[FIN] Regular Mafia Round 4: Myth Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
I'm sure there are better ways but then again how often is scum actually caught day one?
you can catch scum D1 through interaction or through lucky night actions ?‍♀ maybe the odds are 60/40 for finding a town, roughly said
[automerge]1579208890[/automerge]
40%~ for finding scum ?‍♀
 
Messages
15,332
Reaction score
45,329
Points
33,800
Salty Doubloons
644
Maybe we should ask other GU or Naomi's claim. If not, we may try this

Vote lynch Naomi
 
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
4,314
Points
7,200
Salty Doubloons
2,726
So @Ryu Kishi

why you protecting scum, who stole ability?

You just claimed you saw me visit, but ignored the person stealing some one ability??
 
Messages
63
Reaction score
93
Points
350
Salty Doubloons
3
Well as the deity I am said I got something stolen from me and with a little reading comprehension you'll get who I am :weirdpeep:

Has anyone spot that King is being referred in the WU as "they"
I think it's just misspell. It does not fit the context of the paragraph .

yup playing for you
Appreciated, but would you die for me as well?

and and btw, if was not obvious i was joking. as why used the emote..lol
So you claim to be ocean and then state that you are "obviously joking" hence the emoji used along with it.

How is everyone doing??
Slowly dying but it's no big deal ya know.

Its like tbe opposite of how hd usually acts. Ive seen him let himself be lynched as a townie instead of claiming
Interesting, so he is the stubborn type huh?

Hmmm....but no action mentioned by host during DP.
Whenever someone use action in day , host announce it in DP.
I don't know if that's the case but if it is then it should show up at the end of this DP.


By the way if you can b healed then it will make his ability useless..
But if he is Indi then it will help mafia , because it will keep Healer busy..
And there is also possibility of ambush
I can be healed, and making his ability useless is good no? you not trying to say that such spell could possibly be townie are you?

I don't think it matters much if it's indie or mafia honestly. Not really keeping the healer busy, if anything it's the healer job to make sure the townies survive. So the healer being busy is a good thing.

Sure, there could be an ambush possibility but again an ambush can happen in any situation so does it really matter?

can you backtrack how this curse got triggered?
It happened when I was asleep my time, like 10 hours ago give or take. So this is how people greet new comer here huh? by making him die slowly in the game. Sounds fun. Looking at the players I don't see anyone who stands out who could potentially target me with this "madness" curse. Alot of people did not contribute enough either so it's hard to pin point who exactly.

I role block him. that why he sleeping, so he can't do anything.
So, now you are not joking and going full on with it being ocean huh? interesting.

You can’t do anything the first turn. So It’s pretty much an hit and miss :pepehmm:
This feels like something scum would say.
[automerge]1579213890[/automerge]
Maybe we should ask other GU or Naomi's claim. If not, we may try this

Vote lynch Naomi
When I looked at the write up I did not particularly think that ocean is necessarily evil. If what she claims is true and it's a simple role blocking ability then I can definitely see townie having such ability.
[automerge]1579214015[/automerge]
So @Ryu Kishi

why you protecting scum, who stole ability?

You just claimed you saw me visit, but ignored the person stealing some one ability??
I don't know why this entire "steal ability" is a thing. I feel like it's just an assumption you made and went along with it. It's not necessarily true ya know? so I don't know why we are focusing on stealing abilities exactly. Unless you know more than you are willing to say.
 
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
4,314
Points
7,200
Salty Doubloons
2,726
​

I don't know why this entire "steal ability" is a thing. I feel like it's just an assumption you made and went along with it. It's not necessarily true ya know? so I don't know why we are focusing on stealing abilities exactly. Unless you know more than you are willing to say.
past game, scum stole watcher ability, and used that to wolf.. then if can steal town attack role. more damage on town. This is my concern.
[automerge]1579214415[/automerge]
Between usopp not claiming, what King stole.

Then we got Ryu, protecting king..hmm
In a back alley of Mythic Town King was loitering around bored out of their mind when they saw Sun pass by. Not skipping on any chance for fun, they hurriedly challenged them to a duel. Sun defended with armor, but King's stick smashed it to pieces. Taking a treasure as trophy, King left the scene cackling like a madman.
Also with gambit sheep vote, looks like total scum move on his part.
 
Last edited:
Messages
63
Reaction score
93
Points
350
Salty Doubloons
3
past game, scum stole watcher ability, and used that to wolf.. then if can steal town attack role. more damage on town. This is my concern.
You see, this would make sense if the person who found out what ocean was doing was King himself. But from the write up it was Falcon. Completely two different people here. If it was King who watched ocean role block then sure this statement of yours would hold some water but that's not the case here since it's falcon who saw ocean and not king, as far as we are aware king is the one who stole something from sun. Now what that thing is I don't know also have good feeling that King is an indie role.

Also, in the write up it did not mention that falcon saw king and sun. It only states he watched ocean. So the statement law did feels like it's trying to throw people off and you rolled on with it.

Last thing, it's better to keep past games past. It can lead people to a deep rabbit hole.
 
Messages
63
Reaction score
93
Points
350
Salty Doubloons
3
If Falcon is on Sun then he should know identity of Ocen and King too..
And if he is tracker then of only Ocen.
Had to come back to this after seeing naomi comment about it and making up her mind with this thought of thinking.

What made you think exactly that Falcon is on Sun? nothing in the WU states so. This seems like you are trying to throw people off.
 
Messages
1,950
Reaction score
4,314
Points
7,200
Salty Doubloons
2,726
You see, this would make sense if the person who found out what ocean was doing was King himself. But from the write up it was Falcon. Completely two different people here. If it was King who watched ocean role block then sure this statement of yours would hold some water but that's not the case here since it's falcon who saw ocean and not king, as far as we are aware king is the one who stole something from sun. Now what that thing is I don't know also have good feeling that King is an indie role.

Also, in the write up it did not mention that falcon saw king and sun. It only states he watched ocean. So the statement law did feels like it's trying to throw people off and you rolled on with it.

Last thing, it's better to keep past games past. It can lead people to a deep rabbit hole.
alright, oh miss read that >_< my bad.

But people voting me off. Do they honestly expect role blocker not to rb on first night? I can understand scum attacker on first night, hitting someone. But past play with town rb should always rb to ensure they hit scum attacker.

@Fire Tiger how much time left?
 
Messages
63
Reaction score
93
Points
350
Salty Doubloons
3
@Trafalgar Law Also, looking at your post again regarding me being poisoned/cursed I get the feeling that you do not necessarily want me to be healed with those odd comments you provided. It's like making excuses not to heal. Can be a paranoid townie and overthinking or...
 
Messages
1,915
Reaction score
2,972
Points
2,950
Salty Doubloons
2,063
Had to come back to this after seeing naomi comment about it and making up her mind with this thought of thinking.

What made you think exactly that Falcon is on Sun? nothing in the WU states so. This seems like you are trying to throw people off.
That's why i us If
[automerge]1579215194[/automerge]
@Trafalgar Law Also, looking at your post again regarding me being poisoned/cursed I get the feeling that you do not necessarily want me to be healed with those odd comments you provided. It's like making excuses not to heal. Can be a paranoid townie and overthinking or...
And i give the reason why i think so !
 

AL.

Messages
3,053
Reaction score
6,731
Points
10,200
Salty Doubloons
3,404
ryu is rubbing me the wrong way with that vote

but than again its ryu
 
Messages
1,155
Reaction score
5,065
Points
3,250
Salty Doubloons
1,150
alright, oh miss read that >_< my bad.

But people voting me off. Do they honestly expect role blocker not to rb on first night? I can understand scum attacker on first night, hitting someone. But past play with town rb should always rb to ensure they hit scum attacker.

@Fire Tiger how much time left?
1 hour
 
Messages
63
Reaction score
93
Points
350
Salty Doubloons
3
That's why i us If
But nothing in the WU states or even remotely hint such situation. So the entire thought process makes no sense. Even put in a "if" context. Why would anyone think that? it's like you are trying to come out with stuff for the sake of it not thinking if it makes sense or not.
[automerge]1579215656[/automerge]
But people voting me off. Do they honestly expect role blocker not to rb on first night? I can understand scum attacker on first night, hitting someone. But past play with town rb should always rb to ensure they hit scum attacker.

I am looking at this post and thinking to myself, are you being genuine or this is an act. You are right if I was a roleblocker I would of probably used it first night as well. Your argument here is totally valid, and honestly i am getting the feelings that you are being genuine here. Who are currently in your sus list and would lynch this DP? what do you think of law?
 
Messages
1,915
Reaction score
2,972
Points
2,950
Salty Doubloons
2,063
But nothing in the WU states or even remotely hint such situation. So the entire thought process makes no sense. Even put in a "if" context. Why would anyone think that? it's like you are trying to come out with stuff for the sake of it not thinking if it makes sense or not.
Dude just read the WU...
Falcon was watching someone , could be tracker or lookout.
Ocen used ability on Sun..
If he is tracker he can tell Ocen
If he is look out he can tell both...so simple..
And his result was Ocen (Naomi) visit Sun (GU)
He didn't claim more than that...

And Falcon is more like God Garuda , which make him townie..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom