then expends on it and highjack it for contribution. Same with her sharing Salah's observation, it doesn't feel genuine and the rambling about this being a usual discussion elsewhere as well in her experience defeats the whole point.

 

[A famous historian]

I'm the towniest townie

 

[Waindo]

So in conclusion we got nothing but ppl posting for salty doubloons D1.

 

[Jinri]

I don't like this entrance much. Subtlety complains about the D1's usefulness discussion, but then expends on it and highjack it for contribution. Same with her sharing Salah's observation, it doesn't feel genuine and the rambling about this being a usual discussion elsewhere as well in her experience defeats the whole point.

There was no subtlety in that complaint.

Furthermore, I responded to someone who stated a position on it, to which I tentatively agree with, but ultimately reject because it is just too common. So what I just said with this person is "I see your point but disagree because it happens a lot everywhere."

Aren't you the one who's ways inactive until the end of D1?
[automerge]1581256372[/automerge]
Always*

 

[A famous historian]

The Alwaysmind I know likes to hold town to a high standard. He gives people shit for not posting and voting and is always complaining about inactivity. A "day 1 is always like this" post doesn't fit him.

I was sleeping.

So in conclusion we got nothing but ppl posting for salty doubloons D1.

 

[Waindo]

There was no subtlety in that complaint.

Furthermore, I responded to someone who stated a position on it, to which I tentatively agree with, but ultimately reject because it is just too common. So what I just said with this person is "I see your point but disagree because it happens a lot everywhere."

Aren't you the one who's ways inactive until the end of D1?
[automerge]1581256372[/automerge]
Always*

Actually I'd say novas is the most active in first phases of games.

 

[novaselinenever]

The truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

There was no subtlety in that complaint.

Furthermore, I responded to someone who stated a position on it, to which I tentatively agree with, but ultimately reject because it is just too common. So what I just said with this person is "I see your point but disagree because it happens a lot everywhere."

Aren't you the one who's ways inactive until the end of D1?

There was, the snarky tone of something that appears to be a simple remark on what the discussion was about. And the sarcastic "noted" lol.

It doesn't read that way, it feels like you're highjacking it to establish a position there and enabling him but at the same time being reluctant. It doesn't feel like you ultimately reject is what I mean, the second phrase feels more like a side note. Also speaking about the discussion being too common, I don't think that means it is not worth anything. It's how someone approach something/their behavior that is relevant to figuring out their alignment rather than the discussion itself most of the time. Expand on what you "tentatively agreed" with, and those players.

Yep, that's me.