gambit-chwan, I am telling you, u r barking up the wrong tree
If Wai is mafia and Hatz is mafia how come Wai is throwing his mate under the buss?
or both are town or one is scum and the other town. Would be very bad play if they where both mafia....
Plot twist, there's no scum. lol. That's what Aries would do.If Wai is mafia and Hatz is mafia how come Wai is throwing his mate under the buss?
Now your post is making more sense. Still we don't know the whole story I don't believe we should jump on this. I am not saying if there is another copy that other cop should claim. But is to risky going after a cop claim.
Hahahaha who is Aries?
Ok I see hahahaha
Did I say they're both maf smhIf Wai is mafia and Hatz is mafia how come Wai is throwing his mate under the buss?
Kibi tell me how it can't be a slip? Alongside of claim he telling there can be more than one cop... have you ever seen two cops in the game like that because I haven't
Kibi aren't you jumping on the gun to fast here? Did I vote for him? Did I stop considering his case? There can only be two reasons for him to say that someone else might claim the cop, either he thinks the game can have another cop alongside of him as multiple ToS invest roles or he was expecting someone to counterclaim him cuz his claim is not real
Okay let me go out of my way to tell you this, do you seriously expect that 12 players game can have two cops because hatz was implying that... and do you seriously don't want a real cop to counterclaim hatz if he's speaking lies? Make a sense out of your post before writing them
How many cops do you expect in the game of 13 players? There can't be more than 1 cop if there's more than one cop then it should be role like odd day and even day cop, not an actual cop... he expecting his role to get counterclaim only meaning it's fake.
About that Joby, it's rolemadness game and in rolemadness, there can't be vanilla town
There's no point in arguing about the setup. Only host knows this. And yes, having 2 role cops in this setup may be feasible if there are other roles who may contradict and deter such roles. Think outside the box before saying that I don't make sense with my post.
Why are u so certain that there may be no more than 1 cop? Why do I feel like you wanna out all the cops for the sake of reduction?
I thinking outside of the box and going by this logic... there can't be more than one cop in the setup of 13. But the point I still haven't voted hatz because no one counterclaimed and when I asked that question to hatz it was to confirm why assumed that someone might counterclaim, was he thinking with newbie thoughts or he was expecting it.
Cuz I have played way many games and never seen more than 1 cop in the game of less 15 players. Plus it's gonna be unbalanced game because it will make town too strong
It was Kibi who said about rules not me and I only said slip when you were expecting someone to counterclaim you
I don't like to use the noob card but I already told joby how experienced I am with trad.
[automerge]1569912748[/automerge]
Sorry
It means, you were expecting another cop because you're not aware of traditional mafia setups if that was not the case then I don't see any point expecting someone to counterclaim you
This is trad and we don't have much time left.
If you see no point then how you have a scum read on me.
You should ask these question players who are voting for you, not to me who haven't voted you yet and actually asking a question to confirm the curiosity
I still think 2 cops in the setup is sensible.
You're okay with Vanilla town claim in rolemadness?
No, it's not... I am going by the experience here and two cops only make sense when it's even and odd night cops. Don't expect me to go out of my way to defend you just because no one counterclaimed you, its something you have to do it yourself
Don't boast in front of me about the number of games you played. It is to be accounted for that rhis ain't an ordinary setup. Semi-Open games usually mask a game with an unusual setup, often featuring uncommon role interactions or multiple copies of the same role. You mentioned that this a role madness game, so why do u bitch too much on the plausibility of 2 cops? The veracity of one's claim may not be determined by a counterclaim if in case that 2 of them are valid ones. Remember that we need to be careful with our claims because there are consequences. Those consequences not only lie on the scum's night options but also on the players who wouldn't grasp the whole scenario.