Traditional Mafia Game Round 9 - Knives Out

[Rej]

U missed my point, i wasn't asking for your thoughts regarding Trials, i just found it interesting how you deemed it unnecessary to say them & just continue pushing for Trustworthy

Yeah Rej & Sarah

I said it countless times, that strategy was for last DP only & it work well because u didn't ask for Nessos's Claim
Now just vote trusty Observers

You seem to believe his Claim so fast

Anyway here is the problem, if we vote for Poison + two Suspects, only one of them will Claim so Observers will either be forced to deny that person's Claim whatever it is or Lynch the second person who couldn't Claim
If we vote for Poison + OOF + Suspect, then that third person will most likely get Lynched since OOF already claimed

This is why i changed my mind, it's better to vote for OOF along with two other Suspects, i'd prioritize these two over Drago for now;

Vote Suspect OOF, Hayumi, Pepper
@Oreki
[automerge]1597219209[/automerge]

It didn't work well*

Whats your case on pepper?
Pepper 4 scum and observer?
[automerge]1597220199[/automerge]

So, what's up? What's going on right now?

Someone got a guilty result on you, whats your defense?

 

[Salah Eddine]

Whats your case on pepper?
Pepper 4 scum and observer?

I checked their posts, didn't like any
And no, i'm not going vote for Pepper as Observer

As i said that strategy is only for D1
Another reason why we can't use it anymore is because those we vote as Suspects will most probably Claim during Trials
If their Claim is legit & they prove to be Town & we voted them as Observers too then we won't be able to vote them again the next DP
We will be at a disadvantage that way, so it's like i said, that strategy was only for D1

I will vote for Observers right before DP ends, i need to choose the ones who we won't hopefully need next DP while still kinda giving town vibes

 

[Rej]

I checked their posts, didn't like any
And no, i'm not going vote for Pepper as Observer

As i said that strategy is only for D1
Another reason why we can't use it anymore is because those we vote as Suspects will most probably Claim during Trials
If their Claim is legit & they prove to be Town & we voted them as Observers too then we won't be able to vote them again the next DP
We will be at a disadvantage that way, so it's like i said, that strategy was only for D1

I will vote for Observers right before DP ends, i need to choose the ones who we won't hopefully need next DP while still kinda giving town vibes

Ok gotcha, Juliet is high on my list for observer. About the rest, I am adaptive. How much time we got left btw?
[automerge]1597221999[/automerge]
1h and 5 mins till EoD?

 

[Trustworthy Liberal]

Okay it's 2am but I finally have my phone so let me say some thoughts I have from rereading.
Odd claiming/taking a claim I don't know if it's towny and honestly reasoning seems bad to me at least but the claim in if itself seems towny?
I hate being busy and these phases feeling like there is less time then there actually is for me kinda sucks but what ever I guess.
Are we voting in a town and two suspects as the suspects am personally fine with this plan would suggest Poison myself as I trust them and can't be observer this round since was last.
Observer: Odd, Gambit, Rej?
Trial: Poison, Drago, Hayumir?

See peppers name Getting thrown around alittle but they see to have done more then their last mafia game I say so inclined to trust it for now.
[automerge]1597223409[/automerge]

Ok gotcha, Juliet is high on my list for observer. About the rest, I am adaptive. How much time we got left btw?
[automerge]1597221999[/automerge]
1h and 5 mins till EoD?

Less then an hour okay then...

Juliets I feel is kinda towny for their thoughts but are wrongfully tunneling me really could sub them into Observer alot but feel I have decent people there already

 

[Larsi]

OK, caught up, though I just skimmed. Also, so many people not following the voting format.

Vote Suspect oddoddfruit (the way he's begging for observer is iffy, and then claiming out of nowhere)
Vote Suspect Trustworthy Liberal (Unlike me, didn't give a reason for absence this DP)
Vote Suspect Dragomir (I already didn't like his play much before the voting phase, but then there was the voting phase, and dipping out during this day phase.)

I'm not sure who to vote for observer atm, salah's an option, but he didn't want it. Probably juliet again at least.

 

[Trustworthy Liberal]

Okay it's 2am but I finally have my phone so let me say some thoughts I have from rereading.
Odd claiming/taking a claim I don't know if it's towny and honestly reasoning seems bad to me at least but the claim in if itself seems towny?
I hate being busy and these phases feeling like there is less time then there actually is for me kinda sucks but what ever I guess.
Are we voting in a town and two suspects as the suspects am personally fine with this plan would suggest Poison myself as I trust them and can't be observer this round since was last.
Observer: Odd, Gambit, Rej?
Trial: Poison, Drago, Hayumir?

See peppers name Getting thrown around alittle but they see to have done more then their last mafia game I say so inclined to trust it for now.
[automerge]1597223409[/automerge]

Less then an hour okay then...

Juliets I feel is kinda towny for their thoughts but are wrongfully tunneling me really could sub them into Observer alot but feel I have decent people there already

Forgot to Bold.
Vote Suspect Poison
Vote Suspect Dragomir
Vote Suspect Hayumir

Cool so that should be all then I think I got it all this time.
Also Larsi I was not home most of today's phase most was at a friends who I haven't been able to hang with since October and we chilled with out group playing VR games and DnD. Since you stated I did say where I was today I got back at my other lists and is now 2:30am so kinda tired.

 

[Oreki]

- I've Extended the Interrogation Phase for 7 hours as I will not be able to start trial anytime soon -

2. @Poison Chan
3. @Gambit
4. @Pepper
5. @RAIL_GUN
7. @Alice The Menace
8. @Rej
9. @Juliet
10. @Fallen Prince
11. @Hayumi
12. @Larsi
13. @oddoddfruit
14. @Trustworthy Liberal
15. @Waindo
16. @Salah Eddine

 

[Rej]

Okay it's 2am but I finally have my phone so let me say some thoughts I have from rereading.
Odd claiming/taking a claim I don't know if it's towny and honestly reasoning seems bad to me at least but the claim in if itself seems towny?
I hate being busy and these phases feeling like there is less time then there actually is for me kinda sucks but what ever I guess.
Are we voting in a town and two suspects as the suspects am personally fine with this plan would suggest Poison myself as I trust them and can't be observer this round since was last.
Observer: Odd, Gambit, Rej?
Trial: Poison, Drago, Hayumir?

See peppers name Getting thrown around alittle but they see to have done more then their last mafia game I say so inclined to trust it for now.
[automerge]1597223409[/automerge]

Less then an hour okay then...

Juliets I feel is kinda towny for their thoughts but are wrongfully tunneling me really could sub them into Observer alot but feel I have decent people there already

This is a different juliet btw, dw same shit happened to me when entering TS xD I expected TS juliet to be the same as ours xD

Can you reelaborate your reads on juliet now?
[automerge]1597225428[/automerge]
I just came back from work and glad its getting extended. I am heading to bed. Ya'll better make posts.
[automerge]1597225452[/automerge]

OK, caught up, though I just skimmed. Also, so many people not following the voting format.

Vote Suspect oddoddfruit (the way he's begging for observer is iffy, and then claiming out of nowhere)
Vote Suspect Trustworthy Liberal (Unlike me, didn't give a reason for absence this DP)
Vote Suspect Dragomir (I already didn't like his play much before the voting phase, but then there was the voting phase, and dipping out during this day phase.)

I'm not sure who to vote for observer atm, salah's an option, but he didn't want it. Probably juliet again at least.

Sounds genuine

 

[Larsi]

Cool so that should be all then I think I got it all this time.
Also Larsi I was not home most of today's phase most was at a friends who I haven't been able to hang with since October and we chilled with out group playing VR games and DnD. Since you stated I did say where I was today I got back at my other lists and is now 2:30am so kinda tired.

You're the most tentative on my list, so it might change.

I am heading to bed.

Don't you live in germany? It's the middle of the day lmao

 

[Rej]

@Salah Eddine @oddoddfruit
Do you guys have reads on Larsi or the inactives?

Gonna check it out later.
[automerge]1597225541[/automerge]

You're the most tentative on my list, so it might change.

Don't you live in germany? It's the middle of the day lmao

I have migraine I need a small nap of 1-3 hours

 

[oddoddfruit]

@Salah Eddine @oddoddfruit
Do you guys have reads on Larsi or the inactives?

Gonna check it out later.
[automerge]1597225541[/automerge]

I have migraine I need a small nap of 1-3 hours

I don't have reads on anyone, just hoping Salah is town and I get carried
[automerge]1597226662[/automerge]
@Salah Eddine who are you voting for?

 

[Salah Eddine]

@Salah Eddine @oddoddfruit
Do you guys have reads on Larsi or the inactives?

Gonna check it out later.

By inactives do you mean most Players xD
Let's see:

1. Gambit --- Totally non-existent this DP, could be a Scum who agreed to kill Nessos & kill Activity & now they are taking advantage of that, extremely low Activity compared to D1 (@Gambit explain your low Activity, give us some real life excuse please)

2. Pepper --- Already gave my thoughts & voted on them, their Posts seem more like reaching Posts Requirements and playing too safe

3. RAIL --- Same as Gambit (@RAIL_GUN why the absence?)

4. Alice --- Same but i feel genuine effort tbh & they voted for same Suspects so hard to determine their motives

5. Larsi --- Exact same play as last ToS where he was Scum, it's just that i have been in long Hiatsu & i forgot his Town Play so can't be sure, but still, i lean he is Scum for now

6. Trustworthy --- I don't recall their Playstyle (Sorry if we played together a lot before, i just don't remember) but i honestly can't sense genuine thoughts, it's like they are gathering from what they read & coming up with a way to rephrase it as their own original post. Neutral reads, need more time

7 Waindo --- If he is still playing then he is Town because it matches a Character in the Movie & if he was subbed plz tell me who replaced him?

