Traditional Mafia Game Round 9 - Knives Out

[Salah Eddine]

I still prefer a discussing and that we go with the 3 the majority of player wants to have as Observer.

What would be your picks right now?

Votes are Private whether you like it or not
These discussions will only serve to check Players opinions which is cool, but don't expect that they are gonna Vote for the same Players they said they would here, Scum obviously can lie & even Town can lie if they deem it necessary

I already told you, i voted for same Players i chose as Suspects, You & Rej & Juliet
I want both Observer & Observed to be Suspects in case we catch 2 Scums (Well that depends on how Trials happen really, still waiting to see them to finally map a Strategy for this Game)
[automerge]1596904726[/automerge]

Did you read anything at all to come to that conclusion? You might not like over analysing but you know you should still do analysis before placing votes? At least Interact with them?

I don't recall saying that i didn't read
And i didn't say Over-Analyzing is bad, most Players here know that i love Analyzing, i just meant that doing this before we finally see how DP works could cause Confusion more than it benefits

 

[Nessos]

Why is my name in there! +??

Cause I not only Townread you , but also think you are a player who makes reasonable decisions.

 

[Poison Chan]

I think I would read the opening cause I'm getting confused why observe and suspect should be same/different isk what's everyone saying..
[automerge]1596904804[/automerge]

Cause I not only Townread you , but also think you are a player who makes reasonable decisions.

And since when you are town reading me? Also are you town reading juliet?
[automerge]1596904961[/automerge]

I don't recall saying that i didn't read
And i didn't say Over-Analyzing is bad, most Players here know that i love Analyzing, i just meant that doing this before we finally see how DP works could cause Confusion more than it benefits

I love fluffing myself but given others inputs and stuff I think digging a bit won't be bad. So you read and found them scummy. Did you provide with a reason? I'm still catching up though.

 

[Nessos]

I think I would read the opening cause I'm getting confused why observe and suspect should be same/different isk what's everyone saying..

As I mentioned

• Everyone votes 3 who thinks they are town in private for observer
• Everyone votes 3 as potential lynch targets

Observer choose who gets lynched among top suspects.

If I get the tactic of @Salah Eddine its Vote the same as Observers as you voted suspects. So suspects and Observer end up being the same.
Would cause a funny battle.
But I also see the +5 Points for every observer, which I want to see in Towns Hand and Not get directly wasted.
[automerge]1596905120[/automerge]

Scum obviously can lie & even Town can lie if they deem it necessary

Sure scum could lie, but Town would Most likely follow the majority. This scum would have less power in choosing one of the observer.

I do not want pointless witchhunting of observer next DP.

 

[Poison Chan]

As I mentioned

• Everyone votes 3 who thinks they are town in private for observer
• Everyone votes 3 as potential lynch targets

Observer choose who gets lynched among top suspects.

If I get the tactic of @Salah Eddine its Vote the same as Observers as you voted suspects. So suspects and Observer end up being the same.
Would cause a funny battle.
But I also see the +5 Points for every observer, which I want to see in Towns Hand and Not get directly wasted.
[automerge]1596905120[/automerge]

Sure scum could lie, but Town would Most likely follow the majority. This scum would have less power in choosing one of the observer.

I do not want pointless witchhunting of observer next DP.

I understood the first part you said. But sarah 's post got me confused. So she wants some fun is it?

 

[Dragomir]

Unvote Juliet
Change Vote Rej

Why are you voting for Rej?

 

[Rej]

Nessos and Drago look like they are solving and I haven't gotten any scum pings from them and there was one post from Nessos I liked. Gambit I am sus of for not answering me and the empty naked votes he did. Beky hasn't done much and I'm getting a coasting vibe from him.

What do you think of the other players? I also did not like how Salah votes the most active players just to see how the trial works. If I recall correctly Trustworthy said they will sheep Gambit and that was also pretty scummy because town players should develop their own reads and not sheep other players otherwise players will just assume they are scum who is just following players hoping not to get caught. I am also concerned about the other players who haven't posted much and this starts to make me wonder there could be some scum who wants to watch players point fingers at each other. I have alot of suspects on my list.

thats the kind of posts I like from you,
some people have yet to be active, I think Salah didn't give any reads? he just asked some questions
I don't know about odd, I expect more but I don't like how odd snowballed as scum candidate, this is often done by scum to catch a good player offguard and have them wagonized, I am observing this

Poison Chan is okay

Pepper made some good posts, he is a good reflection of himself this game

I expect more from Ratchet/RailGun, sadly he isnt here to play so almost like a dead slot for now.

I will have to ISO Beky, haven't care much about him for now, I should revisit

Larsi and Waindo are MIA, tho I found Larsi a bit off, not really contributive for now
[automerge]1596905641[/automerge]
Hayumi is annoying, sheeping votes, can't see anything town there for now.
[automerge]1596905734[/automerge]
actually the recent posts of Salah are feeling better

 

[Nessos]

I understood the first part you said. But sarah 's post got me confused. So she wants some fun is it?

Not really want to have fun more like finding a strange was of solving the game.

 

[Dragomir]

Unvote Rej
Vote Hayumi

Hayu needs to die for his vote on Rej.

