[FIN] Traditional Mafia Round 4 - Crazy Noisy Bizarre Town

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302


Actually I'd say novas is the most active in first phases of games.
I wouldn't be surprised if I got some names confused. I called someone named "PocketGod" "ChickenPost" for a while before corrected.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rej
Messages
198
Reaction score
215
Points
1,050
Salty Doubloons
302
There was, the snarky tone of something that appears to be a simple remark on what the discussion was about. And the sarcastic "noted" lol.
What I means is that I wad pretty overt there. I don't think that I was subtle at all.

It doesn't read that way, it feels like you're highjacking it to establish a position there and enabling him but at the same time being reluctant. It doesn't feel like you ultimately reject is what I mean, the second phrase feels more like a side note. Also speaking about the discussion being too common, I don't think that means it is not worth anything. It's how someone approach something/their behavior that is relevant to figuring out their alignment rather than the discussion itself most of the time. Expand on what you "tentatively agreed" with, and those players.
I'm "reluctant" because while it does seem like a scum move to fit in, it happens far too often to be a reliable.

Yep, that's me.
Hm.
 
Messages
3,336
Reaction score
10,079
Points
9,000
Salty Doubloons
1,061
I wouldn't be surprised if I got some names confused. I called someone named "PocketGod" "ChickenPost" for a while before corrected.
Sir Pocketgod Chickenpost. Sounds very british. :pikachu:
 

novaselinenever

Best Dad!
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
3,995
Points
5,300
Salty Doubloons
19,359
What I means is that I wad pretty overt there. I don't think that I was subtle at all.
If you say so, fair enough I guess.
I'm "reluctant" because while it does seem like a scum move to fit in, it happens far too often to be a reliable.
Which one is a scum move? Talking about it, or engaging in the convo?
Lol shouldn't you be happy?
 

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
What do you mean?
That's true, pretty much lost my interest for this forum so I wasn't that active, I'll try to change that.
@novaselinenever if you doesn't know what playful means, then there is google

@Dragon D. Luffy, I gave my everything to give credible reads which are not consisting of any bullshit or bias and telling my stance to the people and how they entered. I don't need to justify your wrong suspicion on me. You have to properly elaborate on why I am scummy and on why my reads could be random. I believe every read from myself.



Since I just recently was scum with DDL I will give him the townpass, even if he tries to fuck on me :dogkek:
[automerge]1581259054[/automerge]
Why didn't we just start with N1 ?
Cuz this is no Reg/ToS, this is real mafia.

^this would have been the correct answer :pepeking:

Salah imho looks rly confused and helpless = town
[automerge]1581259107[/automerge]
Rej is both trolling & acting helpful so yeah i can see the suspicion there
Dunno about Historian
please quote where I was trolling, me simply adding an emoji to a post can't be considered trolling
 

Beky

Nancy <3
Messages
2,944
Reaction score
6,339
Points
6,350
Salty Doubloons
3,704
This doesn't feel natural. I don't like how you're highjacking someone's else observation, it feels like forced banter to continue it and put a vote on the board after questioning the quick votes.
Most of quick votes i've seen were baseless. Just to get a reaction from someone.

Meanwhile your set up comment is an actual vote i did not.to test a reaction but as a serious vote.

Most of the times when i see a player talking about set up is bcs he wants to talk about something that makes sense, just enough to make him flow above the radar. Yea sure knowing set up can be good but trying to guess it this early makes no sense cause hosts can do wild stuff. Yea ofc in 20 player game 4 to 5 mafia is optimal, most know it, why say it... say it to flow a bit above radar

And i was drinking yesterday, woke up hangover and didnt noticr her post right away
 

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
hmm i'm sus of lurkers, but still aware some people have time zone. It's the one that are on around this time that are to quite!
adding Naomi to my town PoE, I doubt scum Naomi takes such a quick stance in the game
 

novaselinenever

Best Dad!
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
3,995
Points
5,300
Salty Doubloons
19,359
@novaselinenever if you doesn't know what playful means, then there is google
In relation with your read and expectation of him.
Most of quick votes i've seen were baseless. Just to get a reaction from someone.

