- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 556
- Points
- 1,500
- Salty Doubloons
- 212
that sounds really easyyy!Just put me and Salah and someone else as Observers today and together we will vote off whoever Salah wants. Easy
First, that's not defending it's simply pointing out why and where you are going wrong, if I don't correct you won't be having a clear mind about me or anyother player, including Rej and Jo.Dunno why you're defending here? i didn't accuse you of being the villain at all, i actually pointed that out to explain that if my idea is right regarding Rej/Joby's Role then they are looking for the Villain & you're not that Villain, i only said that i will look more into it
But even if we assume i suspected you, your argument here is lacking, how would you know that by revealing someone contacted you, you can be seen as the Villain if you haven't watched the movie? From your perspective, even if you're the Villain, you wouldn't know such detail.
Your defense was from my perspective as someone who watched the movie, not yours so it doesn't stand
Either way, as i said, i'm not suspecting you, i just pointed out what i think Players should be aware of
Especially if they try to contact someone else
here, by asking him to prove his towniness I definitely do not encourage him to claim, as I quoted before, I'm specifically against all these claims specially when it is that early in the game, and I am pretty clear about it all the while.Here you're encouraging him that instead of pushing for Nessos Lynch (Which was not a bad thing to do at all) he should instead prove he is Town, the guy was obviously left with no choice but to Claim, since one of the Observers is a Suspect with him so he will definitely vote for him & the second Observer is siding with him. When he finally does claim, this is what you say:
what was the right option you say, I don't know that myself, cause if I knew that I would have been a perfect player, but anyways I'll tell you what I expected a town to act in that scenario, he could have justified his votes and reads in a convincing manner, he should have questioned the observer more as to why he is scummy , he was rather laid back and his posts seemed like he was rather expecting it and , and the way was okay with his lynch instead of arguing or how he acted basically, it all seemed like an outed scum who cannot help but get lynched. additionally, I do not expect town to push for another lynch instead of questioning the other available slot. He was more like "Nessos must be lynched".What is the right option to defend himself if not claiming when three observers want him lynched? It was Trial Phase, it was too late, it's only him & Hayumi there, even if he was Jailor or whatever this game mode have of important roles, he was forced to claim by you guys
And when does a Suspect not posting enough makes him not worthy of a lynch? if an inactive player isn't among three suspects then cool, players simply ignored him, but if an inactive player is among three top suspects then town definitely suspect him and his inactivity is a factor for sure, unless they have invisible posts i didn't notice
I'm more suspicious of Drago, i just pointed these two occurrences to say that you are a potential suspect but not yet
There is no need to defend any further and just to add one final thing, if you didn't take one claim spot yesterday (where you only revealed little info) both Beky & Nessos would have claimed so please don't rush to take claim spots
From now on, anyone who takes claim spot and doesn't reveal very important info, i will push for their vote as suspects so that during Trials, we will have 2 claims to choose from
You think my claim didn't give much information when you just mentioned a bit above that the villain and contacting people is likely scenario according to the movie. I shortened and gave you 3 names. how is that any less? besides, what would claiming one's role as town is more important [when most people won't even trust and work according to the claim, as we could see for beky's case] than listing 3 names among which we can get a scum?
Anyways, I think I explained everything and it won't be giving more info from that, cause I know I am town and he was town and by the looks of it i am pretty sure Nessos was town as well. So this argument is pointless, and I would be looking at the other stuffs now.
and here I wanted to be carried for once