[FIN] Traditional Mafia The Gang Plays Mafia [Mafia Championship Practice]

[tedxtr]

Rej why are you town reading Michelle again?

 

[Gambit]

it's quite interesting how the wagon is in transition. I wanna see how it progresses. We got time..

 

[Onadaga]

then i am gonna say, that it's either you're not familiar with my way of speech or you simply derail yourself from your 6 or 7 so years of experience in reading people.. it's not always the experience but the manner in which you approach it. you told us that you approach the game to win, but with a fail read on someone holds you back from winning.. and yet it will you guys an information. so go on.

i keep coming back to thinking that the emotions here are pure and towny, idk. its hard to tell

does gambit fake emotions/frustration often as scum?

 

[Dragomir]

true it doesn't

when i saw the posts at the page where you post that meme of that person and said "man, rej is town this game" that made me feel like you're town. just the energy u give off. but then as i kept reading and let it marinate i decided that i still don't like your one-liner questions of which i dont immediately see your conclusion, i felt as if that could be scum trying to appear busy
[automerge]1587048231[/automerge]

i dont think its very townie of a person to ask one-liner question and be satisfied with responses that make him just feel "this is ok"

dont take this as an attack on you (if you're town), thats not what i mean

overall this whole thing is minor (imo) and could be a large playstyle difference

It's not exactly a difference in playstyle. Their responses I simply thought were ok and fine. They didn't ping me as bad so I didn't question any further about the topic.

RAINBOW


Rej
tedxtr
Michelle
Dragomir
Stray Cat
Beky
Onadaga
Nessos
Gambit
Juliet
joby
Poison Chan
Oreki
Samael

Trafalgar Law

I feel like somewhere setting here, where blue represents the towncore, while I don't see myself as the most proactive player, but damn, this is just my own info kapoapapp

It means everyone whos is green coloured might be able to shift redish, but for me personally I would lock 4 people town.
Maybe it is just uber metafeeling because I also use to play with Mich, ted and Poison in a community.
Hence why I am not townreading Poison yet and she has to gain her speed and input as hypothetial town. Dunno if it is just wishthinking but I like playing with her nevertheless.

Samael had a weird posts here I really want him to be revisitted this DP, also by others and we need him to give more input.
In the recent pages I miss Oreki being more deductive and taking less the backseat. Oreki is a player who likes to grasp opportunities and chase them, maybe that is what I miss.
@Oreki come join the read list fun and maybe I will change your placement.


Interesting list, I personally question your reads in those three and would wish some more thoughts about them, what do you mean with "meh"? Why is Sam good? What about Poison do you like? And what about Oreki do you dislike?


Also yes my rainbow is a more detailled GTH read list with multiple brackets. Red equals Dragos "bad" and blue equals Dragos "great".
(Statement is aimed at others, who ask themselves what is going on here rn )

That rainbow looking clean af with all those colors.

Ted is meh based on his Nessos posts. I didn't like them. He mainly just defended Nessos and never truly explained the town read that he had on him. It's hard to explain why I find this all to be bad but simply put, it pinged me and made me remove my town read from him.

Oreki is not doing anything of productiveness and I hate it. He's not putting that much effort into trying to solve the game. Also, his scum read on Nessos reads very fake.

@Dragomir Because of these interactions... I think nessos putting unnecessary pressure on Michelle... it was sudden, uncalled and there was nothing wrong with sudden reads... felt like he was trying to find slip to just take his own chance

The post feels awkward and it comes off pretty forced. It makes me think scum buddy trying to bus. The read just really does not look real at all.

About Poison, her posts look genuine to me. She's trying with what she's got and feels like a innocent townie to me.

 

[Onadaga]

or well more specifically does he fake them well?

 

[Beky]

does gambit fake emotions/frustration often as scum?

I honestly can't say. He most plays as town xd

The Game - The Hall of Fame

Welcome to The Hall of Fame! Credit to @Dragomir for the Banner, and The Syndicate for the name and formatting idea This thread is a compilation of the records for all the games played on Thriller Bark. You can find in it your stats as a player on TB across all the sub-sections, as well as...

thrillerbark.com

 

[Dragomir]

Oh, forgot about Samael. I put him as good for the mindmeld I had with his post on Ted. I liked and agreed with what he said.