 

[Salah Eddine]

I love fluffing myself but given others inputs and stuff I think digging a bit won't be bad. So you read and found them scummy. Did you provide with a reason? I'm still catching up though.

I don't see the difference between this DP1 & an Evening Phase and personally i never ever participate in Evening Phases
This first Half of DP1 only require us to choose 3 Players to be Suspects & 3 to be Observers
It's like this is an Evening Phase & the Host is asking us for Initial Metareads

No one have solid Arguments for suspecting or trusting anyone unless i see a Day Action or Claim
So obviously our Choices will be based mostly on Metareads & Feelings
The Game officially starts during Trial Phase which is still DP1 btw

The Movie starts with Interrogations too & every Character was Suspicious to be honest and had motives to be the Villain (Aside from that Youngster, Old Woman, Maid & Detectives ofc)

Shortly after that we learn that the Main Detective of the Story (Daniel Craig) was Hired by Unknown Person (Which i believe what gave Inspiration to this Mechanic of Private Votes of Observer)

The Villain is the one who Hired the Detective if i recall, so don't expect that voting for Best Townie is the right answer to this, expect Plot Twists here & Scum with Abilities & Wincons that perhaps rely on these Votes

This is another reason why i wanted to start by Voting for same Suspects as Observers too, because i want to check this Scenario of Two Suspects interacting before we get to NP1 & more complications happen

 

[Dragomir]

Vote Hayu
Vote Beky
Vote Odd

 

[Salah Eddine]

I understood the first part you said. But sarah 's post got me confused. So she wants some fun is it?

How am i a "She"? Who is Sarah?

 

[Beky]

I actually read Rej as scummier tha you.

I'm catch up but if you didn't explain why so can you do it?

 

[Beky]

You're going to have to elaborate on that. You can't just say entrance is scummy since that can be a good excuse for scum to say I find your entrance scummy.

True i agree with this. IMO its not good look for gambit

Kinda scummy I guess. What do u think of Juliet?

Again not explaining why

 

[Nessos]

I don't see the difference between this DP1 & an Evening Phase and personally i never ever participate in Evening Phases

Tue big difference between Evening Phase and Day Phase before first Night is that one Player will get lynched.

D1 can reveal a lot. There is no need to dogde it.

 

[Beky]

Yes, there is. Confirming his role pm just means that he knew the game was gonna start soon, not when it'll start. So it's natural that he'd put it off the side while waiting and evidently forgot about it. I'm not sure how this is a slip. The example you provided is a different due to the fact that players turned in their actions the night before. Nobody did that here.

It's entirely possible for a townie to have a forgotten about the game start.

Quote them and tell me what's wrong with them.

I'm not even gonna try to read your posts with that disgusting colour on em lmao

Poison lock town.

Oh no here we go again

vote lynch Gambit
vote lynch Hayumi
vote lynch Nessos

Gambit is self explanatory.
Hayumi is following the wave without messing with it
Nessos bcs i don't get the Town MVP desire from his this game. He isn't the one to be outshined but he is by several people

dark horse - Odd

Observers

Juliet
Alice
Dragomir

vote lynch Gambit
vote lynch Hayumi
vote lynch Nessos

Gambit is self explanatory.
Hayumi is following the wave without messing with it
Nessos bcs i don't get the Town MVP desire from his this game. He isn't the one to be outshined but he is by several people

dark horse - Odd

Observers

Juliet
Alice
Dragomir

@Oreki

Also add Pepper to dark horse list

 

[Trustworthy Liberal]

Since it starts stocking, I would Like to hear everyones opinion which 3 they think are the best for Observer right now. (No selfnomination)

Right now my picks would be

• Drago
• Poison
• Juliet

I will do the counting.

Spoiler: tags

1. @Nessos
2. @Poison Chan
3. @Gambit
4. @Pepper
5. @RAIL_GUN
6. @Beky
7. @Alice The Menace
8. @Rej
9. @Juliet
10. @Fallen Prince
11. @Hayumi
12. @Larsi
13. @oddoddfruit
14. @Trustworthy Liberal
15. @Waindo
16. @Salah Eddine

Ah let's see for observer
I am going with this is trusted people so I would say Rej, Gambit, Poison

Likes the posts of Poison I have seen.
Rej and Gambit is just because.

Really the people we chose let us learn more information about the yes?

 

[Gambit]

Ah let's see for observer
I am going with this is trusted people so I would say Rej, Gambit, Poison

Likes the posts of Poison I have seen.
Rej and Gambit is just because.

Really the people we chose let us learn more information about the yes?

Just because what?

 

[Trustworthy Liberal]

Also Drag

Okay so i vote my three top suspects then instead of one is this mode from how i gather
[automerge]1596854288[/automerge]
First note a way to disable the special font's like the one above?
Cause they actually hurt my eyes trying to read it
[automerge]1596854824[/automerge]
Tempted to sheep Gambit cause of Rem and cause i think they are different then the last game i played with them and they were scum there so...

This is why

 

[Hayumi]

I’m in 3 other games atm in two other forums. So yah I’m kind of just going with the flow for my Rej and Beky vote. I don’t have any real personal susses apart from Alice. I think Nessos is town so far. And not much has even happened at this point to base votes off of.