Traditional Mafia Game Round 9 - Knives Out

[Pepper]

Say who was that said they were the "star of the show" earlier?
I want to look back on that quote

 

[Juliet]

The reason for his Death can clearly be seen & guessed, he was very Active, they killed Activity this DP by getting rid of him.
Many players are taking advantage of that now

Yeah definitely Genuine but we can't vote for her to be an Observer this DP, but we won't be breaking rules if we vote for her as Suspect, she will still be helpful during Trials.
As for Observers, i will wait & see what Majority thinks to give my final thoughts & vote

I'd like to see Hayumi questioned again so that we get his Claim, leaving a D1 Suspect unchecked any longer will only result in more confusion.
As for Odd i have a guess regarding his Role and it's not Scum one but at same time i don't think his Claim would hurt Town, assuming my guess is right ofc. Whether i'm right or wrong though i won't vote for him as Observer

I broke it down into separate paragraphs, it's same thing
There is no need to question you more, because what i said was mostly one-sided, i wasn't asking for answers
Not to mention that the only way to fully remove doubts is by claiming which i don't want in this Phase
We can hear your defense during Trial Phase if others follow in voting you as Suspect

The host kept saying to vote all three in single post
I checked your posts, you seem very determined to lynch Trustworthy since game began, you didn't even bother give thoughts about last Trial, you just continue to push for Trustworthy, does your wincon demand that?

Hi Scum, how are you? what do you think should we lynch you today or let you play a little longer?
I mean your posts are extremely valuable, each one of them holds so much info, i believe it's better to keep you around more

So for my Suspects Votes, i'm gonna vote Drago & Hayumi, as for third spot, it will either be Poison or Pepper
@Poison Chan it's your choice, do you want us to vote you as Suspect so that you participate during Trials and act as fourth Observer against Drago & Hayumi or you prefer that we vote Pepper?

I saw why Beky got voted off. Nessos, Drago, and Poison voted Beky as suspect for scum reading him, when he claimed cop the observers said the character doesn't fit a cop. I wouldn't always look too much in a character having to fit the role because there can always be some roles where a character doesn't fit the role but sadly there are some players out there who would say the character doesn't fit the role. I was leaning town on Nessos and Drago on day 1 and Drago hasn't even said much today. Trustworthy's play on day 1 was so scummy and even Nessos said he was getting scum vibes from Trustworthy. Trustworthy's play on day 1 didn't look like it was coming from a town thought process.

 

[Larsi]

I know there's not much to read, but today has honestly been hell, and I'm about to crash. Woke up, had to take care of my wife and take her to the emergency room, late for work. Hellish work week due to big sale to start off fall season. I'm gonna eat, try to sleep and I'll catch up if day is still ongoing when I wake up.

 

[Rej]

Also thinking about it I would guess that majority of the main family is considered town regardless of personality with scum actually consisting of the protag, the black sheep of the family, and the cops

Funnily enough wanting to being carried feels like it could match a couple family members, though if that is actually affects their roles or not who knows

isnt @Salah Eddine the one with flavour knowledge?

So for my Suspects Votes, i'm gonna vote Drago & Hayumi, as for third spot, it will either be Poison or Pepper
@Poison Chan it's your choice, do you want us to vote you as Suspect so that you participate during Trials and act as fourth Observer against Drago & Hayumi or you prefer that we vote Pepper?

might take a while until she answers, so you can't depend on her

Gambits pretty towny but not confident on making that a top read if mine.

what is iffying you?
[automerge]1597185270[/automerge]

I know there's not much to read, but today has honestly been hell, and I'm about to crash. Woke up, had to take care of my wife and take her to the emergency room, late for work. Hellish work week due to big sale to start off fall season. I'm gonna eat, try to sleep and I'll catch up if day is still ongoing when I wake up.

you can be glad, ya not living in EuW



gotta head to bed for now

 

[Pepper]

isnt @Salah Eddine the one with flavour knowledge?



might take a while until she answers, so you can't depend on her

what is iffying you?
[automerge]1597185270[/automerge]

you can be glad, ya not living in EuW



gotta head to bed for now

Cause Salah is the only one who has seen the movie
I mentioned seeing it in the sign up thread
But I don't blame any schmucks for not reading every post there after all I don't

 

[Juliet]

Btw, since Nessos was janitor cleaned mafia will be using dead cleaned players roles as their fake claim and in the trial whoever the observers are and asks for a claim during the trial they will have to say along the lines of what's your ability, who did you target each night, and why did you target those players. We don't even know if the janitor ability is a 1 shot or if it is unlimited. Normally a janitor ability in trad is a 1 shot and in tos it is unlimited.

 

[Trustworthy Liberal]

Btw, since Nessos was janitor cleaned mafia will be using dead cleaned players roles as their fake claim and in the trial whoever the observers are and asks for a claim during the trial they will have to say along the lines of what's your ability, who did you target each night, and why did you target those players. We don't even know if the janitor ability is a 1 shot or if it is unlimited. Normally a janitor ability in trad is a 1 shot and in tos it is unlimited.

I like this train if thought assumeing they have the info is safer.
Think it means we should save claims for before trial?
That has multiple people can comment in it over three?

 

[Alice The Menace]

Btw, since Nessos was janitor cleaned mafia will be using dead cleaned players roles as their fake claim and in the trial whoever the observers are and asks for a claim during the trial they will have to say along the lines of what's your ability, who did you target each night, and why did you target those players. We don't even know if the janitor ability is a 1 shot or if it is unlimited. Normally a janitor ability in trad is a 1 shot and in tos it is unlimited.

I like this post from Juliet. It's coming from a Townie mindset.


Drago on the other hand didn't gave importance on Salah's post. not a Towny trait.

A townie mindset shouldn't be afraid to answer right away. He asked to break down Salah's post because he's afraid to slip.

I want to put Hayumi again on trial. She can claim there. I forgot who suggested it.. But we shouldn't take the claim spots during the Interrogation phase. And let the suspects take the claiming spot during Trial.

 

[Pepper]

I think it's fair to go ahead and put individuals who aren't as active (including me don't act like I'm unaware of my own post count) on trial since the process is a lot less strict compared other setups

 

[oddoddfruit]

I'm feeling a bit disrespected here so I'm going to take a claim space like I said I would


@Oreki

I'm Alan Stevens the Lawyer, I am town, I have a passive where I am immune to roleblocks and redirections and I have an active ability where I can recharge 1-shots.

 

[Pepper]

I'm feeling a bit disrespected here so I'm going to take a claim space like I said I would


@Oreki

I'm Alan Stevens the Lawyer, I am town, I have a passive where I am immune to roleblocks and redirections and I have an active ability where I can recharge 1-shots.

what the fu...

 

[Hayumi]

I think it's fair to go ahead and put individuals who aren't as active (including me don't act like I'm unaware of my own post count) on trial since the process is a lot less strict compared other setups

I’m down to claim whenever if enough people want me to.
[automerge]1597199475[/automerge]
Oops wrong quote lmao. But yah I’m down to claim

 

[Pepper]

I’m down to claim whenever if enough people want me to.
[automerge]1597199475[/automerge]
Oops wrong quote lmao. But yah I’m down to claim

Would be nice and all if someone didn't already just f*cking took a slot because they felt "disrespected"
[automerge]1597204577[/automerge]
Well I'm going to sleep and will just leave my votes here
Vote Hayumi, OddOddFruit, and Dragomir
Observers will be Rej, juliet and I dunno Alice

 

[Poison Chan]

okay so I read stuff. Given the activity it's hard to distinguish players tbh.
anyways,

Odd is pretty odd this game just saying.

Vote suspect #1: Odd
Vote suspect #2: Drago - I dislike how he did not buy the claim of Beky.
Vote suspect #3: Larsi - just a hunch

uh, I didn't buy Beky claim either why aren't you voting me?

I just want to be an observer and then let Salah carry me, nothing wrong with that
[automerge]1597155631[/automerge]
I might be taking a claim spot if you don't start blindly trusting me
[automerge]1597156041[/automerge]
Let me make this clear, I'm going to be lazy this game and everyone else has to carry me the whole way

I do not understand why you are so dependent on Salah and agreeing with him so much?
@Salah Eddine was there any lover/couple characters in the movie?

Back off, getting carried is my strat

that's my strat when I'm scum .

Tbh, I think one of the reasons Nessos died was because he hard defended me when discussing who to lynch for the trial based off my meta and his familiarity with my town play. Especially since leaving me as the remaining three of the initial trial is an easy af angle to push.

I do not think the same.

So for my Suspects Votes, i'm gonna vote Drago & Hayumi, as for third spot, it will either be Poison or Pepper
@Poison Chan it's your choice, do you want us to vote you as Suspect so that you participate during Trials and act as fourth Observer against Drago & Hayumi or you prefer that we vote Pepper?

I don't mind being in trial for interacting with others, but here's what I thought Just now, the observers get 5 trust points, now if we go according to your plan from day 1 that both the suspects and the observers should be same, we might get scums in the observers and they would get enough trust points to buy those which are helpful for them. also, no I do not mind being in trial as a suspect, but wouldn't that be bad if we could have three suspects everyone is suspecting and having them interact more?

might take a while until she answers, so you can't depend on her

I was sleeping ~. ~

Btw, since Nessos was janitor cleaned mafia will be using dead cleaned players roles as their fake claim and in the trial whoever the observers are and asks for a claim during the trial they will have to say along the lines of what's your ability, who did you target each night, and why did you target those players. We don't even know if the janitor ability is a 1 shot or if it is unlimited. Normally a janitor ability in trad is a 1 shot and in tos it is unlimited.

uh I do not think they would know the roles they janitored unless they rolecopped him first.

 

[Gambit]

uh, I didn't buy Beky claim either why aren't you voting me?

You got a point. Odd alrdy claimed townie role so Immana change it.
Vote suspect #1: Poison
Vote suspect #2: Drago - I dislike how he did not buy the claim of Beky.
Vote suspect #3: Larsi - just a hunch

 

[Rej]

@Alice The Menace
@oddoddfruit
@Larsi

Your votes?

 

[Alice The Menace]

VOTELYNCH :
DRAGO, HAYUMI,

I'm still undecided for the third one.
[automerge]1597210728[/automerge]
I will vote for you Rej as One of the OBSERVERS. The other two will be secret here so Scums will have low probability to have an observer of their choice.

 

[RAIL_GUN]

Vote - Odd, Poison
Observer - Juliet, Gambit

 

[Salah Eddine]

I saw why Beky got voted off. Nessos, Drago, and Poison voted Beky as suspect for scum reading him, when he claimed cop the observers said the character doesn't fit a cop. I wouldn't always look too much in a character having to fit the role because there can always be some roles where a character doesn't fit the role but sadly there are some players out there who would say the character doesn't fit the role. I was leaning town on Nessos and Drago on day 1 and Drago hasn't even said much today. Trustworthy's play on day 1 was so scummy and even Nessos said he was getting scum vibes from Trustworthy. Trustworthy's play on day 1 didn't look like it was coming from a town thought process.

U missed my point, i wasn't asking for your thoughts regarding Trials, i just found it interesting how you deemed it unnecessary to say them & just continue pushing for Trustworthy

I do not understand why you are so dependent on Salah and agreeing with him so much?
@Salah Eddine was there any lover/couple characters in the movie?

Yeah Rej & Sarah

I don't mind being in trial for interacting with others, but here's what I thought Just now, the observers get 5 trust points, now if we go according to your plan from day 1 that both the suspects and the observers should be same, we might get scums in the observers and they would get enough trust points to buy those which are helpful for them. also, no I do not mind being in trial as a suspect, but wouldn't that be bad if we could have three suspects everyone is suspecting and having them interact more?

I said it countless times, that strategy was for last DP only & it work well because u didn't ask for Nessos's Claim
Now just vote trusty Observers

You got a point. Odd alrdy claimed townie role so Immana change it.
Vote suspect #1: Poison
Vote suspect #2: Drago - I dislike how he did not buy the claim of Beky.
Vote suspect #3: Larsi - just a hunch

You seem to believe his Claim so fast

Anyway here is the problem, if we vote for Poison + two Suspects, only one of them will Claim so Observers will either be forced to deny that person's Claim whatever it is or Lynch the second person who couldn't Claim
If we vote for Poison + OOF + Suspect, then that third person will most likely get Lynched since OOF already claimed

This is why i changed my mind, it's better to vote for OOF along with two other Suspects, i'd prioritize these two over Drago for now;

Vote Suspect OOF, Hayumi, Pepper
@Oreki
[automerge]1597219209[/automerge]

it work well because u didn't ask for Nessos's Claim

It didn't work well*

 

[Dragomir]

So, what's up? What's going on right now?