 

[tedxtr]

Oh, forgot about Samael. I put him as good for the mindmeld I had with his post on Ted. I liked and agreed with what he said.

Have you read my case on him at all? Does it make you move the needle on him in any way?

 

[Dragomir]

Ona, how about you vote Samael with me? Rej, you could vote as well.

After having briefly skimmed Nessos' town game I no longer feel confident in my previous town lean, although I still feel bad about the lynch somehow.

Expand on this.

 

[Dragomir]

Have you read my case on him at all? Does it make you move the needle on him in any way?

Yeah, I did. And nope it didn't.

 

[Rej]

Rej why are you town reading Michelle again?

She is never a lynch worth D1, going with that mindset in she has a solid Day One performance, approaches different people, doesn't shy back to ask questions and go deeper with persons. She is solid AF.
Except you can convince me with some of her micro play.

 

[Oreki]

Oreki is not doing anything of productiveness and I hate it. He's not putting that much effort into trying to solve the game. Also, his scum read on Nessos reads very fake.

It's not fake just lack real substance... though I would welcome you to point out your doubts on me

 

[Dragomir]

i keep coming back to thinking that the emotions here are pure and towny, idk. its hard to tell

does gambit fake emotions/frustration often as scum?

You seem to be on the fence a lot with your reads and aren't very clear. Tell me, what is it? Gambit town or wolf?

 

[Dragomir]

It's not fake just lack real substance... though I would welcome you to point out your doubts on me

Lacking real substance points to it being fake my guy.

 

[Gambit]

i keep coming back to thinking that the emotions here are pure and towny, idk. its hard to tell

does gambit fake emotions/frustration often as scum?

I love faking emotions; Man, I honestly don't put emotion into the game LOL. I am logical BUT kinda playful. You'd see where did will go. I honestly think that we have already fashioned a lot of reactions at this point.. And it's pretty circumstantial that once you voted me off, there goes a subtle vibration of wolves peddling lynches to the heart of town. I wanna keep them going..

 

[Dragomir]

It pretty much means that you just forced the read and don't have anything to actually suspect the man for. Hence not genuine and fake.

 

[Oreki]

Lacking real substance points to it being fake my guy.

When I said real substance what i meant there is not a long explanation but I said still what I am gonna said if I even were to give you long essay on that

 

[Dragomir]

When I said real substance what i meant there is not a long explanation but I said still what I am gonna said if I even were to give you long essay on that

Give me the long explanation.

 

[Beky]

Idk Oreki just seems sleepy to me. He doesn't try like you would expect from a scum player to gain some cred.
And i don't think being passive is viable scum tactic in this game

 

[Onadaga]

I apologize in advance if this makes Dragomir feel alienated/annoyed, not my intention

I just feel as if he wasn't very transparent with this thought process from his earlier posts. He said "I love this, lock town" and "I hate this" on 2 separate occasions and that's all he expressed on the first page of his ISO, at least I didn't see anything else.

The other stuff were questions which you could argue that he just asked in order to push the game forward, that's fair but you could also argue it's scum that's trying to sneak into things and appear busy.

I feel as if he just changed his tone to make more effort to be expressive of what HE thinks, and after being called out for not doing that, I think it's scummy

The post feels awkward and it comes off pretty forced. It makes me think scum buddy trying to bus. The read just really does not look real at all.

About Poison, her posts look genuine to me. She's trying with what she's got and feels like a innocent townie to me.

Oh, forgot about Samael. I put him as good for the mindmeld I had with his post on Ted. I liked and agreed with what he said.

If you ISO him, you will see that his posting style from earlier is making statements "This is scummy; This is wrong" whereas now it's emphasis on "I think this is scummy; I think this is wrong"

I fully realize this whole thing could very well be very very dumb and that he's town. Sorry in advance if so