Btw, no one asked for Info or that nazi kid was the only invest we had?
If someone have really important info, we can vote for them as Suspect so they can claim during Trials, Poison doesn't necessarily have to be voted again if there is a better Townie with Info

If OOF is Town then what i said about Family Members can be both Town or Scum still stands
But if OOF is 3rd or something (I mean with that exact Role he claimed, assuming he didn't lie) then what Pepper said about Invests & non-family Characters being Scum could be true

I don't have reads on anyone, just hoping Salah is town and I get carried
[automerge]1597226662[/automerge]
@Salah Eddine who are you voting for?

If i'm Town, Scum will kill me soon, don't worry & if i'm Scum then i will be forced to claim when left alone too long
Either way, you better start being helpful & stop counting on me
I can't figure out how Roles are distributed among Characters until we catch the first Scum

 

[Larsi]

Oh lmao, I assumed Wai had been subbed out, thought I'd read it. Might've been confusing it with something else.

 

[Gambit]

1. Gambit --- Totally non-existent this DP, could be a Scum who agreed to kill Nessos & kill Activity & now they are taking advantage of that, extremely low Activity compared to D1 (@Gambit explain your low Activity, give us some real life excuse please)

I just woke up and honestly the game activity also affected mine. There's no RL scenario aside from playing another game which is very active.

I will try to catch up everything.

 

[oddoddfruit]

By inactives do you mean most Players xD
Let's see:

1. Gambit --- Totally non-existent this DP, could be a Scum who agreed to kill Nessos & kill Activity & now they are taking advantage of that, extremely low Activity compared to D1 (@Gambit explain your low Activity, give us some real life excuse please)

2. Pepper --- Already gave my thoughts & voted on them, their Posts seem more like reaching Posts Requirements and playing too safe

3. RAIL --- Same as Gambit (@RAIL_GUN why the absence?)

4. Alice --- Same but i feel genuine effort tbh & they voted for same Suspects so hard to determine their motives

5. Larsi --- Exact same play as last ToS where he was Scum, it's just that i have been in long Hiatsu & i forgot his Town Play so can't be sure, but still, i lean he is Scum for now

6. Trustworthy --- I don't recall their Playstyle (Sorry if we played together a lot before, i just don't remember) but i honestly can't sense genuine thoughts, it's like they are gathering from what they read & coming up with a way to rephrase it as their own original post. Neutral reads, need more time

7 Waindo --- If he is still playing then he is Town because it matches a Character in the Movie & if he was subbed plz tell me who replaced him?

Btw, no one asked for Info or that nazi kid was the only invest we had?
If someone have really important info, we can vote for them as Suspect so they can claim during Trials, Poison doesn't necessarily have to be voted again if there is a better Townie with Info

If OOF is Town then what i said about Family Members can be both Town or Scum still stands
But if OOF is 3rd or something (I mean with that exact Role he claimed, assuming he didn't lie) then what Pepper said about Invests & non-family Characters being Scum could be true

If i'm Town, Scum will kill me soon, don't worry & if i'm Scum then i will be forced to claim when left alone too long
Either way, you better start being helpful & stop counting on me
I can't figure out how Roles are distributed among Characters until we catch the first Scum

You know, town Salah would have just used this opportunity while it was on the table

 

[Oreki]

@AL. Has subbed in for @Waindo ​

 

[AL.]

um so hi guys

 

[AL.]

someone with a rundown??

 

[Juliet]

Lynching me will also look bad for the observers and your points are gonna go down. I am scummy? Sure. I was coasting? Sure sure but I was passive for a reason.

On day 1 you said you were playing passive and normally the normal way to play passive is to not vote at all. You made yourself scummy on day 1 and brought yourself more attention on day 1 and how is this a passive play on what you were doing on day 1?

Okay it's 2am but I finally have my phone so let me say some thoughts I have from rereading.
Odd claiming/taking a claim I don't know if it's towny and honestly reasoning seems bad to me at least but the claim in if itself seems towny?
I hate being busy and these phases feeling like there is less time then there actually is for me kinda sucks but what ever I guess.
Are we voting in a town and two suspects as the suspects am personally fine with this plan would suggest Poison myself as I trust them and can't be observer this round since was last.
Observer: Odd, Gambit, Rej?
Trial: Poison, Drago, Hayumir?

You said earlier today you were leaning town on Poison and now you put her as your suspect.

I just woke up and honestly the game activity also affected mine. There's no RL scenario aside from playing another game which is very active.

I will try to catch up everything.

On day 1 you said you were playing passive for a reason and now you say the activity affected you and are busy playing another game. This doesn't seem to match on what you are saying on day 1.


Vote Suspect Trustworthy Liberal
Vote Suspect Gambit

 

[Rej]

someone with a rundown??

we still found 0 scum, but we have some suspects, just vote suspected players and I guess we be fine
you read the mechanic stuff?
[automerge]1597241182[/automerge]
If I had no migraine and 40 degrees in my room I'd already steamrolled this game