Meanwhile your set up comment is an actual vote i did not.to test a reaction but as a serious vote.

Most of the times when i see a player talking about set up is bcs he wants to talk about something that makes sense, just enough to make him flow above the radar. Yea sure knowing set up can be good but trying to guess it this early makes no sense cause hosts can do wild stuff. Yea ofc in 20 player game 4 to 5 mafia is optimal, most know it, why say it... say it to flow a bit above radar

And i was drinking yesterday, woke up hangover and didnt noticr her post right away
Hosts being able to do wild stuff doesn't mean one can't discuss and theorize about the setup, like that makes no sense. It's exactly because of it that you should theorize and try to figure stuff out. The "make flow above the radar" is an extremely cheap way to have some bland reasoning to suspect someone. It feels like basic level suspicion so I don't feel it's genuine. It's also dishonest af especially since I'm not hiding behind mechanical talk to fake contribution so I'm not sure where "flow a bit above the radar" can be applied here. It's a very helpful post to have as an anchor, and it's also about my experience with Drago and knowing him as a host since I mentioned his indie affection and his tendencies as host that would have the original 19 players setup be just a +1 townie with the addition of a 20th post.

As for my comment about the banter, the post was formatted and clearly have a bantery feel to it. That's what I was referring to. I don't like that tone since it's used to soften it. As for the vote itself, it can be serious sure but the reasoning given is extremely cheap and feels dishonest since it doesn't reflect reality at all. It's like "hurr durr he spoke about the setup, he's using mechanical talk to fake contribution". That's bullshit fam lol.
 

novaselinenever

Best Dad!
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
3,995
Points
5,300
Salty Doubloons
19,359
What's the difference?
Your "tentatively agree" marks a difference. Salah is the one that started the conversation, and he concluded that people were engaging in the convo to fake contribution. You agreed with him, so which is it? Especially in this case with the players behavior since you agree with Salah, and I have thoughts there as well.
You bring me PTSD from my latest N1 vigging.
I think Oko did you favor with that lol, you'd have been the talk of D2.
 

Rej

Messages
5,048
Reaction score
13,185
Points
14,950
Salty Doubloons
108,741
In relation with your read and expectation of him.
A playful Waindo is showing a bigger presence, his words have a bigger impact on certain individuals, may it be trolling, taunting or whatever, he doesn't do it here. Often both town or scum Waindo tend to be that playful, but I saw it more with town Wai tbh. Scum Wai might be more caring in the end. He admitted he changed his gamestyle which is quite obvious, it's not the first game I play with him where he changed his playstyle.
It fits with what Waindo said that he isn't much into mafia recently, he can't project his energy into the game as he did previously.
[automerge]1581260682[/automerge]
If @Waindo gives me some nice reads then I think I will be able to PoE him, hopefully as town
 

novaselinenever

Best Dad!
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
3,995
Points
5,300
Salty Doubloons
19,359
adding Naomi to my town PoE, I doubt scum Naomi takes such a quick stance in the game
Salah imho looks rly confused and helpless = town
We're vibing way too much, you're giving me the heebie jeebies lol. You town my brother? :pepewhy:
A playful Waindo is showing a bigger presence, his words have a bigger impact on certain individuals, may it be trolling, taunting or whatever, he doesn't do it here. Often both town or scum Waindo tend to be that playful, but I saw it more with town Wai tbh. Scum Wai might be more caring in the end. He admitted he changed his gamestyle which is quite obvious, it's not the first game I play with him where he changed his playstyle.
It fits with what Waindo said that he isn't much into mafia recently, he can't project his energy into the game as he did previously.
Hmmm fair enough. He's got good points from me for the D1 is useless talk and his negative energy around it, feels like genuine frustration.
 
Messages
3,336
Reaction score
10,079
Points
9,000
Salty Doubloons
1,061
I mean playful could be one of the words to describe me, I've been watching a guy doing song covers on electric toothbrushes for the past hour or so.

How could I give you any coherent reads in this chaos tho? :pepethinking:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom