If we follow your COO theory, they are on the same speed Tier.
If not, Shaarib is faster by one speed tier. *.*
And that's why you'd never beat Akainu if I hosted you anyway, cause you only look at stats lol.
If Akainu covers the whole battlefield in magma and then turns himself into magma and merges with the massive ass field of magma, how are you ever going to find him and attack him with your COA, when your COO awareness barely has any range? You're just gonna be attacking into an endlessly increasing field of magma none of which is Akainu's actual body.
lol
This DPR system that has always existed here is good and all, but it has led to a place where people really underestimate strategy in a fight.
Trust me, you being level 80 and having multiple 121+ stats obviously means you overcommitted to those stats (and you're very powerful in those specific stats), but it creates a weakness elsewhere, as just shown.
With your complete lack of COO, you wouldn't even be able to beat Pica atm the way Zoro beat him (even though Pica is a weak ass xD). Pica would just endlessly hide in stone all over the island while hunting you down with spikes of stone. All you could really do is just stalemate by floating somewhere high up in the air and out of any range of stone. xD